Discussion
I was driving home from work today when i passed a police car in the countryside,the car followed through a villiage then onwards for four or five miles before pulling me over,they got me to rev the engine then reved it themselves before declairing it was too loud and that i would have to refit the standard backbox,one of them was wearing a boilersuit with some initials on it one of which was a v i think,when i asked was it definetly too loud,as no measuring equipment was used the policeman said he thought it was and the guy in the boilersuit said anything above standard was too loud but i dont think this is true is it are there not decibel limits according to year manufactured etc,the car is a 1992 sierra glsi 2.0 dohc with a custom chrome straight through backbox and a k&n induction kit is there a chance it is not too loud and if i ignore the request to change it back what penaltys do i risk as no written notice was issued,thanks for any help.
GreenV8S said:
I think the BiB was right to say that it shouldn't be louder than standard. VOSA would give you the definitive answer.
If he didn't give you a rectification notice then presumably he has no intention of checking you've done what he said.
Have some spare for next time: . . . . . .
I think the guy that said it shouldnt be louder than standard was posibly from vosa as i said he had a boilersuit with a v on it but isnt their a decibel limit rather than if its not standard its illegal?If he didn't give you a rectification notice then presumably he has no intention of checking you've done what he said.
Have some spare for next time: . . . . . .
Hi 
This is something I know a LOT about as I probably have the LOUDEST Porsche in the UK....
OK Some facts first....
NO Police officer has a Decibel meter
NO MOT station has a Decibel meter
NO Main Ministry station has a Decibel meter
Because...THERE IS NO LEGAL DECIBEL LIMIT !
I do...lol
The MOT centres CANNOT fail you on an MOT on noise...no matter how loud it is..
The relevant MOT section says you must NOT have a leaking exhaust or exhaust boxes and it must be gas tight, but nothing about noise...that applies whatever exhaust you have fitted and also if you have NO exhaust fitted (believe it or not)
So in theory you could take your car for an MOT on headers and it must pass as you have no leaks etc etc...
A car does NOT have to have a "standard" manufacturers exhaust on it at all...
But now to the sensible bit...
If I sat outside a Macdonalds revving the whatsits off my engine and I was reported, the police would not do me for a loud exhaust but WOULD do me for something like "public nuisance" or similar...
Noise is not very well covered in the regulations to be honest and its a bit of a grey area...
If you are not a 19 year old chav and being silly then I doubt you will get prosecuted...
Edited to add....after 1992 an MOT centre could fail you for no cats though,but that doesnt apply to earlier cars...I am pretty sure a police vehicle examiner could manage a charge from that as well although I dont know what exactly, probably something under "construction and use" etc..
All the best Brett

This is something I know a LOT about as I probably have the LOUDEST Porsche in the UK....
OK Some facts first....
NO Police officer has a Decibel meter
NO MOT station has a Decibel meter
NO Main Ministry station has a Decibel meter
Because...THERE IS NO LEGAL DECIBEL LIMIT !
I do...lol
The MOT centres CANNOT fail you on an MOT on noise...no matter how loud it is..
The relevant MOT section says you must NOT have a leaking exhaust or exhaust boxes and it must be gas tight, but nothing about noise...that applies whatever exhaust you have fitted and also if you have NO exhaust fitted (believe it or not)
So in theory you could take your car for an MOT on headers and it must pass as you have no leaks etc etc...
A car does NOT have to have a "standard" manufacturers exhaust on it at all...
But now to the sensible bit...
If I sat outside a Macdonalds revving the whatsits off my engine and I was reported, the police would not do me for a loud exhaust but WOULD do me for something like "public nuisance" or similar...
Noise is not very well covered in the regulations to be honest and its a bit of a grey area...
If you are not a 19 year old chav and being silly then I doubt you will get prosecuted...
Edited to add....after 1992 an MOT centre could fail you for no cats though,but that doesnt apply to earlier cars...I am pretty sure a police vehicle examiner could manage a charge from that as well although I dont know what exactly, probably something under "construction and use" etc..
All the best Brett

