Camera flashed, but I was within limit
Camera flashed, but I was within limit
Author
Discussion

PPPPPP

Original Poster:

1,140 posts

262 months

Monday 31st December 2007
quotequote all
Happened to me on Uxbridge Road North London - I was driving exactly at 30mph in a 30 zone(I checked later it was a 30 zone). Any ideas? I will get the speedo checked, but do not think it is faulty (compared it another car driven exactly at 30mph.

Drove past the same camera today at 30 and the camera did not flash.

Edited by PPPPPP on Monday 31st December 22:31

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Monday 31st December 2007
quotequote all
Ive had this. Never received anything.

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Monday 31st December 2007
quotequote all
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.

WeirdNeville

6,050 posts

246 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
I've had this happen to me a couple of times, and it hasn't resulted in a NIP or a letter. Sometimes the cameras just seem to be faulty, I recall one period of a couple of days when a digital gatso was simply flashing every car that passed it, prompting lots of panic braking despite the cars beign ell within the speed limit.

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
happened to me before, pulled over and noted the time, my speed and what speed i thought it was, never had anything thru, so should not worry that much, tend to drop speed for cameras just in case am in a lower speed area than I think i am

PPPPPP

Original Poster:

1,140 posts

262 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
Scraggles said:
.... tend to drop speed for cameras just in case am in a lower speed area than I think i am
Thanks for the responses. Amazing, but Cameras make us drop speed thereby creating further traffic congestion etc etc...

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
Scraggles said:
happened to me before, pulled over and noted the time, my speed and what speed i thought it was, never had anything thru, so should not worry that much, tend to drop speed for cameras just in case am in a lower speed area than I think i am
The camera warning notices seem to be getting speed limits on them now to solve this problem.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
I wish I had your faith in the system....(obviously I know why you have,I think wink) how many people actually just roll over when presented with a NIP and just accept it?

PPPPPP

Original Poster:

1,140 posts

262 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
OK, I appreciate you may know a fair bit about this subject. Are you therefore alluding to the fact that this sort of incident does occur?

And assuming the camera is working perfectly, does it trigger if one is travelling at 31mph, or is it 32, or 33 or???

Edited by PPPPPP on Tuesday 1st January 18:39

jambuster

28 posts

231 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
PPPPPP said:
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
OK, I appreciate you may know a fair bit about this subject. Are you therefore alluding to the fact that this sort of incident does occur?

And assuming the camera is working perfectly, does it trigger if one is travelling at 31mph, or is it 32, or 33 or???

Edited by PPPPPP on Tuesday 1st January 18:39
There is nothing to worry about. There was a case recently where a local gatso was flashing day and night at cars, cysclist and birds flying past regardless of the speed travelled. Unfortunately (as per usual) the local scamera partnership denied that their could possibly be any fault with the camera so it went unfixed for about two weeks scaring thousands of people like yourself but none were prosecuted because as already stated the markings on the road indicate the speed travelled at.

Edited by jambuster on Tuesday 1st January 18:49

thebluebus

3,558 posts

248 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
I wish I had your faith in the system....(obviously I know why you have,I think wink) how many people actually just roll over when presented with a NIP and just accept it?
Same thing happened to me recently - my concern was an NIP coming out to me 'automatically', without any human eyes actually looking at the images to see that I was only doing 25 in a 30.

Never heard anything though, so I now believe there is a greater element of 'checking' to this than I previously thought.

DavidUK

130 posts

228 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
I've always thought it was your approach to the camera that triggered a flash. So if it looks as if you're over the limit it'll take a picture to check. Therefore it may well flash if say you were over 30 approaching the camera, but under 30 when you actually passed it

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
It doesn't always have to be a vehicle that was moving for the camera to go off....



This duck got flashed on a Dutch road where the maximum speed was 50 km/h and the duck flew by at 64 km/h and got flashed as well biggrin

If you was driving at this particular road at that moment you would have seen the camera flash, but probably not the bird.

