968 - 928 ?
Author
Discussion

Corpulent Tosser

Original Poster:

5,468 posts

276 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
I am looking for a car to use when I am at home, I work 28 days away, 28 days home, so do not need a car to commute, wife has a fairly new 4x4 which is everyday transport and tow vehicle for my hillclimb car.

To the point, ratherthan spend a lot of money on a car for myslef to use when at home I was thinking about a 928 or 968 as something a little different, sporty and I could use for transport plus the occasional track day, and maybe even a blast up a hill.

As the garage is full, would either of these fit the bill, considering it would not turn a wheel for 28 days outside , though it could be covered, which would be best, I do fancy the V8, but is it better ?

Any advise, even don't do it, would be appreciated.

Corpulent Tosser

Original Poster:

5,468 posts

276 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
Forgot to add, I thought I could get a decend example of either for under 10K.

richad027

115 posts

256 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
It shouldn't be too much of a problem, covering definitely helps in winter and you will need to use a battery charger, if its left for 28 days unused. My 968 has no problems with being left unused so long as the battery charger is connected, which is very easy to do.

Richard.

Corpulent Tosser

Original Poster:

5,468 posts

276 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks Richard,

I am not home until Dec and may start having a look around then, will do many web searches to see what is available and at what cost in the meantime.

Murray

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
Not many 928's are tracked, I guess because the extra lardage makes it an expensive exercise.

On the otherhand, just about every 968 in the known world has seen some track action.

Form your own conclusions....

SS7

Edited by shoestring7 on Friday 9th November 08:57

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
what would you like in your sandwich today sir? Chalk or cheese?

I've never had a 968... but I do have a 928S and a 944.
Personally I love the 944 more.

The 928 was a beauty to drive, such smooth power, but the damn thing is so big! Get an electrical fault on one and you royally stuffed, the fusebox is 18 inches long nearly.

I find the 944 better to drive for fun, obviously its way down on power, but you just feel like you're more involved. It feels like you could get near to it's limits. The 928 is so smooth that you dont get the same feeling until you're going rather faster than you might want to be on a winding A-road.

They're both ace cars, you need to work out what you really want to get out of it.

nickb55

276 posts

240 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
Conian said:
what would you like in your sandwich today sir? Chalk or cheese?

They're both ace cars, you need to work out what you really want to get out of it.
Spot on. 968(cs) for fun and track... 928 for touring and comfort...

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
Although they may cost similar to buy, the 928 was a much MUCH more complex machine, and therefore there is a whole load more to go wrong when it stops working. 928's can quickly run up some very big bills, so go in with care. (Having said that, a good one will run up 250k miles with no problems, if looked after carefully.)

Drive both, they are very different machines.


Oli.

Corpulent Tosser

Original Poster:

5,468 posts

276 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks guys

From what I am reading a 968 would be more my kind of toy, any particular problems I should look out for, any must haves with the car, is the Club Sport much better/different.

Really any info that might help me get a good one.

Ta
CT

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Corpulent Tosser said:
Thanks guys

From what I am reading a 968 would be more my kind of toy, any particular problems I should look out for, any must haves with the car, is the Club Sport much better/different.

Really any info that might help me get a good one.

Ta
CT
Nip over to www.968uk.com. In short, the Clubsport is the one everyone wants, a lot are tired, and a very nice one is expensive ~£15k plus.

A UK market 'Sport' is a CS with a small number of almost essential options, and is less likely to be tracked to death. Freshen it up with KW or Koni suspension, and big brakes/Recaro Pole Position seats to Sir's taste and you won't be able to tell it from a ClubSport to drive - plus they have rear seats which may be a benefit.

The earlier Coupe's are more likely to have leather, aircon, stereo, small wheels etc. and has slightly different (ride height) suspension, more sound proofing, and better interior trim. For a daily drive this is very nice,but moving towards 928 territory.

All have mechanical weaknesses (cams, transaxle) and a poor one will cost a lot to put right. However they are basically simple and string, and the specialists (Hartech, Jon Mitchell, SMC amongst others) know them well.

HTH

SS7

Corpulent Tosser

Original Poster:

5,468 posts

276 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks

CT

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Hi smile

I am the PCGB`s 928 moderator , so I may be a little biased...lol

Its really about what you are going to do with the car...

If you want a road car with the occasional track day...the 928 wins hands down...its faster than the 968...a lot more comfortable and uses a LOT more fuel smile

If you want only a track car ..go for the 968...

My best advice is to test drive BOTH...

If you are anywhere near Bournemouth you are welcome to drive mine smile

I use mine as a daily driver with no problems at all (apart from fuel consumption lol )

And when that huge V8 rumbles into life every morning ...I still get a big smile...

All the best Brett smile

hoges11

1,011 posts

259 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
I've had both and they are both great cars but very different. The 968 handles like a dream, is a tiny bit underpowered, is comfy and very easy to live with and seems to be pretty low maintenance. The 928 drives a bit more like a tank but a bloody fast one, has power enough to pull the front off a small block of flats, is very very comfy (but had a bit of a squeeze for headroom in the front, I'm 6'3&quotwinkand easy to live with but is very complex and things do seem to go wrong more often (usually electrics, the engine is cut from a solid piece of granite).

Having said that I liked the 968s' very much but loved the 928 (and with some of the niggles you have to love them!), they get you like that and the 968 is a bit more bland. My wife on the otherhand much preferred the 968's.

It depends what you are after, the 968 is a sports car the 928 is a big GT. Personally if I was after a sports car I'd get a 964 rather than a 968 (although if I was tracking it I'd be very tempted by the 968CS) and if after a GT it would be the 928. If I had two porsches it would be an old 911 possibly turbo and a good 928GTS, if I had three It'd be a 996TT an old 911 (possibly)turbo and a 928GTS with still no room for a 968. Its not that I dont think the 968 is a great car, it is just not good enough to compare with the others.

One final point, 928's like to be driven and I think most of the issues you get come out of them being underused, if you get one drive the hell out of it and it'll just get better and better.

willdew

2,138 posts

295 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Exactly how a 968 is set up, and what's been refreshed on it (and with what replacements) makes a much bigger difference now that if it's a CS, a Sport or a Coupe.

I don't mean to come across as being a blinkered 968 fanboy, but a well set up 968 is still a genuinely world class handling car. Yes, more power would be nice, and 4 cylinders are never going to have that much character, but, depending what you're looking for, there's very little to touch them without spending a lot more money.

Stick some KW's on, some decent pads and brake fluid, replace the 12 year old bushes, add some good quality tyres, and you can have a lot of fun indeed. Even better, when buying, find one with this done already and save a packet.