Discussion
I happened to be on the M3 this morning inside the M25 when I spotted a HATO parked up on one of the raised ramp things previously designated for police only. Now they've relaxed them to "official use only", these HATOs seem to be able to park too.
He was on the westbound carriageway, I was travelling east and in my mirror I saw a mexican wave of brake lights from the light/medium traffic approaching his position.
Now I understand these guys are supposed to be handy for when they're called upon to help, but surely they should be cruising about with the traffic or parked out of sight?
By blatently pretending to be the police, aren't they causing an increased risk of tailgating related accidents or some other panic induced feckery?
Is it in their remit to pretend to be a police car watching the cars go by?
SM
He was on the westbound carriageway, I was travelling east and in my mirror I saw a mexican wave of brake lights from the light/medium traffic approaching his position.
Now I understand these guys are supposed to be handy for when they're called upon to help, but surely they should be cruising about with the traffic or parked out of sight?
By blatently pretending to be the police, aren't they causing an increased risk of tailgating related accidents or some other panic induced feckery?
Is it in their remit to pretend to be a police car watching the cars go by?
SM
I cant understand why people who are travelling below the limit feel the need to slam their brakes on when seeing this, whether it be Police or HATO. I can understand the ones who are over the limit, and thats probably a knock on further back which eventually slows the traffic down to well under what it was going at.
Coming back to the question, I'd say thats a pretty safe place to take a break, keep an eye on the traffic and are ready to go if they get a call. Dont have a problem with it personally - I think the problem there lies with drivers on the carriageway
Coming back to the question, I'd say thats a pretty safe place to take a break, keep an eye on the traffic and are ready to go if they get a call. Dont have a problem with it personally - I think the problem there lies with drivers on the carriageway
supermono said:
I happened to be on the M3 this morning inside the M25 when I spotted a HATO parked up on one of the raised ramp things previously designated for police only. Now they've relaxed them to "official use only", these HATOs seem to be able to park too.
He was on the westbound carriageway, I was travelling east and in my mirror I saw a mexican wave of brake lights from the light/medium traffic approaching his position.
Now I understand these guys are supposed to be handy for when they're called upon to help, but surely they should be cruising about with the traffic or parked out of sight?
By blatently pretending to be the police, aren't they causing an increased risk of tailgating related accidents or some other panic induced feckery?
Is it in their remit to pretend to be a police car watching the cars go by?
SM
Given that they are funded by my taxes, and the current price of fuel, the longer they remain stationary the better!!He was on the westbound carriageway, I was travelling east and in my mirror I saw a mexican wave of brake lights from the light/medium traffic approaching his position.
Now I understand these guys are supposed to be handy for when they're called upon to help, but surely they should be cruising about with the traffic or parked out of sight?
By blatently pretending to be the police, aren't they causing an increased risk of tailgating related accidents or some other panic induced feckery?
Is it in their remit to pretend to be a police car watching the cars go by?
SM
andy_quantum said:
I think the problem there lies with drivers on the carriageway
Oh without a doubt. However, the presence of the HATO may catalyse an accident that may otherwise not happen. And that's a bad thing. Especially since the people laying on their brakes are afraid they'll be nicked when in actual fact they won't -- not by a HATO.Anything that can be done to reduce the chances of an accident happening should be done, and IMO parking a pseudo policecar in a police observation spot does the reverse.
SM
streaky said:
andy_quantum said:
I cant understand why people who are travelling below the limit feel the need to slam their brakes on when seeing this, whether it be Police or HATO.
Instinctive licence-preservation reaction - StreakyDepending on which car I'm in, I sometimes find it easier to monitor my speed on engine revs or TomTom than the actual speedo if it's just a quick confirmation check. I know what revs the engine should be at for the speed limit and gear I'm in, and it could be that those under the limit are woken up to either everyone else braking or the sight of a marked/liveried up vehicle stopped on the side of the road, so immediate response is to brake rather than observe.
From experience (being in the job HATO)I do not use these points or stay on the hard shoulder any longer than required.
The emergency lights + battenburg are like moths to a flame.
Ive seen and heard of too many incident involving EMS (and HATO) vehicles. Therefore these points are a bit no no for me unless the particular job you are on dictates to use them.
The emergency lights + battenburg are like moths to a flame.
Ive seen and heard of too many incident involving EMS (and HATO) vehicles. Therefore these points are a bit no no for me unless the particular job you are on dictates to use them.
Breaking will always be a natural reaction as we know that speed cameras can have slip effect which over reads the actual speed.
We are guilty until proven innocent, so would you drive past a camera at 70? No - you slow down to 65 or so "just in case" you are being hit by a dodgeyscope. How cheated would you feel when you get done for say 76 when you had seen the camera, and checked your speed to be 70. You have no defence as that is always dismissed, so the only way to avoid being caught nowadays is to make sure you alter your speed to well under the limit to ensure that even the worst dodgeyscope can't increase the reading into ticketing zone ...
