993 oil choice
Author
Discussion

gary11

Original Poster:

4,163 posts

232 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
any one any thoughts on oil choice for a 96 993 tt,ive always used mobil 1 on my previous normaly aspirated 993s ive had 5 with no problem,however people have reccomended castrol for the turbo,i have gone with millers racing oil so will see how it goes,
gary

sbrewster

113 posts

263 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
I use Castrol Magnatec in my 993 C2S.

That's what Northway's recommended when I bought it, and I've been using it ever since.

Apparently the thinner fully synth oils like Mobil 1 can sometimes exascerbate any minor oil leaks (if you have any).

I do an oil change every 6k miles and the Magnatec looks surprisingly well when it's drained.

Haven't tried anything else, but I'm happy with the Castrol.

Obviously don't know if it's contributing to wear by not using fully synth, only time will tell.

Si

gary11

Original Poster:

4,163 posts

232 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
thanks for the reply,ive changed my oil to millers and now have a leak from rh turbo,bin advised there is a revised oil feed apparently the turbo syphons oil when engine is turned off but i think it may be too thin or coincidence who knows?
cheers again.
......will wait and see

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

254 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
mobil one on a 993

phelix

4,684 posts

280 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Mobil 1 MS 15/50

tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
I use Silkolene Pro S 5W-40 as recommended by opieoilman in the oil advice thread.

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
tertius said:
I use Silkolene Pro S 5W-40 as recommended by opieoilman in the oil advice thread.
Same here. No other reason then it was advised by opieoilman as the best available and also I track my car several times a year. I've got a garage full f it now as I bought in bulk.

pp

paultje

1,042 posts

270 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
phelix said:
Mobil 1 MS 15/50
I think this is sensible....Mobil 1, but a higher viscosity...less likely to leak.

gary11

Original Poster:

4,163 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
thanks chaps

SunDiver

780 posts

268 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
15W Mobile 1 - Recommended to me by the chaps at Tognola Engineering - seems the thicker 15w oil is less likely to leak and helps somewhat with the 993TT smoke-on-startup issues...Although I'm also interested in those modified turbo lines with a check valve...

ACEparts_com

3,724 posts

272 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
I usually use mobil 1 0-40 in the winter and 15-50 in the summer but as I pay less than £3 a litre for it I tend change it as often as my pants.

FWIW, I'm currently running 0-40 and noticed that the right hand turbo is peeing oil out making it forunate that I have upgraded ones sailing across from the states right now.

gary11

Original Poster:

4,163 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
ok same as mine ,where did you get turbos,i may upgrade at same time seems silly not to,i missed some gt2 ones on usa ebay recently cheap too never mind,what model have you,be interested in your costings, due to the dollar us is probably cheapest,will advise ofmy quote its not going in till 13th nov,will probably lay her up till then gutted,
gary

phelix

4,684 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
With regard to oil siphoning through the turbos...

Because the turbos are at a low point on the engine some oil will siphon out of the engine. People on rennlist are militant that you must use genuine Porsche-supplied filters (not Mahle branded ones) and that they must not be overtightened. Hand tightened half a turn after the gasket makes contact seems ot be the consensus.

I recently had my oil changed and Castrol 5/40 put in. The car smoked like an army tank on start up if it sat for more than a few minutes. I removed the turbo sump plugs and allowed the oil to drain out. Out of one of the sumps a further 2 litres drained out over 2 days! The root cause was an over-tightened oil filter (genuine Porsche) which broke the anti-siphon valve within the filter. A new Porsche filter and Mobil 1 15/50 and all's well. (The offending indie, who I won't name, has agreed to credit me for the oil change next time round.) In my opinion the over-tightened filter caused 98% of the problem; I went with the 15/50 as I am happier with that in the 993tt engine from all of the material I've read. I know Porsche recommends a lighter weight now but they didn't when the car was first introduced.

There are various companies that sell anti-siphon valve kits using the very same valves Porsche fitted to the 996 but unless that puff of smoke bothers you I would bother. I fitted them to my car and they're a sod to fit and it's a sod to ensure there's no seepage.

But all just my opinion.

gary11

Original Poster:

4,163 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
hi phelix i did think it was something to do with the oil change as she was perfect till then excellent reply,ive only been on ph for a week am a motortrader myself,and am amazed at the wealth of info on here,i have personaly owned 5 993s and loved everyone had a riviera blue rs replica that i loved was never going to sell till the turbo came up! i wouldve been gutted if the turbos were up for renewal,i will drain the oil as you suggest did you leave it to stand for a while with the plugs out,i suppose i should fit two new filters also will make sure i get proper pork ones cheers again
gary

phelix

4,684 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
Beware that if the filter is the problem oil will continually drain from the turbo sumps until the filter is replaced. Or the tank runs dry.

Even once you've done the filter change and drained the sumps it will take some time to burn off the oil.

neilski

2,563 posts

266 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
Pickled Piper said:
tertius said:
I use Silkolene Pro S 5W-40 as recommended by opieoilman in the oil advice thread.
Same here. No other reason then it was advised by opieoilman as the best available and also I track my car several times a year. I've got a garage full f it now as I bought in bulk.

pp
Another vote for Pro S here as well. Loads of good info in the Opie Oil thread.

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
sbrewster said:
Apparently the thinner fully synth oils like Mobil 1 can sometimes exascerbate any minor oil leaks (if you have any).
Synthetic oil is NOT 'thinner'.

The SAE rating gives the exact viscosity at 100 degrees C.
A 10w40 mineral oil at engine temps (80-90 degrees C) will have the same thickness as a 0w40 synthetic, together with less shear strength, and less lubricating qualities. Mineral 10w40 oil is SAE 10 oil with coiled polymers (plastic) that makes it 40SAE when hot. When the polymers leave (as varnish coating your engine usually) the base SAE10 takes over. Yes, old mineral 10w40 can come out of the sump as SAE10 and lumps of plastic left in the engine.

What _actually_ happens with engine seeps and leaks is that at cold temperature the synthetic oil IS thinner, because it is a better multigrade. This helps is get round quickly on start-up and saves fuel as it pumps more easily, but is also has the effect of not congealing around seep points when cold.

Synthetic oil has a more constant viscosity over a temperature range (an intrinsic quality) which helps the engine but not cold leaks. Mineral oil gets thicker when cold - just about it's only 'benefit' (besides price). At running temperature SAE40 is SAE40, saying synthetic is 'thinner' is equivalent to saying that SAE40 is not SAE40!!

In a 993 I'd use a decent PAO synth such as Mobil1, and accept the odd cold-standing weep as a small price to pay for no varnish, better lubrication, easier winter starting and high shear strength protecting the engine much better. There is a reason Porsche use synthetic in their new cars.
It's because it is a much much better oil.

gary11

Original Poster:

4,163 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
very interesting ive heard good things about millers its supposed to be a good racing oil especially for the turbo engines its got three esters you know!! whatever that means,i think i may go back to mobil one though porsche specify shell or castrol I think my one has been run on shell from new judging by its history and "porsche recommend shell stickers" on intercooler,thanks all for the advice
gary

graeme36s

7,230 posts

248 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi Gary,
I too would stick to Mobil 1 15W/50 MS grade. 964's particularly can suffer with oil leaks using 0W/40 and 993's I would not think are any better.

dev bhamra

23 posts

234 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Seems I use something different from everyone on here...Shell Helix Plus 10w40 as recommended by the guys who serviced the car before I bought it.

Dev