928 S2 v S4
Author
Discussion

bigdavy

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

238 months

Wednesday 14th November 2007
quotequote all
Hello again guys, as everyone here has been so very helpfull with advice for my friends possible 911 purchase i thought i would jump in with a request for myself.
I want a 928. 3 friends have them one early 'S' model and 2 with S2's one of which i have the chance of buying.

I would like to ask for any general comments, i have read the excellent buyers guide on 928.org but would like to hear from those who have taken the plunge.
Also whats the view between the S2 and S4? My current thoughts are the 2 is more diy friendly and slightly less complex but i must admit i prefer the updated looks of the 4 scratchchin

Thanks in advance

Cheburator mk2

3,238 posts

230 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
bigdavy said:
I would like to ask for any general comments, i have read the excellent buyers guide on 928.org but would like to hear from those who have taken the plunge.
Also whats the view between the S2 and S4? My current thoughts are the 2 is more diy friendly and slightly less complex but i must admit i prefer the updated looks of the 4 scratchchin
Thanks in advance
It really depends on the individual car - manual or auto, a good example or a basket case etc. The S2 is more DIY friendly, but in auto form is noticeably slower than a S4. On the other hand a good S2 5spd will obliterate any S4 but a good GT or GTS. Also bear in mind that the last S2s - 1986 model year (Sep1985-Sep1986) will have S4 running gear underneath - better suspension geometry and Brembo 4-pots all round which were lifted off the 962/959...

My ideal configuration will be a 1986 S2 5spd without sunroof and with the sports suspension, lsd and sports manual seats. If you need any more info - send me an email.

BTW. I have both a 1990 LHD 928GT based race car with GTS engine, 5spd box and brakes and a 1984 928S2 5spd with S4 running gear smile

bigdavy

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

238 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks, unfortunatley i need an auto so no manuals. Is there really quite a difference between the 2 and 4? I've been in my friends S2 auto and it seems fast enough but i've never tried an S4.

I'm in a bit of a quandry really, i would prefer a 4 but have the chance of buying my friends S2 at a really really good price, (easily half the cost of a decent S4) it does need a little tidy up but nothing major and at the price i could buy it do everything it needs and it would still be a cheap car.

Cheburator mk2

3,238 posts

230 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
bigdavy said:
Thanks, unfortunatley i need an auto so no manuals. Is there really quite a difference between the 2 and 4? I've been in my friends S2 auto and it seems fast enough but i've never tried an S4.

I'm in a bit of a quandry really, i would prefer a 4 but have the chance of buying my friends S2 at a really really good price, (easily half the cost of a decent S4) it does need a little tidy up but nothing major and at the price i could buy it do everything it needs and it would still be a cheap car.
The S2 Auto suffers from a gap in the gear spacing and relative lack of torque when compared to the S4 Auto. The 16v engines are very rev happy and make their torque and power high up the band (4100rpm for torque and 6250rpm for power), then the gearbox changes up from 2nd into 3d and there is nothing there. On the S4, the gap in gear spacing is still there, but the engine has a torque plateau between 3000rpm and 4500rpm, which helps a lot in terms of performance.

As with regards to buying a car which needs TLC - never underestimate the power of the wallet sensor which is built into every 928. The minute it senses some money in your wallet it will start working over time smile

Edited by Cheburator mk2 on Friday 16th November 15:43

barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
Hi Davy

Cheb's advice is all good. Personally I prefer the shark nosed look of the early cars but I suppose that's a personal thing. I currently have an S4 manual and a very early manual car (1979) but I used to have an S2 auto.

They aren't slow by any means, but as Cheburator points out, there is a big gap in the ratios. A nice S2 auto is still a lovely car and a great 928. They are very quick up to 80mph in second gear.

Joel

Cheburator mk2

3,238 posts

230 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
barchetta_boy said:
Hi Davy

Cheb's advice is all good. Personally I prefer the shark nosed look of the early cars but I suppose that's a personal thing. I currently have an S4 manual and a very early manual car (1979) but I used to have an S2 auto.

They aren't slow by any means, but as Cheburator points out, there is a big gap in the ratios. A nice S2 auto is still a lovely car and a great 928. They are very quick up to 80mph in second gear.

Joel
You still grinning from ear to ear when you drive the 1979 5spd?

barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
Cheburator mk2 said:
You still grinning from ear to ear when you drive the 1979 5spd?
Funny you should ask, just been to pick it up from its berth in Ealing and taken it back to the office. It just puts a huuuge grin on my face every time I hear that V8 rumble...

mr_spock

3,376 posts

246 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
I have a very tidy 89 S4 auto. All the nasty stuff has been done - torque tube, converter bearings, timing belt, water pump, injection computer, brakes, service, window seals and some paint refurb by Daytona Coachworx. Lots of other little bits - I like my cars to be perfect!

Come and have a try if you like. I've been half-arsedly considering a Lotus Cortina, so might sell, but either way why not come and have a try and see if you like the S4. I'm near Wembley/Harrow.

bigdavy

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

238 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
Mr spock, thanks a lot for the great offer but as i'm just south of Glasgow i'll have to decline.

