540 to 944
Author
Discussion

nerf

Original Poster:

991 posts

262 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
hello all.
im not from round these parts, i like what youve done with the place... i hang out a few doors down in the BMW room. ive owned my E39 540 for just over a year and im getting itchy feet. its a great car with huge Go but its a bit big for just little ol me. i've always loved the styling of the 944 (S2) and im considering buying one with a budget of about 4k.

ive checked out reviews online etc and they all seem very positive but would love some fresh comments from any owners on here. ive been spoiled on the reliability front with BMW ownership for 7 years now (E34 535 for 5.5 years), and wouldnt want to take a step backwards on that front, but i want a car that will make me smile each time i jump in. so any commenmts on ease of ownership would be cool, and stories of huge reliability would help me make a decision...

many thanks nerf

RobbieMeister

1,307 posts

301 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
If you want a proper smile get a turbo!

Li Moo Bai

847 posts

236 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
That is lux money I think. But don't dismiss them either - I run one and very impressive in-gear it is too smile

ETA: I run mine as an everyday car and have done for the last 9 months. I have loved every minute, and it has needed only minor jobs doing. They are extremely reliable and robust for cars of their era IMO.


Edited by Li Moo Bai on Tuesday 20th November 12:41

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
I've had my S2 for the last 20 months as a daily driver, and it has yet to let me down. (Actually, that's not true - the immobiliser packed up once leaving me in the poo, but that was fixed by the roadside with a toolkit from the boot.) About 10 months ago I changed jobs and now drive to work (40-ish mile round trip) as opposed to using the tube. So, the car is now driven every day, and runs much better, starts more enthusiastically, pulls harder and more smoothly etc etc etc than before. (It was never bad, but now it is better than ever.)

They are practical (2+2, but decent sized boot with a good hatch) and pretty easy to live with. Most importantly, they really are a blast to drive - never fails to put a smile on my face!

If £4k is your budget you may get an S2 - I don't know what the prices are like now. I would definitely say that you need to shop around. I looked at 7 before I bought mine, and ended up buying the cheapest and best (I paid a little over £4k.) I looked at dogs for which £6.5k was being asked, and there is a LOT of dross out there. Go carefully, and a PPI is a VERY good idea if you don't know these cars.

Running costs need to be viewed carefully. See my profile for a detailed list of the last 20 months.


Oli.

diver944

1,855 posts

307 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
Bear in mind that a 944 S2 is a much older car than your 540 so things will wear out and need to be replaced. I am guessing it is also a rarer car (could be wrong) so the law of supply and demand dictates that some 944 only parts prices are stupid money.

Having said that we have had our S2 for nine years and racked up nearly 90k miles with no major problems and no breakdowns so if you are prepared to look after them they will look after you. My profile also has running costs for comparison.

£4k could be an ambitious budget to find a rust free, fault free example but there are occasional bargains out there so look at lots and be prepared to travel to find the right one for you

nerf

Original Poster:

991 posts

262 months

Wednesday 21st November 2007
quotequote all
thanks for your replies guys, excellent advice. hoping to go see a couple and get a test drive in at the weekend.
cheers nerf

Li Moo Bai

847 posts

236 months

Wednesday 21st November 2007
quotequote all
nerf said:
thanks for your replies guys, excellent advice. hoping to go see a couple and get a test drive in at the weekend.
cheers nerf
nerf

I'd really advise you take someone else along who is a bit more familiar with these cars. There are a few quirky faults that a particular to the 944 that are easily missed if you don't know what to look for.

this is not to say you don't know your stuff btw.

Good luck and hope you find a cracker!