Will Porsche even the stakes with Ferrari ??
Will Porsche even the stakes with Ferrari ??
Author
Discussion

Glenn McMenamin

Original Poster:

2,305 posts

269 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
I think Ferrari have caught Porsche sleeping of late, i also think they have been resting on their reliablity laurals too much, while Ferrari have sneeked up on them, and are giving them a good battering with cars like the 430 and especially the forthcoming Scud.
They have technology such as F1 paddle shift (best in the industry ?) and this E-diff thingy seems to be pretty effective too, they seem to be pushing the envelope much more than Porsche....

All Porsche have given us is PASM Suspension, and still a crappy shitronic.....

I am Porsche through and through, but if these F cars weren't quite so expensive, i may have had a walk on the wild side....

I really hope Porsche have got one of the 1st Scuds, and will be taking it apart to see where they are falling behind......maybe Porsche is losing out to Ferraris F1 experience ???

Edited by Glenn McMenamin on Thursday 1st November 12:25

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't these cars in different price brackets? what sort of Ferrari can I get for £75K?

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Agree, Ferrari seem to have come on strong in GT series too...Porsche totally resting on their laurels......the thing is though, they are the most profitable car company and seem to be able to sell as many cars at high prices to the punters queuing up...so from the accountants/shareholders point of view, what are they doing wrong?
Maybe they are more focussed on owning VW than the cars right now??

Glenn McMenamin

Original Poster:

2,305 posts

269 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't these cars in different price brackets? what sort of Ferrari can I get for £75K?
Yes you are right, i was refering more to the £100k + end i.e. RS's GT2's and TT's..

G.

Glenn McMenamin

Original Poster:

2,305 posts

269 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
clubsport said:
Agree, Ferrari seem to have come on strong in GT series too...Porsche totally resting on their laurels......the thing is though, they are the most profitable car company and seem to be able to sell as many cars at high prices to the punters queuing up...so from the accountants/shareholders point of view, what are they doing wrong?
Maybe they are more focussed on owning VW than the cars right now??
Yes, i suppose they think nothing is broke, so no need to fix, i would also hope to see what's also coming into the market place at the same time, and react accordingly.....time will tell.

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Glenn, the next big things we have to look forward to are a Hybrid Cayenne and that equally hideous Panamera thing....I do think the direct injection and DSG across the range are a step in the right direction, at least they are catching up with VW in that sense.

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
I know where Glen is coming from and two members of my local Porsche Club have got ferraris to replace there Porsches. I think everyday reliabilty and quick ring times are wearing a bit thin with the buying performance car public who also want some drama and sense of occasion from there cars. I think Lamborghini have posted incredible profits recently and seem to have the reliability/sense of occasion/speed factor recipe down to a T.

P.S. Did i not hear that the new Nissan Skyline posted a sub 7:40min time around the ring? It seems even the japanese are catching up.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
The cars are in different price leagues... gt2 vs 430... 20,000 miles, 20 track days and 2 years... got to have a lot more wedge for the 430

vin_r1

85 posts

236 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
I think what Porsche offers is probably slightly simpler but more robust and useable as an everyday car. I agree the new 430, Scud are very nice but there is still a massive price difference even between the GT2.

Most people (general public) when they see a 911 can't really tell the difference between them whether it be a normal Carrera or TT - just my 2p worth.

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
vin_r1 said:
I think what Porsche offers is probably slightly simpler but more robust and useable as an everyday car. I agree the new 430, Scud are very nice but there is still a massive price difference even between the GT2.

Most people (general public) when they see a 911 can't really tell the difference between them whether it be a normal Carrera or TT - just my 2p worth.
Most people (general public) would think that a Lamborghini is a Ferrari, or even a Maserati is a Ferrari

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
If Porsche can't put bigger engines in (and given the enviro pressure thats ok), they really need to save a lot of weight. That way we all win as the cars cost less to run on track, do less environmental ill and they can get back some lost ground to Ferrari.

