Criminals ?
Author
Discussion

runner911

Original Poster:

634 posts

274 months

Saturday 17th November 2007
quotequote all
According to labours Baroness Scotland, if we creep over the speed limits either intentionally or by accident, we are CRIMINALS.

This from Mike Rutherfords column in todays (17/11/07)Telegraph.

"A lot of fuss has (rightly) been made in recent days following the revelation that drivers doing 12mph or more above the speed limit will receive six instead of three points and therefore risk losing their licences after committing just two offences.
But the pain doesn't end there. It hasn't been widely reported, but fines will rise too, from £60 to £100.

As I said on the BBC, Sky TV and Channel 4 news last week, the punishment hardly fits the crime. And in case you're wondering, yes you are a criminal if you exceed the speed limit. And that's official. Who says? Labour's Baroness Scotland, the only politician I know who has dared to pin the "criminal" tag on motorists who deliberately or accidentally creep over the speed limits that might (but might not) be posted at the side of the road. And there's naive old me thinking that criminals are murderers, rapists, burglars, muggers... "

graeme36s

7,230 posts

248 months

Saturday 17th November 2007
quotequote all
remember one rule for them and one rule for us. Will the last one to leave please remeber to turn the lights off.

ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Saturday 17th November 2007
quotequote all
Thats why i love it when top traffic cops get caught with their pants down and get zapped by radar doing 150mph plus!!. "oh yes i nearly forgot, his reply to that was " i was getting familiar with the car"!!

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Bring on the civil war.

Sadly the English are far too civil to ever revolt.

Unlike the Welsh who are always revolting.

Trueman sparks

88 posts

230 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
If the speed limit is governed by law, and speeding is "breaking the law", then who else other than a criminal breaks the law? Not a nice label but if its accurate...It just means every driver is a criminal, big deal.


But 6 points is ott, fines will deter people, points costs people jobs.

Henry-F

4,791 posts

276 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
It is simply that the speed limits as currently set and determined many years ago when transport modes were far less advanced, are widely regarded as being wrong. There are some areas of high risk where the speed could do with being lowered to 20mph other areas where in good conditions the limit needs to be raised.

Obviously the most out of sync limit is on the motorway where almost 100% of motorists regularly break the law. If Norman (the lawman) turns a blind eye as has usually happend to date only chosing to prosecute those breaking their "unofficial" limit of around 85mph then civil revolt is avioded. The use of electronic equipment make this harder for him to do.

Then law needs to be changed so that the bulk of society view speed limits as fair and accurate (once again even if that means lowering limits in some areas). Then, and only then will we regard speeding as anti social behaviour in the same way we do drink driving where the limit is set correctly so as not to disadvantage those who sucked a cough sweet, had a small glass of wine 2 hours ago with their lunch or had 3 pints 10 hours ago the night before.

At the moment you have the chicken and egg scenario where officials genuinely concerned for safety set a limit of 40mph when they actually want to see speed at 50mph citing the fact that people always speed and drive 10mph over the limit.

Be brave, set proper limits, have people respect them and reap the reward as finally the motorist themselves view speeding as a criminal activity. In reality you probably only need to increase the motorway speed limit to 80mph and providing you allow the standard 10% plus 1 (or 2 as the Sussex camera operator told me they allow at Goodwood) you will have cracked it. People will regard the motorway limit as sensible and it will all flow downwards from there.

Not really rocket science is it ?

Henry

steve.B

457 posts

238 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
I don't like the label 'CRIMINAL' which we all are, just some of us have not been snapped yet by these stupid money making machine.
These camaras don't catch the people who weave from lane to lane, overtake on the inside , hog the fast lane, drink and drive, take drugs and drive, have no car tax and no insurance.
It also doe'nt take in to account the road conditions where different times of day or night should change the safe speed to drive these roads/motorways.
Bring back the copper in the car with his gun at least its a fairer game.
I have a great idea speaking as a criminal for my worn tyres.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Whatever sort of criminal speeding makes us we will never be as bad as this government and its entourage are.

Illegal war in Iraq, corruption and bare faced lying and incompetence puts them way out ahead of the speeding motorist, without doubt, in the 'criminal' stakes.

More fool us for letting them make the laws...............

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Henry-F said:
It is simply that the speed limits as currently set and determined many years ago when transport modes were far less advanced, are widely regarded as being wrong.
Any councils routinely lower these limits for extra revenue.

Still, once you are a criminal, you can do all sorts of things and get away with it...

nemeton

214 posts

234 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Remember this women has never received a single vote from the electorate? She sits in the house of Lords with a big fat expense account & expects us to respect her. Well lady, get off that soap box & get elected into the house of commons, then I may have some respect for your opinions..

We shout to the world, telling them that democracy is the way to go but back home we have a bunch of unelected, establishment figures in the House Of Lords that tell us what to do but have never had there name appear on a single election voting slip..

Grey Ghost

4,617 posts

251 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Perhaps the soppy old bint should meet some real criminals..... How about a group of gin sozzled yardies to kick her back doors in biggrin

br d

9,072 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
The problem with your logic Henry is that you base your assumptions on your own mores. If you raised the motorway limit to 80 then we'd have to put up with the same pricks who like to fly up the inside lane and cut in at 90 only they'd think they can do it at 100.
It's all very well talking about raising limits for the likes of you, but you'll just end up giving carte blanche to the c**ts who already think they own the fecking road. 70mph is too slow on a motorway, because the people who know how to drive and have a car that can handle it can safely drive quicker, but the dick heads who cause the accidents will just cause more.

brad

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
nemeton said:
Remember this women has never received a single vote from the electorate? She sits in the house of Lords with a big fat expense account & expects us to respect her. Well lady, get off that soap box & get elected into the house of commons, then I may have some respect for your opinions..

