Manual vs Tiptronic
Manual vs Tiptronic
Author
Discussion

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Guys,

can i ask your opinion or your thoughts on the two. I have always been a manual person myself. I'm certainly not interested in an automatic but what do people think of tiptronics in comparison?

Also, do the tiptronics accelerate faster than a manual due to speed of gear change?

Wetwipe

3,019 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
With the greatest respect i would suggest you use the search function. This question is as old as the ark and has been discussed many many times.

Have a look and if there is anything else you want to know shout

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
PLEASE PLEASE use the search facility to look for the many many previous dicussions on this, rather than start a whole new one.

As a factual answer to your question, the manual is capable of accelerating quicker because there's no loss of power associated with an automatic gearbox (using fluids to turn rather than cogs) and manuals have more gears (except Boxster 2.5/2.7) - Tips only have 4 gears on a 993, 5 on 986/996/987/997. A poor driver may be slower in the manual of course.

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
thegoose said:
PLEASE PLEASE use the search facility to look for the many many previous dicussions on this, rather than start a whole new one.

As a factual answer to your question, the manual is capable of accelerating quicker because there's no loss of power associated with an automatic gearbox (using fluids to turn rather than cogs) and manuals have more gears (except Boxster 2.5/2.7) - Tips only have 4 gears on a 993, 5 on 986/996/987/997. A poor driver may be slower in the manual of course.


Guys thanks for the comments and the problem i have is that i cant find the search function. Where is it?

I always look there on other forums first.

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all

Hereward

5,174 posts

261 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
r5gttgaz said:
The answer is manual.
Unless you are buying a car for a wife who has the mechanical sympathy of a sledgehammer.

nodz17

310 posts

253 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
if you've got a dodgy left leg, like me, then the answer is tiptronic.

i liked my manual 993 c4.

i love my tip 993 c2.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
mansoor999 said:
I'm certainly not interested in an automatic
well you pretty much answered your own question then. tip is an automatic

tonikaram

324 posts

241 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
thegoose said:
As a factual answer to your question, the manual is capable of accelerating quicker because there's no loss of power associated with an automatic gearbox (using fluids to turn rather than cogs)
I have read very frequently (and have found some acceptance), that a Turbo tip would accelerate faster because, as I recall "the tip, being an automatic, will somehow result in keeping the rotating speed of the turbo high, rather than have it fall between gears". Therefore straight line acceleration will be slightly better with the TT tip compared to a manual TT.

This was very unfortunate news as I am not fond of any auto/tip anywhere near Porsches. So, is that theory wrong? can we celebrate?

Kay

Dr S

5,163 posts

257 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
tonikaram said:
thegoose said:
As a factual answer to your question, the manual is capable of accelerating quicker because there's no loss of power associated with an automatic gearbox (using fluids to turn rather than cogs)
I have read very frequently (and have found some acceptance), that a Turbo tip would accelerate faster because, as I recall "the tip, being an automatic, will somehow result in keeping the rotating speed of the turbo high, rather than have it fall between gears". Therefore straight line acceleration will be slightly better with the TT tip compared to a manual TT.

This was very unfortunate news as I am not fond of any auto/tip anywhere near Porsches. So, is that theory wrong? can we celebrate?

Kay
For the 996TT it might be true at very high speeds because the manual will loose some momentum during gear shif which the auto will not. That's why the old SL55 was faster 0-300 kmp/h than many manual supercars

The 997TT is faster as a tip also to 62 mph as before the launch it builds up torque in the drive train which the manual can't. Still, I don't like the feel of Porsche autos. Manual any day for me

Marlon

735 posts

289 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Dr S said:
tonikaram said:
thegoose said:
As a factual answer to your question, the manual is capable of accelerating quicker because there's no loss of power associated with an automatic gearbox (using fluids to turn rather than cogs)
I have read very frequently (and have found some acceptance), that a Turbo tip would accelerate faster because, as I recall "the tip, being an automatic, will somehow result in keeping the rotating speed of the turbo high, rather than have it fall between gears". Therefore straight line acceleration will be slightly better with the TT tip compared to a manual TT.

This was very unfortunate news as I am not fond of any auto/tip anywhere near Porsches. So, is that theory wrong? can we celebrate?

Kay
For the 996TT it might be true at very high speeds because the manual will loose some momentum during gear shif which the auto will not. That's why the old SL55 was faster 0-300 kmp/h than many manual supercars

The 997TT is faster as a tip also to 62 mph as before the launch it builds up torque in the drive train which the manual can't. Still, I don't like the feel of Porsche autos. Manual any day for me
Can vouch for that (I think the SL55 box is very similar to the Porker). If you want to travel quickly in a straight line then the auto box in the SL is fab; repeatable 10-sec 0-100 dash. Nuff said. Of course, the SL weighs the same as Noah's old boat and the throttle response isn't as crisp as Pork crackling, so auto suits it better. For a 911, unless you do lots of motorway crawling, get a manual IMO.

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
I based the speed comparison on the BMW SMG and a manual. The SMG is quicker 0-60 purely because of the speed in gear change.

Thanks Anyway.

BTW - found out that i access this through www.porkers.co.uk and tehre is no search button on that website

sidicks

25,218 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
mansoor999 said:
I based the speed comparison on the BMW SMG and a manual. The SMG is quicker 0-60 purely because of the speed in gear change.

Thanks Anyway.

BTW - found out that i access this through www.porkers.co.uk and tehre is no search button on that website
Not a valid comparison - the BMW M3 SMG is a manual gearbox with electronics changing the gears for you. The Tiptronic is a more traditional auto.

When the the new PDK (twin-clutch) gearbox) is available on the 911 range then your point is likely to be valid.

Sidicks

Hammerwerfer

3,234 posts

271 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
r5gttgaz said:
The answer is manual.
Correct!

Brink

1,505 posts

239 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Next...

alfa phil

2,316 posts

238 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
if i could have a new 997turbo rag top it would have to be a tip, id get a bit nervous taking my hand of the wheel while hammering it , probably an age thing

car.chic

5,995 posts

246 months

Saturday 3rd November 2007
quotequote all
My Boxster S is a tiptronic for one reason, I hate driving manuals with light clutches the Boxster although a nice action is quite light, I just can't get on with them!!

If I was going for a classic 911 I'd go manual all day long, my next car should hopefully be a GT3 which I find the clutch great in!!

Don't ask me what it is because I'm really not so sure. BTW a good driver in a tip will absolutely hammer a poor/ average/ half decent driver in a manual, you'd need near on perfect gear changes to be any quicker than a good driver in a tip.

alfa phil

2,316 posts

238 months

Saturday 3rd November 2007
quotequote all
my boxsters s clutch is rather stiff ,so much so as ive had to correct my driving position to stop myself getting a bad back, i think id rather like a nice light clutch ,but if i had a lot more power in a car deal with, i would defo go for a tip.

car.chic

5,995 posts

246 months

Sunday 4th November 2007
quotequote all
alfa phil said:
my boxsters s clutch is rather stiff ,so much so as ive had to correct my driving position to stop myself getting a bad back, i think id rather like a nice light clutch ,but if i had a lot more power in a car deal with, i would defo go for a tip.
The one I tried was quite light, hmmm typical I probably got one in a 1000 or something!