What criteria are used when deciding to close a thread
Discussion
Just reeding the GT2 thread with a smile and got to the closed by darren bit.
Darren Im not trying to cause controvercy but I cant help but notice that on this forum threads seem to get arbitary short shrift especialy since the haymarket sale it somtimes feels like a classefied site with a forum attached. i have always been a PH advocate but it gets dull to see a thread locked for very little reason.
I understand the need to comercalise the site and have been an advertiser big fan of haymarket as it happens, but what was wrong with GT2 thread?
Darren Im not trying to cause controvercy but I cant help but notice that on this forum threads seem to get arbitary short shrift especialy since the haymarket sale it somtimes feels like a classefied site with a forum attached. i have always been a PH advocate but it gets dull to see a thread locked for very little reason.
I understand the need to comercalise the site and have been an advertiser big fan of haymarket as it happens, but what was wrong with GT2 thread?
Quite simple. We have a rule on the site, no adverts allowed on the forum.
Steve did an advert type post earlier in the week concerning his turbo. There was already a number of posts on the thread before I spotted it, so left it open. Then within three days we have a similar advert type post from the same poster, I closed it. I could have deleted it, but chose to leave it open due to the other posts and as a reminder to people of the free classifieds facility PH offers.
How we moderate the forums is widely open to debate, there is no Mods Manual to stick to, just an interpretation of the rules and the tone of the site. I think people would prefer a bit of leeway and the odd closure or deletion if someone takes the pi$$? rather than strictly enforced deletion of anything that could be construed as breaking the rules.
Ref Haymarket take over. As someone who helps out with moderating on the site (unpaid), None of the mods have been asked to do anything differently. Haymarket seem to be taking the approach of Ted's methods worked to build the site, so let's stick with his formula, where they seem (IMHO) to be making a difference is away from the forums, with the IT and marketing side of PH.
cheers
DAZ
Steve did an advert type post earlier in the week concerning his turbo. There was already a number of posts on the thread before I spotted it, so left it open. Then within three days we have a similar advert type post from the same poster, I closed it. I could have deleted it, but chose to leave it open due to the other posts and as a reminder to people of the free classifieds facility PH offers.
How we moderate the forums is widely open to debate, there is no Mods Manual to stick to, just an interpretation of the rules and the tone of the site. I think people would prefer a bit of leeway and the odd closure or deletion if someone takes the pi$$? rather than strictly enforced deletion of anything that could be construed as breaking the rules.
Ref Haymarket take over. As someone who helps out with moderating on the site (unpaid), None of the mods have been asked to do anything differently. Haymarket seem to be taking the approach of Ted's methods worked to build the site, so let's stick with his formula, where they seem (IMHO) to be making a difference is away from the forums, with the IT and marketing side of PH.
cheers
DAZ

supermono said:
I thought it was because of me saying that my polar silver GT2 was for sale in that thread. But I guess not 
SM
No, you were merely answering the OP's question. But thanks for reminding us on another thread!
SM
The no advert rule is there to protect the forum from being spammed with advert threads. It's a necessary rule to stop the place turning into some sort of Porsche bits bazaar.
What started out as helping out on the porsche forum ended up with me having moderators access all PH forum. Although I draw the line at going on the TVR forums too often, porsche drivers telling them what not to do could easily be misconstrued as an act of war!
DAZ
DAZ

Edited by dazren on Thursday 1st November 17:07
dazren said:
What started out as helping out on the porsche forum ended up with me having moderators access all PH forum. Although I draw the line at going on the TVR forums too often, porsche drivers telling them what not to do could easily be misconstrued as an act of war!
DAZ
DAZ

Edited by dazren on Thursday 1st November 17:07

Someone mention TVR?

Big Al. said:
dazren said:
What started out as helping out on the porsche forum ended up with me having moderators access all PH forum. Although I draw the line at going on the TVR forums too often, porsche drivers telling them what not to do could easily be misconstrued as an act of war!
DAZ
DAZ

Edited by dazren on Thursday 1st November 17:07

Someone mention TVR?


dazren said:
Quite simple. We have a rule on the site, no adverts allowed on the forum.
Steve did an advert type post earlier in the week concerning his turbo. There was already a number of posts on the thread before I spotted it, so left it open. Then within three days we have a similar advert type post from the same poster, I closed it. I could have deleted it, but chose to leave it open due to the other posts and as a reminder to people of the free classifieds facility PH offers.
How we moderate the forums is widely open to debate, there is no Mods Manual to stick to, just an interpretation of the rules and the tone of the site. I think people would prefer a bit of leeway and the odd closure or deletion if someone takes the pi$$? rather than strictly enforced deletion of anything that could be construed as breaking the rules.
Ref Haymarket take over. As someone who helps out with moderating on the site (unpaid), None of the mods have been asked to do anything differently. Haymarket seem to be taking the approach of Ted's methods worked to build the site, so let's stick with his formula, where they seem (IMHO) to be making a difference is away from the forums, with the IT and marketing side of PH.
cheers
DAZ
I can agree with this, as I have been discussing the kind of posting due to our advertising and have been advised to not deviate from any previous type of posts, so try and keep our advertsisng to a minimum unless asked about or it's an intro thread by us or someone else.Steve did an advert type post earlier in the week concerning his turbo. There was already a number of posts on the thread before I spotted it, so left it open. Then within three days we have a similar advert type post from the same poster, I closed it. I could have deleted it, but chose to leave it open due to the other posts and as a reminder to people of the free classifieds facility PH offers.
How we moderate the forums is widely open to debate, there is no Mods Manual to stick to, just an interpretation of the rules and the tone of the site. I think people would prefer a bit of leeway and the odd closure or deletion if someone takes the pi$$? rather than strictly enforced deletion of anything that could be construed as breaking the rules.
Ref Haymarket take over. As someone who helps out with moderating on the site (unpaid), None of the mods have been asked to do anything differently. Haymarket seem to be taking the approach of Ted's methods worked to build the site, so let's stick with his formula, where they seem (IMHO) to be making a difference is away from the forums, with the IT and marketing side of PH.
cheers
DAZ

What gets me on PH is the free advertsising by nonpaying advertisers who get all their mates or fake logins to recommend time and time again, when they don't put their hand in the pocket like we do. I guess it's hard as sometimes it;'s a genuine request but normally I find the usually referrers who are more than likely geting a fliipin backhander post up when they haven't posted for weeks!!!!
Rant over!
As you were!!
dazren said:
Big Al. said:
dazren said:
What started out as helping out on the porsche forum ended up with me having moderators access all PH forum. Although I draw the line at going on the TVR forums too often, porsche drivers telling them what not to do could easily be misconstrued as an act of war!
DAZ
DAZ

Edited by dazren on Thursday 1st November 17:07

Someone mention TVR?



Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