We shout to the world, telling them that democracy is the way to go but back home we have a bunch of unelected, establishment figures in the House Of Lords that tell us what to do but have never had there name appear on a single election voting slip..
Have you actually read what she has achieved for Blighty? Have a look at her voting record and performance relative to other peers! See here:
http://www.theyworkforyou.com/peer/baroness_scotla...

You don't have to respect her opinions, but this is a QC, and no ordinary one at that. She's also presided over the correction of some major injustices towards women (which are not logged on the above site, nor the other to which I will refer in a response to follow). Now if you have sisters or mothers or aunts or nieces, would you prefer that she did nothing for them?

Back to the topic. It is a fact that anyone breaking the law is effectively committing a crime. If you don't like that, don't break the law, or find a way to change it. I don't like many motoring laws either, but she didn't make those laws, and as a QC she's expected to be completely clear about these things.

Of course you don't have to agree with any of this, but I do feel a little balance is in order here. smile

Edited by bcnrml on Sunday 18th November 21:21

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
Perhaps the soppy old bint should meet some real criminals..... How about a group of gin sozzled yardies to kick her back doors in biggrin
I think as a QC she's probably met a fair few criminals in her time (even under the supposedly mild family law).

Further, given her apparently strong backing for the anti-terrorism laws (see here: http://www.theyworkforyou.com/peer/baroness_scotla... she's probably nothing like as soppy as you portray. Finally, I've seen her in the flesh, and I can assure you she looks nothing like an old bint.

Have a look here for more (which I acknowledge may not be entirely accurate, but who'd want to publish wrong data on a lawyer, and a QC to boot?):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baroness_Scotland_of_...

Happy reading! smile

UK952

769 posts

290 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
The problem is there is a big difference between breaking the speed limit and driving like a tw*t. The government is focusing on exceeding the number not on bad driving. Driving is getting worse accidents are no longer reducing. The DOT figures show that speeding is not really a problem on our roads being a contributing factor in only around 6% of all accidents. Poor observation is the big killer. Being forced to drive slowly may reduce concentration taking it to extremes are you more alert driving at 60 on a motorway or at 120?

Tony

runner911

Original Poster:

634 posts

274 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
BCNRML.

"Toeing" the party line ?

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
runner911 said:
BCNRML.

"Toeing" the party line ?
No - just responding to what I consider more typically unfair (and likely inaccurate) statements about someone of whom the whingers likely know little or nothing. She's a lawyer, for heaven's sake. Does anyone expect a lawyer (QC especially) to dilute a material fact, especially on a technicality? Have a read of what Lurking Lawyer and Vesuvius have to write about legal matters. Facts are facts. If I am caught doing 31mph in a 30mph zone and I get convicted for it, I will have been criminalised. I don't like it, but that's the fact we all have to live with.

Also, too many people come on here and take pops at Blighty (and its leaders) unfairly. It is too easy, no? It is fine to criticise, but please let's do so armed with facts. I prefer to see criticisms and observations using evidence (no, I'm no lawyer). If that's too much to ask for, then it would be good to know! smile

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
bcnrml said:
runner911 said:
BCNRML.

Facts are facts. If I am caught doing 31mph in a 30mph zone and I get convicted for it, I will have been criminalised. I don't like it, but that's the fact we all have to live with.
Doesn't make it fair or democratic. Can't you see that?

As an aside, why do you live in Spain if there is so much right about the UK?

You have told us you're not a Lawyer but you sound like you have a political association far above the normal?

runner911

Original Poster:

634 posts

274 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
"As an aside, why do you live in Spain if there is so much right about the UK?

You have told us you're not a Lawyer but you sound like you have a political association far above the normal?"

Furthur to comments from DSM as above with which I totally agree , it seems to me that bcmrnl must have a direct link to 10 Downing Street !

Does he honestly believe the drivel which emanates from this corrupt administration , particularly with regard to speed enforcement and Road Traffic Law in general ? Furthur that speed cameras do little if anything to reduce fatal/serious injury accidents on Britains roads, and are nothing more than revenue raisers ?

Come on, just look at the accident stats. published in the DOT's recent paper!

Henry-F

4,791 posts

276 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
br d said:
The problem with your logic Henry is that you base your assumptions on your own mores. If you raised the motorway limit to 80 then we'd have to put up with the same pricks who like to fly up the inside lane and cut in at 90 only they'd think they can do it at 100.
It's all very well talking about raising limits for the likes of you, but you'll just end up giving carte blanche to the c**ts who already think they own the fecking road. 70mph is too slow on a motorway, because the people who know how to drive and have a car that can handle it can safely drive quicker, but the dick heads who cause the accidents will just cause more.

brad
Let`s not get confused here. We aren`t discussing bad driving, nor are we disussuing the merits of our system of government or the effort of those people engaged in it`s running. We`re talking about speed limits and why 95% of the population break them (and in doing so the law) when they are not otherwise criminals or unintelligent people.

The reason is simply that the limits are wrong, particularly on the motorway. If the limit was raised to 80mph and the 10% plus 1mph rule applied to prosecutions the speed would not increase at all, because people drive on the motorway at 80-85mph today. The police would also still be able to prosecute poor driving standards as they do today.

What would happen though is those people who did get prosecuted would be done so with the full support of other motorists as opposed to the current rather random affair of a camera placed on a bridge prosecuting hundreds of motorists who are doing nothing that millions of other motorists on other sections of motorway are doing elsewhere. They feel, quite rightly, dissolusioned with their punishment and by association every other speed limit they see. They also feel dissolusioned with the police who prosecuted them.

Henry