Can I have your opinions please ?
Discussion
I am still debating the 911 Vs M3. I have around £30K to spend and whilst my head says go with the newer M3, my heart says buy this:
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/241999.htm
I had a chat with Damien at RSJ and I must say he seemed a pleasant enough chap, he ceratinly didn't try to force this car down my throat.
I know I need a porsche warranty for it, but does this give me the same rights as if I was buying it from the Porsche network ?
Also, would it still be worth getting an inspection on it (Peter Morgan or other) ?
The reason I was going with a BMW AUC was for piece of mind, but if a porsche warranty is as good as a Porsche AUC then maybe the 911 is the route to go.
If I go with a 911 it has to be in Seal Grey with black leather, it really sets the car off IMHO.
Any help greatly appreciated.
Thanks
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/241999.htm
I had a chat with Damien at RSJ and I must say he seemed a pleasant enough chap, he ceratinly didn't try to force this car down my throat.
I know I need a porsche warranty for it, but does this give me the same rights as if I was buying it from the Porsche network ?
Also, would it still be worth getting an inspection on it (Peter Morgan or other) ?
The reason I was going with a BMW AUC was for piece of mind, but if a porsche warranty is as good as a Porsche AUC then maybe the 911 is the route to go.
If I go with a 911 it has to be in Seal Grey with black leather, it really sets the car off IMHO.
Any help greatly appreciated.
Thanks
You'd have to get the car inspected (111 point check) - about £250 and then assuming it passes buy the Porsche warranty at £895 per year - no difference if you'd bought from Porsche themselves. This compares to about £1,800 per year for a BMW warranty for an M3.
The Porsche warranty is very similar to the BMW one (I've blown two E46 M3 engines so speaking from experience) and is very comprehensive. If it breaks they replace it, if it wears out you pay for it.
I've had three M3s and now two 997s - I'd go Porsche every time.
However, not wanting to set off the usual debate, go for a manual (the tip is crap!!).
Cheers
The Porsche warranty is very similar to the BMW one (I've blown two E46 M3 engines so speaking from experience) and is very comprehensive. If it breaks they replace it, if it wears out you pay for it.
I've had three M3s and now two 997s - I'd go Porsche every time.
However, not wanting to set off the usual debate, go for a manual (the tip is crap!!).
Cheers
I bought a similar age/mileage car from RSJ a few months back. They handled the 111 point check/warranty with Porsche and agreed to fix anything that came up. I've been very happy with the car since.
Also, I sold my last 996 to them earlier this year, seeing how thoroughly they checked the car over I had loads of confidence in them when buying the latest one.
Cheers
Also, I sold my last 996 to them earlier this year, seeing how thoroughly they checked the car over I had loads of confidence in them when buying the latest one.
Cheers
RSJ are good.
If the tip is what you want then go for it. I dont think this car has a sound pack, not sure how important that is to you.
As for the M3 v 996 debate, they are both awesome cars. With a BMW for me its a bit naff that a large percentage of what your in could also be a part of a 316i.
If the tip is what you want then go for it. I dont think this car has a sound pack, not sure how important that is to you.
As for the M3 v 996 debate, they are both awesome cars. With a BMW for me its a bit naff that a large percentage of what your in could also be a part of a 316i.
drfrank said:
Any help greatly appreciated.
buy my car:http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/274567.htm
HTH,
BERGS

drfrank said:
I am still debating the 911 Vs M3. I have around £30K to spend and whilst my head says go with the newer M3, my heart says buy this:
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/241999.htm
I had a chat with Damien at RSJ and I must say he seemed a pleasant enough chap, he ceratinly didn't try to force this car down my throat.
I know I need a porsche warranty for it, but does this give me the same rights as if I was buying it from the Porsche network ?
Also, would it still be worth getting an inspection on it (Peter Morgan or other) ?
£30K will buy you a very decent 996 spec. Having now got the Pork, I can honestly tell you that any excuse to get in it will do. It's a totally addictive experience that will have you planning all sorts of trips abroad etc, etc. I know I would never feel the same about a beamer, great though they are.
But for godsake get the warranty and, if needs be, shoot a couple grand lower down the price range to ensure you get it. One mishap or misfortune will see you recover the value straight off.
The reason I was going with a BMW AUC was for piece of mind, but if a porsche warranty is as good as a Porsche AUC then maybe the 911 is the route to go.
If I go with a 911 it has to be in Seal Grey with black leather, it really sets the car off IMHO.
Any help greatly appreciated.
Thanks
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/241999.htm
I had a chat with Damien at RSJ and I must say he seemed a pleasant enough chap, he ceratinly didn't try to force this car down my throat.
