DB9, Porsche 997 Turbo or Ferrari 612?
DB9, Porsche 997 Turbo or Ferrari 612?
Author
Discussion

Melly_1

Original Poster:

10 posts

225 months

Tuesday 8th January 2008
quotequote all
Looking for some guidance/opinions and help on which of the above we should buy.

Requirements:
Looking at 3 year old cars with 2+2 seats (not optional!), it's got to be suitable for every day use.
We need to fit a baby and a 7 year old in the back.
Don't like the image of the Bentley GT.

Thanks.

Troesma

432 posts

244 months

Tuesday 8th January 2008
quotequote all
DB9 and 997... you've gotta be kidding..! Only usable 2+2s in the market are the 612 (pretty usable in the back) and the Maser's (GT, GS and the 4200 Coupe).

I have fit a Group 1+ and a Group 1-3 car seats in the Maser with no probs whatsoever... some ppl here can give testament of that, as I drove once to a meet with my (then) 3 yr old daughter.

HTH

CUE99T

1,021 posts

238 months

Tuesday 8th January 2008
quotequote all
997 a bit pricey still........lots of depn still to come......

DB9 becoming decent purchase price, and sounds nice, but older image IMO.....

Masa Gransport, great car, not bad build quality, different, and sounds the bollox in sport mode, lots of space in back for adults or children!!

612, still depn, and V12 running costs won't be cheap I think.


Tried an M5 or RS6?




Jules360

1,949 posts

232 months

Tuesday 8th January 2008
quotequote all
Vanquish ?

Rods

1,798 posts

283 months

Tuesday 8th January 2008
quotequote all
M6?? Absolute bargains at the moment.

bertie

8,569 posts

314 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
Rods said:
M6?? Absolute bargains at the moment.
A BMW isn't in the same bracket as a Ferrari / Aston/ Porsche / Maserati though is it.

Personaly I'd go for a 612 is you can, awesome machines.

blot

1,308 posts

267 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
Don't think I've ever seen a 612 on the road in england, seen a couple in dealers. Have seen plenty of them in Monaco, seem to have been the ubermotorwaycruiser choice for a couple of years over there, certainly wouldn't say no to one out of the OP's choice smile

mhedleyrob

160 posts

234 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
In my humble opinion (having driven all of these cars a few times) this is a no brainer:

1. BMWs - ah, no.

2. Ferrari 612 - not as involving as you would expect. Rather big and lumbering (as all 4 seat Ferraris seem to be), depreciates like a stone and a fortune to run. Good looking in a Sarah Jessica Parker sort of way.

3. Aston DB9 - very pretty, bit older in the tooth, some build quality issues giving nigly faults, and again expensive to run. Very good looking though.

4. 997 Turbo - very reliable, cheap to run (by supercar standards) and still fairly desirable in the 2nd hand market. But you will be a 'Porsche' driver - either loved or loathed.

Porsche it is then. Good luck hunting.







mhedleyrob

160 posts

234 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
mhedleyrob said:
In my humble opinion (having driven all of these cars a few times) this is a no brainer:

1. BMWs - ah, no.

2. Ferrari 612 - not as involving as you would expect. Rather big and lumbering (as all 4 seat Ferraris seem to be), depreciates like a stone and a fortune to run. Good looking in a Sarah Jessica Parker sort of way.

3. Aston DB9 - very pretty, bit older in the tooth, some build quality issues giving nigly faults, and again expensive to run. Very good looking though.

4. 997 Turbo - very reliable, cheap to run (by supercar standards) and still fairly desirable in the 2nd hand market. But you will be a 'Porsche' driver - either loved or loathed.

Porsche it is then. Good luck hunting.

ps. you will need to chop the legs off anyone travelling in the back of a DB9.

bertie

8,569 posts

314 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
Are 911s any good in the back?

Do you not need the same home amputation kit?

mhedleyrob

160 posts

234 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
bertie said:
Are 911s any good in the back?

Do you not need the same home amputation kit?
I used to run 911s when my kids were young with no problems at all. We are talking 7 and under here. Admitedly my current one is not much use in this regard.

Don't get me wrong, I am not an out and out Porsche fan. It just seemed the best car to get at the time.

