944S2 vs 944 Turbo
Discussion
Both good cars, When buying it's condition that counts. Not mileage, Not number of keepers. Just condition. If you keep an open mind & look at plenty. Join Tipec & go to the local meets & try them.
(Thought you wanted a Cab'???) Have to say that the 2.5s are very under rated though. Absolute bargain at the moment. Properly set up plenty fast enough for road use. If you read the road tests (Just google.) It was the lux they liked the best on the road. It's how much you want to spend. Given 7K I would go for a turbo. Less then I'l stick with my lux. Good S2's like hens teeth. You might be lucky & find one. But keep an open mind!
(Thought you wanted a Cab'???) Have to say that the 2.5s are very under rated though. Absolute bargain at the moment. Properly set up plenty fast enough for road use. If you read the road tests (Just google.) It was the lux they liked the best on the road. It's how much you want to spend. Given 7K I would go for a turbo. Less then I'l stick with my lux. Good S2's like hens teeth. You might be lucky & find one. But keep an open mind!
Biggest problem you will find is down to supply when new. This means that your chances of finding a nice S2 are much higher then a nice turbo. When I was looking 7 years ago (far fewer dogs then) I really wanted a late turbo possibly M030 but struggled to find any nice ones at reasonable money whilst back then plenty of nice S2's around, so I got a S2 and don't regret it. Nowadays your chances of finding either a nice S2 or turbo with good history are much lower because there is a lot of shite out there, hence S2's on ebay for 3K that probably need 3K or 4K spending on them to make a decent car.
It is surprising how different the 2 cars can feel, although it is much less so if you put different suspension on a S2 for track use. As an example I took this guy out on the track in my S2 and he noted straight away how the engine is always revving hard compared to the turbo which seems much less frenetic on the track due to the wide powerband and high torque output. This is because compared to a late turbo the gearing in the s2 is much lower so on the track you are always buzzing through 3rd and 4th (60-80 in third then into 4th). This means that to go even moderately quick on the track in a S2 it feels like you are ragging the thing to death which I quite like.
If you track either car it is likely you will end up replacing the shocks and springs, very few turbos had adjustable koni suspension (m030) from new contrary to popular belief so don't hold out for a 944 with that option, however the late turbo does benefit from an LSD and larger brakes on the front.
On the road the S2 always feels slower then it is (0-100 mph in sub 15s, 150 mph top end) because of the smooth progressive power supply and short gears, whereas a late turbo feels even quicker then it is because of how long 3rd gear lasts considering that at only half way up the rev range the torque kicks you into the seat.
Drive both because some ppl find the turbo lag very off putting compared to modern turbo cars, whereas others may find the lack of a big kick into the seat in an S2 off putting.
It is surprising how different the 2 cars can feel, although it is much less so if you put different suspension on a S2 for track use. As an example I took this guy out on the track in my S2 and he noted straight away how the engine is always revving hard compared to the turbo which seems much less frenetic on the track due to the wide powerband and high torque output. This is because compared to a late turbo the gearing in the s2 is much lower so on the track you are always buzzing through 3rd and 4th (60-80 in third then into 4th). This means that to go even moderately quick on the track in a S2 it feels like you are ragging the thing to death which I quite like.
If you track either car it is likely you will end up replacing the shocks and springs, very few turbos had adjustable koni suspension (m030) from new contrary to popular belief so don't hold out for a 944 with that option, however the late turbo does benefit from an LSD and larger brakes on the front.
On the road the S2 always feels slower then it is (0-100 mph in sub 15s, 150 mph top end) because of the smooth progressive power supply and short gears, whereas a late turbo feels even quicker then it is because of how long 3rd gear lasts considering that at only half way up the rev range the torque kicks you into the seat.
Drive both because some ppl find the turbo lag very off putting compared to modern turbo cars, whereas others may find the lack of a big kick into the seat in an S2 off putting.
Forgot to say that after being around 944's for 7 years etc. etc. IMHO there is practically no difference in terms of long term running costs, reliability, maintenance etc, I believe the turbo is very marginally more costly but nothing like as great as some ppl think so don't let this factor colour your decision. The only difference is that if you do a lot of miles you can get away with just a 10k or 12k service on the S2, whereas the turbo must have 6k oil changes. In reality most ppl these days are not doing 12k miles a year in their 944 so a yearly service in either car is much the same.
JulesD, blatant ad coming up! My 944 Turbo is now regretfully for sale, due to impending house purchase. Its a 1988 250 with LSD & big brakes. I've owned it a year. Just 42K miles and believed genuine. The car was imported from Germany as a damaged car & re-shelled into a RHD shell in 1998 by PH Sportscars of Shardlow and then spent 5 1/2 years in storage (hence low mileage). PH Sportscars will verify all of this. Its my 4th car so, again, hasn't done much work bar 5 track days, which it has taken in its stride. Its recently been serviced; its had all the belts & rollers changed. Braided brake hoses have been fitted. Sports leather seats, 968CS steering wheel & rear bench. No relaibility issues in my ownership. Send me an e-mail or PM me if you are interested - I'm based near Donington Park/ East Midlands Airport.
Edited by andy97 on Tuesday 30th October 07:57
[quote=andy97]JulesD, blatant ad coming up! My 944 Turbo is now regretfully for sale, due to impending house purchase. Its a 1988 250 with LSD & big brakes. I've owned it a year. Just 42K miles and believed genuine. The car was imported from Germany as a damaged car & re-shelled into a RHD shell in 1998 by PH Sportscars of Shardlow and then spent 5 1/2 years in storage (hence low mileage). PH Sportscars will verify all of this. Its my 4th car so, again, hasn't done much work bar 5 track days, which it has taken in its stride. Its recently been serviced; its had all the belts & rollers changed. Braided brake hoses have been fitted. Sports leather seats, 968CS steering wheel & rear bench. No relaibility issues in my ownership. Send me an e-mail or PM me if you are interested - I'm based near Donington Park/ East Midlands Airport.
You've got mail.
You've got mail.
I had a lovely '90 model turbo with the M030 suspension option in the late 90's. Lovely car,handling top notch and when on boost, the performance was spectacular. The only negative aspect from my point of view was the rather uninspiring engine note.
The great thing with the turbo is that you can easily get the power up to 300BHP for very little money. Have never driven an S2 but some prefer these as the 944T is very much old school turbo ie masses of turbo lag.
Geoff
The great thing with the turbo is that you can easily get the power up to 300BHP for very little money. Have never driven an S2 but some prefer these as the 944T is very much old school turbo ie masses of turbo lag.
Geoff
porschegeoff said:
The great thing with the turbo is that you can easily get the power up to 300BHP for very little money. Have never driven an S2 but some prefer these as the 944T is very much old school turbo ie masses of turbo lag.
Geoff
Spot on. I've got an '89 Turbo, M030 suspension, 968 castor mounts, new ARB bushes all round, 4 wheel geometry setup and about 290BHP. Lovely handling and stupid grins from the One.... Two.... Three... BANG! 1980's turbo delivery :0 (just be careful in the wet)Geoff
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