I'm actually looking at an S4 on Ebay, it looks a good genuine car but one thing, seller says it's had a digital clock change in 1999 (with full paperwork) and it now reads xxxxx kilometers. Are they all in kilometers or could this be a possible import? Should it not be miles?
By the way it's a strange colour - cassis red metallic which i really like, i'm just wondering if you have ever seen one and what the colour is like (sometimes hard in a photo to tell)

rallycross

13,764 posts

268 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
A bit of friendly advice... I suggest you do not buy one of these cars off ebay without seeing it first!

ebay is not the ideal place to buy a massively sophisticated 20 yr old car that easily has the potential to cost more in repairs/making it right than the purchase cost.


bigdavy

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

238 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
Yeah thanks, I wouldn't. I'm trying to arrange for an inspection or at least someone who owns / knows them to have a look. The advert says all the right things with full history etc etc but you are right in what you say, I wouldn't buy any car from ebay without either seeing or getting it checked.

Thanks for the thought, Davy.

Henry-F

4,791 posts

276 months

Saturday 17th November 2007
quotequote all
This thread worries me a little. People are splitting hairs over relative model differences between different 928s, many of which are over 20 years old now.

The one piece of advice that hasn`t been given is to remember most 928s on the market these days are absolute sheds that need litterally thousands of pounds spent on them so for christ`s sake don`t go into the market place looking for a specific car. Look at all the cars on the market and buy the "best" car available whether it be an S2, S4, etc, etc.

I suspect you will probably end up buying an S4 just based on it`s age and the fact that better 928s tend (a big generalisation) to be S4s.

All the best, and for sure don`t go buying one off ebay. You`d be a braver boy than me & I do it for a living.

Henry

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Saturday 17th November 2007
quotequote all
Henry-F said:
The one piece of advice that hasn`t been given is to remember most 928s on the market these days are absolute sheds that need litterally thousands of pounds spent on them so for christ`s sake don`t go into the market place looking for a specific car.

Henry
Hi Henry smile

Usually you give excellent advice that I agree with, but this time you are wrong.....928s are very rarely "sheds"...they almost always are mechanically sound and if the electrics work (mostly smile ..) then they are a VERY good buy..

As Pcgb 928 moderator, I put a lot of people in touch with sellers and rarely do they have major problems.

It will help if the owner is either a Pcgb member or a Tipec member I have found as they both tend to look after their 928s and have already sorted out any major problems...

Where else can you buy a 150 mph plus supercar for under £5k ???

I know of an early 928 manual in good nick that went for £2.5k recently (Tipec owner)....which is amazing value for money....

To be honest....the only "sheds" I know of.....are being sold by dealers...no insult intended smile

All the best Brett smile

928S2 AUTO V8 4.7 LTR 1986 IRIS METALLIC BLUE WITH X-PIPES, RMB, PROMAX CHIPS, KICKDOWN SWITCH, K&N,WIZARDS OF NOS - NITROUS KIT 150 HP - 505 BHP / 500 FT LBS TORQUE.
PCGB - 928 - FORUM - MODERATOR.
EMAIL : managingdirector@pchealthcare.co.uk

Henry-F

4,791 posts

276 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Henry-F said:
The one piece of advice that hasn`t been given is to remember most 928s on the market these days are absolute sheds that need litterally thousands of pounds spent on them so for christ`s sake don`t go into the market place looking for a specific car.

Henry
Hi Henry smile

Usually you give excellent advice that I agree with, but this time you are wrong.....928s are very rarely "sheds"...they almost always are mechanically sound and if the electrics work (mostly smile ..) then they are a VERY good buy..

As Pcgb 928 moderator, I put a lot of people in touch with sellers and rarely do they have major problems.

It will help if the owner is either a Pcgb member or a Tipec member I have found as they both tend to look after their 928s and have already sorted out any major problems...

Where else can you buy a 150 mph plus supercar for under £5k ???

I know of an early 928 manual in good nick that went for £2.5k recently (Tipec owner)....which is amazing value for money....

To be honest....the only "sheds" I know of.....are being sold by dealers...no insult intended smile

All the best Brett smile

928S2 AUTO V8 4.7 LTR 1986 IRIS METALLIC BLUE WITH X-PIPES, RMB, PROMAX CHIPS, KICKDOWN SWITCH, K&N,WIZARDS OF NOS - NITROUS KIT 150 HP - 505 BHP / 500 FT LBS TORQUE.
PCGB - 928 - FORUM - MODERATOR.
EMAIL : managingdirector@pchealthcare.co.uk
I still stand by my original comments, the vast bulk of 928s in the Auto Trader / ebay are sheds.

These are cars that had 2-3k a year spent on them when they were relatively young and that people think can be kept on the road for £4-500 a year now they are much older! (budget £2-3k a year to keep one on the road and in tip top order.

I do however agree with you that if you can find a good example then there are few cars that equal it`s sense of occasion to drive and looks-wise they would still make the headlines if launched today.

Henry smile