Cayman S drive
Discussion
I took a Cayman S out last Sat courtesy of my local OPC. It’s on a shortlist of 3 with which to replace my 993, if and when I decide to do it. But that’s another story…
First off the door shut with a satisfying ‘thud’. It makes mine sound like you’re closing the lid on a tin of Fox’s biscuits, the likes of which you only see at Xmas time. The interior was tip-top, certainly functional and with a high-quality feel. I don’t go for the 993 ‘hewn from granite’ bullshit but certainly things have developed since the early 90s and I must admit to liking that modern feel.
The engine started with a pleasing growl and settled into a low gurgle. I must admit I was really pleasantly surprised, I had expected it to be somewhat quieter. Ok, it’s not feral like the 993, but they’ve got it right nevertheless.
Before I was allowed to drive the OPC man then proceeded to demonstrate the finer points of the car’s handling. This involved some very fast cornering and an absurdly impressive demo of 2 laps of a small, dry roundabout in 3rd / ca. 45mph. When I got the keys I also tried the same. Wow, what balance, what poise; it just felt ever so chuckable, a bit like a go-cart. The gears slotted in with rifle-bolt accuracy. Acceleration and low-range torque was what I was looking for, and it didn’t disappoint. The heritage was present in the engine and exhaust sounds and it felt very much like a great place to be.
I then got back in the 993 and did the same route. OK, so I missed out the roundabout but as cheesy as it sounds, when you get it right in the 993 it just brings a smile to your face, which I don’t think the Cayman can replicate. This may not be peculiar to just the 993, but possibly applies to all Porsche rear-engined cars Get it wrong though and it’s a dog’s dinner as the weight at the back makes its presence felt.
So, 1 down and 3 to go. I can’t say if I like the Cayman S more - I certainly would need to have it a bit longer and drive the routes I know well from the 993. What I can say was that I walked away very impressed and wished I could afford to run both!
First off the door shut with a satisfying ‘thud’. It makes mine sound like you’re closing the lid on a tin of Fox’s biscuits, the likes of which you only see at Xmas time. The interior was tip-top, certainly functional and with a high-quality feel. I don’t go for the 993 ‘hewn from granite’ bullshit but certainly things have developed since the early 90s and I must admit to liking that modern feel.
The engine started with a pleasing growl and settled into a low gurgle. I must admit I was really pleasantly surprised, I had expected it to be somewhat quieter. Ok, it’s not feral like the 993, but they’ve got it right nevertheless.
Before I was allowed to drive the OPC man then proceeded to demonstrate the finer points of the car’s handling. This involved some very fast cornering and an absurdly impressive demo of 2 laps of a small, dry roundabout in 3rd / ca. 45mph. When I got the keys I also tried the same. Wow, what balance, what poise; it just felt ever so chuckable, a bit like a go-cart. The gears slotted in with rifle-bolt accuracy. Acceleration and low-range torque was what I was looking for, and it didn’t disappoint. The heritage was present in the engine and exhaust sounds and it felt very much like a great place to be.
I then got back in the 993 and did the same route. OK, so I missed out the roundabout but as cheesy as it sounds, when you get it right in the 993 it just brings a smile to your face, which I don’t think the Cayman can replicate. This may not be peculiar to just the 993, but possibly applies to all Porsche rear-engined cars Get it wrong though and it’s a dog’s dinner as the weight at the back makes its presence felt.
So, 1 down and 3 to go. I can’t say if I like the Cayman S more - I certainly would need to have it a bit longer and drive the routes I know well from the 993. What I can say was that I walked away very impressed and wished I could afford to run both!
What else are you test driving?
BMW Z4 M Coupe's are tremendous value at the moment(2007 cars under 6k for between £30-£33k). I bought one over a Cayman S.
Im not saying its the better car, but when you take into account value for money, it really cannot be ignored. It also has bags of character. Lots people compare them to TVR's.
BMW Z4 M Coupe's are tremendous value at the moment(2007 cars under 6k for between £30-£33k). I bought one over a Cayman S.
Im not saying its the better car, but when you take into account value for money, it really cannot be ignored. It also has bags of character. Lots people compare them to TVR's.
Great little write up. Coming from a Z4M, it's the CaymanS all day long for me and if money isn't an issue for you then Autocar's Handling Car AND Autocar's Car of the year 2006/2007 has to be the one for you. Get one for a weekend. I was dubious, like you, at first and told the dealer as much so i got their demo from Saturday morning through to Monday morning. It was this that changed my mind and was therefore worth thier while. Besides, what better way to razz someone elses car for the weekend
.
I met up with some mates at the weekend and swapped for an hour with my mates M. Honestly, within 5 minutes i couldn't wait to get out of it. IMHO, the CS is a much better car in all respects and definitely worth paying the extra for.
What other cars have you got on your list? If you do get a CS make sure you get PASM, Chrono, 19s and Shortshift. All these end up giving you the best driving experience. Good luck.
