944 Inspection-
Author
Discussion

Julesd

Original Poster:

10 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Just had a 944 inspected for me to buy, the conclusion is below. Can any one:

1. Give my an idea of the cost of sorting out the problems.
2. Say how important the lack of service history is.
3. Make any other comment.

Inspection Summary.
This is a 1991 model (as shown by the ‘M’ at the tenth digit of the Vehicle identification Number and the third digit
of the engine number) 211bhp 944 S2 Cabriolet finished in blue with a black interior.
After I had documented this vehicle’s service history the vendor informed me that the engine was replaced with a
second hand unit said to have covered 70,000 miles. This renders all of the service history useless as the history of
the replacement engine is not known.
The bonnet and front bumper have been replaced with second hand red items and the original red paint is visible
under the blue top coat.
Oil leakage was seen from the power steering pump and right hand drive shaft. Emulsified oil in filler cap. Bolts missing from air flow meter bracket
This vehicle could not be road tested as the clutch flexi pipe was insecure and fouling the steering column. As this
item is situated close to the exhaust manifold there would have been a great risk of fire if the flexi hose had
become trapped and ruptured. It is possible that further defects could be present that only a road test would
highlight.
Inspecting this vehicle’s documentation shows that it has had 12 previous keepers. If you were to go ahead and
purchase this vehicle you would become the (unlucky?) 13th owner.
The fact that this vehicle has had 12 previous keepers is enough for me to advise you NOT to purchase and that’s
leaving aside the list of defects that require attention.



Nurburglover

76 posts

243 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
So how much is it?
Have to say that number of keepers doesn't matter a jot on one of these. If the car had 20 owners. Thats still less than one a year & if they all spent a grand+ on it then it would be in good condition.
Lack of service history at least for the engine could be serious. A rebuild would be over 4K. Oil in the water may mean the oil water heat exchanger needs replacing. Or the head gaskets gone. If it's been like that a while then the main bearings could be dead. You won't know until it's too late.
As to the mileage. I've never seen replacement engine from the scrappers with more than 60/70K miles.
More like 160/170k or they wouldn't be scrapped!
You should work on worst case senario. Even if everything was good you should have a contingency fund of not less than £1500 to cover the unexpected. (New clutch is a grand fitted for one of these.)
You can look for a better one. Good ones from as little as 6K now. There great cars when sorted. Try & find one on either Tipec or Porshce GB with known history. Could save you lots in the long run.
Good luck!

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
No. of owners is entirely irrelevant, and absolutely no basis whatsoever to base a purchase decision on on a 15+ year old car.

If this looks like a nice car you'd like to take things further with, then why not get the owner to have the clutch pipe secured - should be a dead easy job and he should want to have it done anyway if it makes the car dangerous - then get it road tested too. If seller won't get that (dangerous) item done, then maybe he's not the kind of guy you want to buy a car from?

If road test shows nothing untoward then go into buying it on the basis that the engine may need cams & chain sometime soon (£1000 - £1500?). If it doesn't then you're in luck - that's what buying any car is - a game of luck.

Julesd

Original Poster:

10 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
The car is currently going for £6995.

As for looking around, I've my heart set on a cabio, but there don't seem to be too many about! Indeed down here in London, this one is one of only 2 I've found within 100 miles!

I'll see if the vendor will sort out the clutch pipe. Lack of history on the engine is a worry, as I don't want the whole thing to fall apart on me in the next 6 months, with a 4K rebuild bill!!

Nurburglover

76 posts

243 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Julsed. What's wrong with traveling. I went 250 miles to get mine! Love it to bits! & it's not a cab but the sunroof comes out like a targa & goes in the boot (a lux.) There are good cabs out there if you look. (Nice one for £5K at Graves end on pistonheads right now.)
Another thing. Mileage is unimportant if they have been well maintained. (Mine had a full rebuild at 140K miles, cost 4.5K but not by me!)
This one may be ok but it sounds like the engine hasn't been fitted with care. So what else is wrong with it??? Bet they didn't bother to put a new clutch in when they fitted the engine!
It's way over price for what it is anyway. You have been warned.


Edited by Nurburglover on Saturday 27th October 20:35

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
£6995?

Is that a typo?????

They are not a rare car, particularly at that price, if it were a turbo cab then maybe it would be about the right money, but for an s2 cab it is at the top end of the price range. It sounds like a lemon of the highest order, leave well alone. However the number of owners doesn't matter.

