CAR comparison of Nissan GT-R and 911 Turbo.
Discussion
The December issue of CAR has an article on the new Nissan GT-R. Towards the end Georg Kacher writes:
"It's here on narrow, crudely patchworked roads that the Nissan says auf wiedersehen to the scrambling, screeching 911 Turbo we have as a chase car. The magic word is compliance. Where the Porsche pitches and yaws like a speedboat in heavy seas, the GT-R simply soaks up vagaries and maintains a straight line."
Ouch! So Porsche: longer wheel base needed, engine in the middle please!
The GT-R also manages a 7m 38s 'Ring lap despite weighing 1740kg and having only 473bhp which suggests a very clever drive train. (I recall a driver of a much earlier GT-R, racing at Bathurst, explaining how it utterly dominated by virtue of being variously, rear, four, front, or even, if the situation demanded, side wheel drive!)
(Would I buy one? No chance. Weighs too much. Nor a Turbo for the same reason. How light can one make a GT3? ...)
"It's here on narrow, crudely patchworked roads that the Nissan says auf wiedersehen to the scrambling, screeching 911 Turbo we have as a chase car. The magic word is compliance. Where the Porsche pitches and yaws like a speedboat in heavy seas, the GT-R simply soaks up vagaries and maintains a straight line."
Ouch! So Porsche: longer wheel base needed, engine in the middle please!
The GT-R also manages a 7m 38s 'Ring lap despite weighing 1740kg and having only 473bhp which suggests a very clever drive train. (I recall a driver of a much earlier GT-R, racing at Bathurst, explaining how it utterly dominated by virtue of being variously, rear, four, front, or even, if the situation demanded, side wheel drive!)
(Would I buy one? No chance. Weighs too much. Nor a Turbo for the same reason. How light can one make a GT3? ...)
Edited by boxerTen on Thursday 15th November 20:50
boxerTen said:
The GT-R also manages a 7m 38s 'Ring lap despite weighing 1740kg and having only 473bhp which suggests a very clever drive train.
The new GT-R is going to be a world-beater in terms of value and I don't discount for one instant what Nissan has done with this car, however I still question the 7:38 Ring time. I doubt the car was box-stock!The last Nissan GT-R was a technological masterpiece, it didn't do a lot for the sales of the car IIRC (there'll always be those that want the challenge of mastering a car with the engine in "the wrong place" too)
I'm sure the same will apply to the R8, fast,safe and sure footed, no doubt a superb car, but is it THAT engaging to drive for the real enthusiast ? Possibly not ?
It won't appeal to the badge jockeys either !
I'm sure the same will apply to the R8, fast,safe and sure footed, no doubt a superb car, but is it THAT engaging to drive for the real enthusiast ? Possibly not ?
It won't appeal to the badge jockeys either !
steve996 said:
AdamT said:
I dont read CAR magazine, for one reason alone... its crap.
Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions
Have you tried CAR lately? I used to think it was garbage too but in the last while it's improved heaps and I now subscribe to it. Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions


AdamT said:
steve996 said:
AdamT said:
I dont read CAR magazine, for one reason alone... its crap.
Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions
Have you tried CAR lately? I used to think it was garbage too but in the last while it's improved heaps and I now subscribe to it. Ill wait till autocar or EVO print something before I make any decisions


much better now.....! Fittster said:
Is there an official UK price for the GT-R yet?
Nope, but given that it isn't even out until the year after next this is not exactly a surprise. Most commentators seem to be expecting £60-65k, which sounds about right (despite being around double the official Japanese starting price
).Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