.I met up with some mates at the weekend and swapped for an hour with my mates M. Honestly, within 5 minutes i couldn't wait to get out of it. IMHO, the CS is a much better car in all respects and definitely worth paying the extra for.
What other cars have you got on your list? If you do get a CS make sure you get PASM, Chrono, 19s and Shortshift. All these end up giving you the best driving experience. Good luck.
Edited by K Man S on Tuesday 30th October 21:03
Other options are 996TT and a Z4MC. I'll try the Z4MC next. I agree that it represents excellent value for money and am keen to see how it handles compared to both the 993 and Cayman S. I'll probably find the TT too scary. The car is only used as a means to switch off from work / family etc.
Also, just come in from 1.5 hour spin in the 993. It certainly does bring a smile to your face!
Also, just come in from 1.5 hour spin in the 993. It certainly does bring a smile to your face!
Interesting comments.
I found that the Cayman S was a league (a few actually) above the BMW in the handling stakes. There's a sense of purity and balance that is lacking in its Deutche cousin. The 996TT never appealed to me - obviously not a bad car but more of a mile muncher than a handler - in my humble opinion of course.
Which leads me to.....
My Cayman S is ready for delivery next week after waiting since April - shame I have to postpone it for another weeks thanks to the palava of selling cars here in Dubai!
I found that the Cayman S was a league (a few actually) above the BMW in the handling stakes. There's a sense of purity and balance that is lacking in its Deutche cousin. The 996TT never appealed to me - obviously not a bad car but more of a mile muncher than a handler - in my humble opinion of course.
Which leads me to.....
My Cayman S is ready for delivery next week after waiting since April - shame I have to postpone it for another weeks thanks to the palava of selling cars here in Dubai!
Asterix said:
Interesting comments.
I found that the Cayman S was a league (a few actually) above the BMW in the handling stakes. There's a sense of purity and balance that is lacking in its Deutche cousin. The 996TT never appealed to me - obviously not a bad car but more of a mile muncher than a handler - in my humble opinion of course.
Which leads me to.....
My Cayman S is ready for delivery next week after waiting since April - shame I have to postpone it for another weeks thanks to the palava of selling cars here in Dubai!
Fair play, to compare a 996tt with a Cayman s is bloody ridiculous ..the tt is a competitor for all but the very top supercars..the cayman s is scrapping it out with m3's,exiges and rs4's..the 996tt would leave a Cayman s for dead in any situation..speed,handling,practicality,street cred etc..wake up chaps the Cayman s is a good car but lets be realistic.I found that the Cayman S was a league (a few actually) above the BMW in the handling stakes. There's a sense of purity and balance that is lacking in its Deutche cousin. The 996TT never appealed to me - obviously not a bad car but more of a mile muncher than a handler - in my humble opinion of course.
Which leads me to.....
My Cayman S is ready for delivery next week after waiting since April - shame I have to postpone it for another weeks thanks to the palava of selling cars here in Dubai!
kayc said:
Asterix said:
Interesting comments.
I found that the Cayman S was a league (a few actually) above the BMW in the handling stakes. There's a sense of purity and balance that is lacking in its Deutche cousin. The 996TT never appealed to me - obviously not a bad car but more of a mile muncher than a handler - in my humble opinion of course.
Which leads me to.....
My Cayman S is ready for delivery next week after waiting since April - shame I have to postpone it for another weeks thanks to the palava of selling cars here in Dubai!
Fair play, to compare a 996tt with a Cayman s is bloody ridiculous ..the tt is a competitor for all but the very top supercars..the cayman s is scrapping it out with m3's,exiges and rs4's..the 996tt would leave a Cayman s for dead in any situation..speed,handling,practicality,street cred etc..wake up chaps the Cayman s is a good car but lets be realistic.I found that the Cayman S was a league (a few actually) above the BMW in the handling stakes. There's a sense of purity and balance that is lacking in its Deutche cousin. The 996TT never appealed to me - obviously not a bad car but more of a mile muncher than a handler - in my humble opinion of course.
Which leads me to.....
My Cayman S is ready for delivery next week after waiting since April - shame I have to postpone it for another weeks thanks to the palava of selling cars here in Dubai!
Credibility? Only worried about by those who's opinion I'd probably ignore anyway.
Speed and practicality, although the latter point is very much relative, I can't argue with.
ism123 said:
I took a Cayman S out last Sat courtesy of my local OPC. It’s on a shortlist of 3 with which to replace my 993, if and when I decide to do it. But that’s another story…
Having also test driven both engined Caymans recently, despite the slightly better handling, especially on tighter roads, I also wasnt tempted to chop my 993 in.... And, I've come to the conclusion that whilst Caymans are very good cars, I think they are overpriced, by at least £8K. After all, 911 convertibles have always been at least £6k more than hard tops haven't they?
If Porsche can produce a 3.4 Boxster for under £40K, surely the hard top version should be under £35K?
Damned clever these Porsche marketing chaps......
Regards, Boo
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


