CAR comparison of Nissan GT-R and 911 Turbo.
CAR comparison of Nissan GT-R and 911 Turbo.
Author
Discussion

boxerTen

Original Poster:

508 posts

235 months

Wednesday 14th November 2007
quotequote all
The December issue of CAR has an article on the new Nissan GT-R. Towards the end Georg Kacher writes:

"It's here on narrow, crudely patchworked roads that the Nissan says auf wiedersehen to the scrambling, screeching 911 Turbo we have as a chase car. The magic word is compliance. Where the Porsche pitches and yaws like a speedboat in heavy seas, the GT-R simply soaks up vagaries and maintains a straight line."

Ouch! So Porsche: longer wheel base needed, engine in the middle please!

The GT-R also manages a 7m 38s 'Ring lap despite weighing 1740kg and having only 473bhp which suggests a very clever drive train. (I recall a driver of a much earlier GT-R, racing at Bathurst, explaining how it utterly dominated by virtue of being variously, rear, four, front, or even, if the situation demanded, side wheel drive!)

(Would I buy one? No chance. Weighs too much. Nor a Turbo for the same reason. How light can one make a GT3? ...)

Edited by boxerTen on Thursday 15th November 20:50

E368

14 posts

228 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
boxerTen said:
The GT-R also manages a 7m 38s 'Ring lap despite weighing 1740kg and having only 473bhp which suggests a very clever drive train.
The new GT-R is going to be a world-beater in terms of value and I don't discount for one instant what Nissan has done with this car, however I still question the 7:38 Ring time. I doubt the car was box-stock!

AdamT

2,825 posts

283 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
I dont read CAR magazine, for one reason alone... its crap.

Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions smile

Slippydiff

16,503 posts

254 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
The last Nissan GT-R was a technological masterpiece, it didn't do a lot for the sales of the car IIRC (there'll always be those that want the challenge of mastering a car with the engine in "the wrong place" too)

I'm sure the same will apply to the R8, fast,safe and sure footed, no doubt a superb car, but is it THAT engaging to drive for the real enthusiast ? Possibly not ?

It won't appeal to the badge jockeys either !

steve996

1,240 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
AdamT said:
I dont read CAR magazine, for one reason alone... its crap.

Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions smile
Have you tried CAR lately? I used to think it was garbage too but in the last while it's improved heaps and I now subscribe to it.

DiscoColin

3,328 posts

245 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
Hmm - they are missing the point. The Nissan GTR doesn't officially go on sale in the UK until 2009. The Porsche that they should be comparing it to hasn't even been built yet...

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
In any case it's still only a Nissan.................

flattotheboards

6,690 posts

237 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
In any case it's still only a Nissan.................
snob!!! hehe

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
flattotheboards said:
DSM2 said:
In any case it's still only a Nissan.................
snob!!! hehe
Well, quite possibly so...........

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
Is there an official UK price for the GT-R yet?

AdamT

2,825 posts

283 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
steve996 said:
AdamT said:
I dont read CAR magazine, for one reason alone... its crap.

Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions smile
Have you tried CAR lately? I used to think it was garbage too but in the last while it's improved heaps and I now subscribe to it.
scratchchin

Trommel

20,671 posts

290 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
Slippydiff said:
It won't appeal to the badge jockeys either !
Far and away the car's biggest issue, especially in "Status on Finance" UK.

steve996

1,240 posts

246 months

Friday 16th November 2007
quotequote all
AdamT said:
steve996 said:
AdamT said:
I dont read CAR magazine, for one reason alone... its crap.

Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions smile
Have you tried CAR lately? I used to think it was garbage too but in the last while it's improved heaps and I now subscribe to it.
scratchchin
Honestly readit much better now.....!

DiscoColin

3,328 posts

245 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Is there an official UK price for the GT-R yet?
Nope, but given that it isn't even out until the year after next this is not exactly a surprise. Most commentators seem to be expecting £60-65k, which sounds about right (despite being around double the official Japanese starting price yikes ).