997v996 - an old story revisited.
997v996 - an old story revisited.
Author
Discussion

Raven Flyer

Original Poster:

1,645 posts

255 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
An old topic, but my first true comparison.

I've got a 996 C4 and am having 3 days in a 997 vanilla 2.

Its got sat nav, xenons, PSE, heated seats and park assist (none of which would be on my spec list) and (thank the lord) its manual.

Initial thoughts...

1) People say the C4s understeer. I have never found this but OMG 997s do. In a solid 4 wheel drift, the 997 nose runs very wide and needs permanent correction.

3) The dash is great, nice colours, loads of info, great.

4) 2WD will never match 4WD out of a corner. I've read loads of stuff about the 2WD versions being a more natural feel and a better car... its all boocks. When you are coming out of a slow second gear corner and nail it, the 4WD gets up the road, the 2WD consults its operating system. At speeds and gears beyond light up, they are the same.

5) the 997 suspension feels softer but isn't. Its superb. The rates are better and the handling is informative and controlled. 10/10. The 996 is 9/10, feeling a bit harder to do the same stuff.


Oh, I forgot 2)... It understeers so badly.

Its hard not to boot out of a drift without having far too much lock on, all the wrong way. In the drift, with a trailing throttle, the nose is running straight or wide. It should be tucking in. Was it designed for the US market?

Its only my second day in it, so maybe I need more time. But at the moment, I am not convinced.

A 2S, with more weight at the back, may be a whole different script.

flattotheboards

6,689 posts

237 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Raven Flyer said:
Its got sat nav, xenons, PSE, heated seats and park assist (none of which would be on my spec list)
why wouldnt you want any of these?

Raven Flyer

Original Poster:

1,645 posts

255 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Correction... I would have PSE, in fact it makes the car.

If you need bleeping sounds to park, you really shouldn't be buying a Porsche. Sat nav really doesn't bother me and as I can't find out how you turn the brightness down, the screen is a distraction at night.

I can see someone living in central London wanting all of these extras.

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
The understeer of the 997 (and all 911's for that matter) is easily handled if you ensure to have weight on the nose when entering the turn. Then it is amazingly balanced with the rear end helping to tighten the radius. You might want to give it more the beans and see how the handling changes

9hellheaven

1,595 posts

240 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Just press the brightness button on the top right. Easy!

wilnick

5 posts

229 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
You are telling me a C2 or C2S 997 understeers. Me thinks you may need some driver training.

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Where on earth are you driving it to be able to indulge in four wheel drifts etc? confused

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Where on earth are you driving it to be able to indulge in four wheel drifts etc? confused

Koln-RS

4,129 posts

243 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
wilnick said:
You are telling me a C2 or C2S 997 understeers. Me thinks you may need some driver training.
That may be true.

Although it is natural for all 911s to understeer (due to the rear weight bias), it shouldn't be particularly noticeable in a standard 997 unless there is a fault with the car/tyres, or the driving technique.

Remember, Clarkson complained that the Elise S2 had too much understeer and the Lotus instructor blamed his heavy handed driving style. The Elise and 2wd 911s both benefit from a delicate touch and turn-in better with some braking weight over the front (not to be confused with lift-off oversteer).

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Should have tried a 987 if you want to experience the 2WD Porsche experience at it's best. wink


Retires to a safe distance and checks sand bucket is at hand.

Raven Flyer

Original Poster:

1,645 posts

255 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
I have well over 100 track days under my belt and several advanced driving courses. I am aware of how to overcome an understeer tendency but my point is that the 997 seems to have more of this tendaency than the 996.

I've had a look at the tyres since last night and the 997 has wider fronts. I wonder if this is the reason.

Ted... the roads are cold, wet and greasy around here. Some familiar, large, quiet roundabouts are all that is needed to explore these qualities in safety.

The brightness button seemed to turn the whole display off, but to be honest I was concentrating on other things so may have not used it correctly.

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Raven Flyer said:
I've had a look at the tyres since last night and the 997 has wider fronts. I wonder if this is the reason.
Wider fronts normally reduce understeer, by providing more front end grip.

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Koln-RS said:
Remember, Clarkson complained that the Elise S2 had too much understeer and the Lotus instructor blamed his heavy handed driving style.
The Elise S2 did have too much understeer. (hence why they fitted wider fronts on the Exige and 111R). Sure you can drive round it as the Lotus chap did, but it doesn't make the setup right...

Pugsey

5,821 posts

245 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Terminal understeer on "cold wet and greasy roundabouts" makes it sound as if you're being far to timid to reveal the car's genuine on limit handling characteristics. As someone else has already said some more beans may be required.... Most mass produced cars have understeer built in to their handling somewhere the idea being that Mr Average bumps into this safely and that's as far as he goes. After sussing their own car (in this case a 997) out most decent drivers will drive round, past and beyond this trait so automatically that they will cease to notice it exists. IMHO. I've seen poor drivers induce horrendous understeer in cars I didn't think capable of it! Not suggesting this applies to OP of course.smile

Bumcrack

977 posts

296 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
wilnick said:
You are telling me a C2 or C2S 997 understeers. Me thinks you may need some driver training.
Agree

wilnick

5 posts

229 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
You must take this car by the horns and not bottle out of the corner. If you feather it around it will understeer.

Pugsey

5,821 posts

245 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
wilnick said:
You must take this car by the horns and not bottle out of the corner. If you feather it around it will understeer.
yes




Wetwipe

3,019 posts

244 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
The Griffalo said:
Should have tried a 987 if you want to experience the 2WD Porsche experience at it's best. wink


Retires to a safe distance and checks sand bucket is at hand.
no need to retire to a safe distance. we all know the 987 is the best handling Porsche ever made

Grey Ghost

4,611 posts

251 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Wait until January when the Cayman has had it's first service and warranty renewed and make me an offer biggrin

No understeer there.....at least not at my driving ability hehe

Koln-RS

4,129 posts

243 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
Raven Flyer said:
I have well over 100 track days under my belt and several advanced driving courses.
That's one heck of a lot of track days - equivalent to one a month, virtually every month, for the last 10 years.

Can't be many people who have done that.