I know I need a porsche warranty for it, but does this give me the same rights as if I was buying it from the Porsche network ?
Also, would it still be worth getting an inspection on it (Peter Morgan or other) ?
£30K will buy you a very decent 996 spec. Having now got the Pork, I can honestly tell you that any excuse to get in it will do. It's a totally addictive experience that will have you planning all sorts of trips abroad etc, etc. I know I would never feel the same about a beamer, great though they are.
But for godsake get the warranty and, if needs be, shoot a couple grand lower down the price range to ensure you get it. One mishap or misfortune will see you recover the value straight off.
The reason I was going with a BMW AUC was for piece of mind, but if a porsche warranty is as good as a Porsche AUC then maybe the 911 is the route to go.
If I go with a 911 it has to be in Seal Grey with black leather, it really sets the car off IMHO.
Any help greatly appreciated.
Thanks
HisJoelness at rsj is a straight guy to deal with.
buy a good facelift car and you will not be disapointed BUT make sure you drive the tip to ensure it is the driving experience you are looking for
and seal grey with black leather is defo the colour to go for. I sold my c2 in this spec to joel earlier in the year. if i could have afforded to keep it alongside its replacement i would have. it was ace
buy a good facelift car and you will not be disapointed BUT make sure you drive the tip to ensure it is the driving experience you are looking for
and seal grey with black leather is defo the colour to go for. I sold my c2 in this spec to joel earlier in the year. if i could have afforded to keep it alongside its replacement i would have. it was ace
I've had a lot of automatics and I was extremely disappointed in the tip when I drove a 911 from autobahn. I'm afraid to say it really was sh*t and detracted from what was a great car.
I don't know what other people have found, but when I put my foot down in other automatics when at cruising speed the result was almost instant acceleration, I bizzarely felt a 1-2 second delay in this 911 which felt like a lifetime when driving.
Somehow I had high expectations of a tip, but it really was shocking. Maybe it was me, but I would definately going manual now.
The only way to know though is to drive both for yourself.
I don't know what other people have found, but when I put my foot down in other automatics when at cruising speed the result was almost instant acceleration, I bizzarely felt a 1-2 second delay in this 911 which felt like a lifetime when driving.
Somehow I had high expectations of a tip, but it really was shocking. Maybe it was me, but I would definately going manual now.
The only way to know though is to drive both for yourself.
Edited by petrolhead76 on Monday 29th October 21:13
No worries with RSJ, which is where I bought my car from. Joel, Damien and Andy are all great. They arranged the warranty directly with Porsche and corrected anything that was wrong before I took delivery. (In my case this was an airflow mass sensor (or whatever it's called!). As a rule RSJ don't let you drive the cars before purchase....which could be unnerving to some.
Good luck.
Rgds, Brin
Good luck.
Rgds, Brin
Thanks for the advice !
The 996 posted above is nice, however what on god's earth are those alloys !! They surely have sent the price tag down by a couple of grand ? hideous absolutely hideous...
Also, I will need some finance on any car I buy, can I go to a third party finance house which would obviously facilitate purchasing privately or will such places only allow you to buy from dealers ?
Thanks again
The 996 posted above is nice, however what on god's earth are those alloys !! They surely have sent the price tag down by a couple of grand ? hideous absolutely hideous...
Also, I will need some finance on any car I buy, can I go to a third party finance house which would obviously facilitate purchasing privately or will such places only allow you to buy from dealers ?
Thanks again
Have you considered the M3CSL?
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/261875.htm
Or the Z4M Coupe?
911 is nice, Tiptronic is a must if you are disabled, if not manual!
CSL would be my choice.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/261875.htm
Or the Z4M Coupe?
911 is nice, Tiptronic is a must if you are disabled, if not manual!
CSL would be my choice.
A few have mentioned the CSL but I like my creature comforts. I admit I have never been in one but I think its probably a little 'hardcore' for what I would use it for, basically commuting and weekend enjoyment. I have no ambition to track either a CSL or 911 so I really want something a little more refined than the CSL
drfrank said:
A few have mentioned the CSL but I like my creature comforts. I admit I have never been in one but I think its probably a little 'hardcore' for what I would use it for, basically commuting and weekend enjoyment. I have no ambition to track either a CSL or 911 so I really want something a little more refined than the CSL
A 911 is special...the brand, the image, the drive, the elegance, the look.I've had an M3 and I driven a fair few 911s now - the 911 is top draw and would win hands down for me - but then I do love the porsche brand and the 911 was a dream car for me when I was younger.
The only thing to consider is the M3 does have two decent seats in the back if you have kiddies who may have outgrown the 911 !!!
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