Maybe the new Granturismo might be the future answer as no one seems to have cracked the 4 seat sportscar emigma yet.

tony h

2,703 posts

276 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
maser gt smile

bertie

8,569 posts

314 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
mhedleyrob said:
bertie said:
Are 911s any good in the back?

Do you not need the same home amputation kit?
I used to run 911s when my kids were young with no problems at all. We are talking 7 and under here. Admitedly my current one is not much use in this regard.

Don't get me wrong, I am not an out and out Porsche fan. It just seemed the best car to get at the time.

Maybe the new Granturismo might be the future answer as no one seems to have cracked the 4 seat sportscar emigma yet.
Interesting.

A genuine question as with a 6 year old and a 2 year old I am in that position myself.

Are the rear seat in 911 cabs the same?

mhedleyrob

160 posts

234 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
bertie said:
mhedleyrob said:
bertie said:
Are 911s any good in the back?

Do you not need the same home amputation kit?
I used to run 911s when my kids were young with no problems at all. We are talking 7 and under here. Admitedly my current one is not much use in this regard.

Don't get me wrong, I am not an out and out Porsche fan. It just seemed the best car to get at the time.

Maybe the new Granturismo might be the future answer as no one seems to have cracked the 4 seat sportscar emigma yet.
Interesting.

A genuine question as with a 6 year old and a 2 year old I am in that position myself.

Are the rear seat in 911 cabs the same?
To be honest I haven't owned or driven one. I assume it must be like most convertibles with rather limited space.

The only real problem with owning a coupe like these as a main vehicle is that the kids can sometimes struggle to see out of the rear windows - as long as you don't mind 'are we there yet?' after about 5 miles then you are ok.

Also my wife likes to drive a Porsche. Hated the Ferraris and Aston (manual) to drive. But then maybe that's a good thing !

tony h

2,703 posts

276 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
bertie said:
mhedleyrob said:
bertie said:
Are 911s any good in the back?

Do you not need the same home amputation kit?
I used to run 911s when my kids were young with no problems at all. We are talking 7 and under here. Admitedly my current one is not much use in this regard.

Don't get me wrong, I am not an out and out Porsche fan. It just seemed the best car to get at the time.

Maybe the new Granturismo might be the future answer as no one seems to have cracked the 4 seat sportscar emigma yet.
Interesting.

A genuine question as with a 6 year old and a 2 year old I am in that position myself.

Are the rear seat in 911 cabs the same?
only owned 993 cabs but the back seats were truly a waste of time. the belts were pretty crap too so attaching a child seat was hard work. i'm sure the current cars have isofix fittings and car's a touch bigger so things might have improved a bit biggrin

MogulBoy

3,066 posts

253 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
CLS55AMG?

DB9 would appear to have zero rear leg room, even for childern but Aston put the seats in there as market research said it was the right thing to do. My guess is that some customers find it hard to "justify" expense on a 2 seater but 2+2 get's the green light!

flow99

1,336 posts

238 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
Vanquish?

If you're looking 612's at £100k, then there's plenty of Vanquish's avaialble at this price.

far better than a DB9, and can squeeze a smidgen more space in the rear, even managed to get a freind's 15y/o in the back for a short journey in one.

Otherwise, would have to be a 997TT for me, but then I'm lurking from the Porsche fraternity!!

Ade355

337 posts

270 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
612 definately !!

Dont blame you regarding Bentley GT - Terrible, terrible, terrible image.

Leggera

29 posts

252 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
Recently sold Db9 - great car but just not practical spacewise if you have kids. Ditto 997. 612 an aquired taste and different but have been witness to a number of major mechanical probs with them. Maser GT good option but depreciation likely to be hefty. Bentley - a lot of car for your money s/h - but doesn't rock my boat. I'm waiting for prices of s/h CL 63 AMGs to reach a reasonable level - space, pace and a certain grace - all wrapped up in a fairly anonymous package - which in my book is a good thing, or for half the money may go for the new C63 AMG Estate - surely when comparing with all the above an absolute bargain when it comes to 'bangs for your bucks'?

ted 191

1,469 posts

255 months

Wednesday 9th January 2008
quotequote all
My 11/7 year olds fit in the 997 coupe ok, but not in a cab as the seat backs are verticle and uncomfortable after a short distance