I was looking for one, I didn't want to spend as much as you, and I saw several cars that were a lot more honest than the one you describe. Get on ebay, PH classifieds, Autotrader, there are plenty.

Julesd

Original Poster:

10 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanx for all the comments so far!!!

No really worried about a long haul to find a car, but not much time to myself with work at the moment, am I am car less at the moment!! I went to Newcastle for my last car, a Tuscan (fun but finiky!!).

Like a fool I didn't even look on the classifieds on here!!! Some interesting prospects, Glasgow might get a visit!!

Forthose who know, is the turbo really worth the extra money? The additional power is welcome, although its not all about that!! I've heard they can be more troublesome?

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
As I understand it the turbo is more reliable strangely, mainly due to it being single cam I suppose.

The blue cab in glasgow owned by a chap called ken was on my list, but after doing 3k miles in 1 week looking at cabs and turbo's I couldn't face scotland. He sent me a lot of pics, and to be honest it looks good. The interior is immaculate.

tr7v8

7,628 posts

259 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Personally I'd give it a miss, it sounds too cheap to be good anyway. However number of owners wouldn't worry me, mine has had 3 personal regs in it's life & each one triggered the owner count. Also Porsches tend to be a buy it for the experience then find other things come up so get sold on reasonably quickly. 944 Cabs are fairly rare so you'll have to be prepared to travel to get a good one. I'd put a wanted ad here & also ring round the specialists, they may know of one coming up in the near future.
As for history long ago it's completely irrelavent. The important history is what has happened in the past couple of years & even with it, I'd still want a service & the belts changed. Also on an S2 the chain & it's tensioners sorted as well.

JED944

12 posts

233 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
I've got s 944 S2 (91 on a 'J').... 108,000 miles.

It's been well cared for rather than pampered with a good history. The previous owner was a top bloke and a real Porsche enthusiast who made sure the essentials were done.

I've had it about 10 months. One of the first things I did was get to take it to Hartech to get the top of the engine looked at. You'll bear in mind that I reckon mine has been looked after. I wanted them to take a look at the Cam Sprockets as well as the chain and belt. There are no publihed wear rates for these, but the guys at Hartech, who've done alot of their own research and homework, reckoned the sprockets were about at their limits so I had the cams changed. This along with belts and a 24,000 mile service, set me back nearly £2,000. It's bought me peace of mind which is beyond price. Incidentally, my engine dyno'd at 212bhp and a bit more than factory quoted torque slightly higher up the rev range.

Other things that need doing are the brakes.... lift plate problem which is common on 944's. The rear calipers need changing along with the brake pipes. With some other odds and sods, I'm looking at another £1,200 prior to its next MOT.

If you're running something this old, you've got to be budgeting for maintenance so I'm far from complaining... but it's easy to spend about £1.5k to £2k a year even on a good example.

Anyone disagree?

Vishal Jadeja

7 posts

229 months

Sunday 28th October 2007
quotequote all
I agree!! 100% Live the Dream!!

I have had my Porsche 944 S2 1990 Model and she has had many Previous Owener and has covered 170,000 miles. I looked around the market and through Piston Heads test drove a fair few cars all over the country. Finally I drove this one and also looked closely at the service history and the owner. The history showed me that she had covered all her miles early, and has been owned by Porsche Club ownes every since who under the classic policy only ran her 3000 miles each and have all spent about 3K each in maintaing her. Cam belt and rollers are the ones to look out for you have to make sure they are changed on time or you in for trouble. I have just bought Uprated braks and pads for the front and back and she runs like a dream. Still have a few Minor Problems but then lets face it we all knew that when we bought one. The Joy is to enjoy the Journey into Porsche and get information and try and fix things at home if possible. Thats the Funn and a Great Project. Have also joined the Porsche Club GB and have got a lot of Tech Support and help. At the end of the day tell me have you ever seen any Sports Car look so good and stand out like any modern day Car for this price??
I think NOT!! She may be 17 Years old but she is a beauty...... So enjoy the Ride and Stop Weeping its all part of owning a classic!! I drive mine every day cause that half the funn!! Enjoy it...
One Day she might be worth a Fortune!!

Julesd

Original Poster:

10 posts

229 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanxs all for all comments, have started a S2 vs Turbo forum link if anyone can advise!