Edited by Medic-one on Tuesday 1st January 19:48

Derek Smith

50,021 posts

279 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
We had a couple of lads using a camera flash gun at a gatso. You wouldn't believe the number of calls we had to our control room from drivers who they flashed. As soon as we turned out CCTV camera onto the location they cleared off. When talking to someone in Hants, they said that they had a kid who used to throw stones to activate the camera as a car passed. You have to pick the correct size stones - not too small so that the camera doesn't see them and not too big so as not to get the necessary speed - but the PC who attended the scene obviously rated the offence somewhat higher than the soco chap he requested to attend so his collection os similarly sized stones, each in its own evidence bag, had to be discarded.

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
Medic-one said:
It doesn't always have to be a vehicle that was moving for the camera to go off....



This duck got flashed on a Dutch road where the maximum speed was 50 km/h and the duck flew by at 64 km/h and got flashed as well biggrin

If you was driving at this particular road at that moment you would have seen the camera flash, but probably not the bird.

Edited by Medic-one on Tuesday 1st January 19:48
Proof at last

The the taxman really is using one big lame duck to flock us.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 1st January 2008
quotequote all
thebluebus said:
esselte said:
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
I wish I had your faith in the system....(obviously I know why you have,I think wink) how many people actually just roll over when presented with a NIP and just accept it?
Same thing happened to me recently - my concern was an NIP coming out to me 'automatically', without any human eyes actually looking at the images to see that I was only doing 25 in a 30.

Never heard anything though, so I now believe there is a greater element of 'checking' to this than I previously thought.
That's assuming there was film in the thing...

PPPPPP

Original Poster:

1,140 posts

262 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
thebluebus said:
esselte said:
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
I wish I had your faith in the system....(obviously I know why you have,I think wink) how many people actually just roll over when presented with a NIP and just accept it?
Same thing happened to me recently - my concern was an NIP coming out to me 'automatically', without any human eyes actually looking at the images to see that I was only doing 25 in a 30.

Never heard anything though, so I now believe there is a greater element of 'checking' to this than I previously thought.
Update at march 4, 2008 - did not hear anything so maybe there is a greater element of checking. That's encouraging.

rdjohn

7,196 posts

226 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
Not every Gatso, or Truvelo, box has a camera inside it - they, and their radars, are very expensive and so are often rotated between sites. When the box is without camera, it is common practice to install a low cost radar that triggers the flash, to keep motorists on their guard, otherwise speeds will tend to increase again.

When fully digital cameras are used, they are permanently connected for enforcment

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
someone set fire to one local to me, now it has a nice blue tarpaulin over it

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Tuesday 4th March 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
If you were traveling at 30, the graduation marks on the road will confirm that on the photo and you will not receive a letter.
Not quite true, in the case below the motorist received the FPN and had to fight it himself by proving with the use of the graduation marks that he was only doing 13 mph.


"The accuracy of speed cameras has been called into question after a man clocked at over 50mph proved he was actually travelling well under the limit.
Kris Haskins said he was amazed to receive a penalty notice from the Dorset Road Safety Camera partnership, accusing him of driving at 51mph in a 30mph zone in Sandford, near Wareham.

Mr Haskins obtained the photographs used as evidence and was able to work out with the aid of the internet that his actual speed was just 13.2mph.

The partnership says the error was due to the camera's radar being triggered by a reflected image.

Mr Haskins, who is deputy mayor of Portland Town Council, told the BBC: "The first thing was to obtain the photographs from the police, and when I'd got those the only way was to go onto the internet and work the distances out."

The camera partnership has apologised for the error, saying it was "an extremely rare occurrence and a known radar phenomenon".

Mr Haskins said he thought it was likely other drivers had been wrongly penalised.

He said many people would not know they could check it themselves, as the fixed penalty notices did not make it clear that it was possible to obtain the film from the camera".