We are guilty until proven innocent, so would you drive past a camera at 70? No - you slow down to 65 or so "just in case" you are being hit by a dodgeyscope. How cheated would you feel when you get done for say 76 when you had seen the camera, and checked your speed to be 70. You have no defence as that is always dismissed, so the only way to avoid being caught nowadays is to make sure you alter your speed to well under the limit to ensure that even the worst dodgeyscope can't increase the reading into ticketing zone ...
andy400 said:
I find it very easy to distinguish HATOs from BiB
Yes it's not that hard. But given the number of brake lights I saw you and I are in the minority. Whilst they deliberately try to look like police and whilst they deliberately fail to notify the public they are not police and have little/no police powers, they will continue to represent an increase in the balance of danger by parking up on a police podium and causing panic. That's my point.
SM
supermono said:
andy400 said:
I find it very easy to distinguish HATOs from BiB
Yes it's not that hard. But given the number of brake lights I saw you and I are in the minority. Whilst they deliberately try to look like police and whilst they deliberately fail to notify the public they are not police and have little/no police powers, they will continue to represent an increase in the balance of danger by parking up on a police podium and causing panic. That's my point.
SM
"...I'm pissed off at the wits who think a HATO/Hi-Viz clad rider/white bike rider is plod. Use your feckin' eyes."
"if you cant spot the difference between them a a plod can i suggest specsavers?"
Personally, at night, If I see anything hi-vis in the distance, I initially think it's the police. From what I have seen on the roads, so do the vast majority of others.
I wish I were superhuman like many others on here.
Davevx220 said:
From experience (being in the job HATO)I do not use these points or stay on the hard shoulder any longer than required.
As a HATO, do you think you would be able to provide just as effective a service if your vehicles were liveried in a more distinguishable manner?Personally I see two sides to this coin, I'm not anti-HATO. I'm just interested in the opinion of a person with a real insight into the role.
Oh dear, I've answered these questions so many times...............
2 points made;..............
They look like police.
Yes they do from a distance, but that is so that they have an "air of authority" when having to put traffic management, rolling road blocks, etc. into place. no-one would bat an eyelid at a white transit!
Sitting on police perches.
They do not sit on these to take breaks, they will be there ready to assist with a job further up the c/way, ajoining m/way, should another patrol be required for a rolling block or lane closure etc.
They could also sit on the top of a junction, for the same reason.
Only as a very last resort will they sit on the H/S as it's the most dangerous place on the motorway, and a number of HATO vehicles have been hit whilst offering protection to members of the public broken down on the H/S, putting officers into hospital.
2 points made;..............
They look like police.
Yes they do from a distance, but that is so that they have an "air of authority" when having to put traffic management, rolling road blocks, etc. into place. no-one would bat an eyelid at a white transit!
Sitting on police perches.
They do not sit on these to take breaks, they will be there ready to assist with a job further up the c/way, ajoining m/way, should another patrol be required for a rolling block or lane closure etc.
They could also sit on the top of a junction, for the same reason.
Only as a very last resort will they sit on the H/S as it's the most dangerous place on the motorway, and a number of HATO vehicles have been hit whilst offering protection to members of the public broken down on the H/S, putting officers into hospital.
Gafferjim said:
They look like police.
Yes they do from a distance, but that is so that they have an "air of authority" when having to put traffic management, rolling road blocks, etc. into place. no-one would bat an eyelid at a white transit!
Agreed, and that is one side of the coin I can see, however if public awareness of HATOs was raised livery could be changed to provide their own unique identity e.g. red and illuminous yellow. Yes they do from a distance, but that is so that they have an "air of authority" when having to put traffic management, rolling road blocks, etc. into place. no-one would bat an eyelid at a white transit!
That would still give an 'air of authority' but without the potentially dangerous confusion with the police (in fact in that case they may look like fire officers although that is still better than the police).
Maybe some of these 'Think!' adverts should publicise the work of HATOs rather than having this mysterious sub-police force seemingly rolled out in secret and confusing the general (i.e. not an informed community like PH) public.
supermono said:
By blatently pretending to be the police, aren't they causing an increased risk of tailgating related accidents or some other panic induced feckery?
Well, how about this. Let's get rid of HATOs and get proper Roads Policing coppers back out there.And they can park on the obs posts.
And they can cause panic braking.
Problem solved.
Edited by Vaux on Monday 7th January 16:32
streaky said:
andy_quantum said:
I cant understand why people who are travelling below the limit feel the need to slam their brakes on when seeing this, whether it be Police or HATO.
Instinctive licence-preservation reaction - StreakyHell i slow down whenever i see any van/car/person etc on a motorway bridge even when i know i am below the limit. Loosing a driving licence where i live would basically be game over. No public transport for miles
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