Personally I don't really care for the rocket ship Ferrari technology. Does it make a car better if it has F1 style traction control where you have to mash the throttle on corner exit to allow the electronics to find maximum grip and pace? Sure it makes the car quicker than a 911, but all out pace isn't the only consideration for recreational driving.

I may be mistaken, but I'm not convinced the ediff is anything that subaru, mitsubishi and nissan haven't been doing for a while now? They all get accused of rocket ship performance whilst demanding very little of the driver. Ferrari's heritage and lack of being Japanese means people don't level those accusation, but I wonder...

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Personally I like the slightly understated nature of most Porsches. I find Ferraris and Lambos a bit too "medallion man" for my taste. It's good that there are cars out there for all tastes. I don't think copying Ferrari is the way forward for Porsche. Out of the current range of cars, I really like the Cayman, as it's a little bit smaller and lighter than a 911.

Jammmy

72 posts

236 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
clubsport said:
Agree, Ferrari seem to have come on strong in GT series too...Porsche totally resting on their laurels......the thing is though, they are the most profitable car company and seem to be able to sell as many cars at high prices to the punters queuing up...so from the accountants/shareholders point of view, what are they doing wrong?
Maybe they are more focussed on owning VW than the cars right now??
Agree 100percent

Is this the start of a revolution.....I hope so.

They have got away with churning the same (reliable) stuff over and over....same interiors, wheels, accessories virtually across the range... which seems to have lost its little boy "WOW"

With Ferrari the "less is more" argument really is less weight, but with exotic materials, Porsche just give you less ....period - and then charge more, and then hide behind limited numbers argument.

Personally, I love(and own)Porsche's I love Ferrari but for fizz buzz and excitement Ferrari all day.... I recommend anyone between Porsches to go and drive a Stradale...

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
DanH said:
If Porsche can't put bigger engines in (and given the enviro pressure thats ok), they really need to save a lot of weight...
completely agree but 2.7-3.0-964-993-996-997 rs models show a worrying trend in reducing effort to save weight over the standard cars.

ferrari already seem to be heading down this route (millechili)

with 'only' 400bhp i *really* dont see why porsche cant produce a 1000-1200kg 911 again

Marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
But which is the most profitable company ,, i guess thats as far as they look or care

scotty_917

1,034 posts

253 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
fbrs said:
....with 'only' 400bhp i *really* dont see why porsche cant produce a 1000-1200kg 911 again
me neither.....it's about time they did!thumbup....how about getting a standard 997 C2, dump everything electrical that's not needed for driving pleasure (including PASM), carpets, sunroof, etc, and sell for less....like the old 911 & 968 CS's....scratchchin

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
fbrs said:
i *really* dont see why porsche cant produce a 1000-1200kg 911 again
I'd buy one of those for sure

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
scotty_917 said:
fbrs said:
....with 'only' 400bhp i *really* dont see why porsche cant produce a 1000-1200kg 911 again
me neither.....it's about time they did!thumbup....how about getting a standard 997 C2, dump everything electrical that's not needed for driving pleasure (including PASM), carpets, sunroof, etc, and sell for less....like the old 911 & 968 CS's....scratchchin
Because the market is too small. It would need it's own sales & marketing budget aswell. It doesn't make business sense for Porsche.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
Because the market is too small. It would need it's own sales & marketing budget aswell. It doesn't make business sense for Porsche.
A bit of a shame really, since their current reputation was built on such cars.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
scotty_917 said:
fbrs said:
....with 'only' 400bhp i *really* dont see why porsche cant produce a 1000-1200kg 911 again
me neither.....it's about time they did!thumbup....how about getting a standard 997 C2, dump everything electrical that's not needed for driving pleasure (including PASM), carpets, sunroof, etc, and sell for less....like the old 911 & 968 CS's....scratchchin
Because the market is too small. It would need it's own sales & marketing budget aswell. It doesn't make business sense for Porsche.
legislation/oil price will force it soon enough