Edited by Brett928S2 on Friday 15th February 18:23
Edited by Brett928S2 on Friday 15th February 18:37
From:
http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/Motoring/OwningAVehicl...
Components tested during your MOT test:
Exhaust system - complete, secure, without serious leaks and silences effectively
What the hell "silences effectively" actually means I have no idea but the implication is clear!
http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/Motoring/OwningAVehicl...
Components tested during your MOT test:
Exhaust system - complete, secure, without serious leaks and silences effectively
What the hell "silences effectively" actually means I have no idea but the implication is clear!
Brett928S2 said:
Hi 
This is something I know a LOT about as I probably have the LOUDEST Porsche in the UK....
OK Some facts first....
NO Police officer has a Decibel meter
NO MOT station has a Decibel meter
NO Main Ministry station has a Decibel meter
Because...THERE IS NO LEGAL DECIBEL LIMIT !
I do...lol
The MOT centres CANNOT fail you on an MOT on noise...no matter how loud it is..
The relevant MOT section says you must NOT have a leaking exhaust or exhaust boxes and it must be gas tight, but nothing about noise...that applies whatever exhaust you have fitted and also if you have NO exhaust fitted (believe it or not)
So in theory you could take your car for an MOT on headers and it must pass as you have no leaks etc etc...
A car does NOT have to have a "standard" manufacturers exhaust on it at all...
But now to the sensible bit...
If I sat outside a Macdonalds revving the whatsits off my engine and I was reported, the police would not do me for a loud exhaust but WOULD do me for something like "public nuisance" or similar...
Noise is not very well covered in the regulations to be honest and its a bit of a grey area...
If you are not a 19 year old chav and being silly then I doubt you will get prosecuted...
Edited to add....after 1992 an MOT centre could fail you for no cats though,but that doesnt apply to earlier cars...I am pretty sure a police vehicle examiner could manage a charge from that as well although I dont know what exactly, probably something under "construction and use" etc..
All the best Brett
So does this mean if they say its too loud then thats it i have to take it off or risk a fine or something similar,you say no police officer has a decibel meter but it stated in our local paper recently that the police had just taken delivery of noise measuring equipment for cars to deter boy racers?
This is something I know a LOT about as I probably have the LOUDEST Porsche in the UK....
OK Some facts first....
NO Police officer has a Decibel meter
NO MOT station has a Decibel meter
NO Main Ministry station has a Decibel meter
Because...THERE IS NO LEGAL DECIBEL LIMIT !
I do...lol
The MOT centres CANNOT fail you on an MOT on noise...no matter how loud it is..
The relevant MOT section says you must NOT have a leaking exhaust or exhaust boxes and it must be gas tight, but nothing about noise...that applies whatever exhaust you have fitted and also if you have NO exhaust fitted (believe it or not)
So in theory you could take your car for an MOT on headers and it must pass as you have no leaks etc etc...
A car does NOT have to have a "standard" manufacturers exhaust on it at all...
But now to the sensible bit...
If I sat outside a Macdonalds revving the whatsits off my engine and I was reported, the police would not do me for a loud exhaust but WOULD do me for something like "public nuisance" or similar...
Noise is not very well covered in the regulations to be honest and its a bit of a grey area...
If you are not a 19 year old chav and being silly then I doubt you will get prosecuted...
Edited to add....after 1992 an MOT centre could fail you for no cats though,but that doesnt apply to earlier cars...I am pretty sure a police vehicle examiner could manage a charge from that as well although I dont know what exactly, probably something under "construction and use" etc..
All the best Brett

Edited by Brett928S2 on Friday 15th February 18:23
Edited by Brett928S2 on Friday 15th February 18:37
Brett928S2 said:
Edited to add....after 1992 an MOT centre could fail you for no cats though,but that doesnt apply to earlier cars...
There is no MOT test for the presence of cats. There are emissions tests which are not practical to pass without cats fitted and working, but there's no explicit requirement to have cats fitted and no test for them being fitted.I thought the noise restriction limits were under construction and use regs. There's no 'standard' i.e. uniform upper limit that all cars have to stay under, but I have the idea that there IS a requirement under C&R that it is not substantially noisier than standard. However, VOSA would be the place for an authoritative answer. This is definitely not tested during the MOT, but the MOT test doesn't say whether it is road legal and doesn't test everything that is required for it to be road legal.
stewartcampbell said:
So does this mean if they say its too loud then thats it i have to take it off or risk a fine or something similar,you say no police officer has a decibel meter but it stated in our local paper recently that the police had just taken delivery of noise measuring equipment for cars to deter boy racers?
If they give you a rectification notice you have to fix it.If they walk up to you and say "fix it pretty please" you might choose to fix it but they haven't taken any steps to force you to. Perhaps they will take action against you if you run into them again, but at the moment they haven't done.
Vixpy1 said:
I was speaking to a tester today, and he informed me they can now fail an MOT for an excessively noisy exhaust.
can you ask him what the limit is?how they test etc?
not being funny but if I got pulled for a loud exhaust (hardly possible on my current steed!) i wouldn't be very polite about it at all.
DucatiGary said:
Vixpy1 said:
I was speaking to a tester today, and he informed me they can now fail an MOT for an excessively noisy exhaust.
can you ask him what the limit is?how they test etc?
not being funny but if I got pulled for a loud exhaust (hardly possible on my current steed!) i wouldn't be very polite about it at all.

Ask them the db limit as laid down in law and you'll willingly comply

TheGriffalo said:
DucatiGary said:
Vixpy1 said:
I was speaking to a tester today, and he informed me they can now fail an MOT for an excessively noisy exhaust.
can you ask him what the limit is?how they test etc?
not being funny but if I got pulled for a loud exhaust (hardly possible on my current steed!) i wouldn't be very polite about it at all.

Ask them the db limit as laid down in law and you'll willingly comply

DucatiGary said:
TheGriffalo said:
DucatiGary said:
Vixpy1 said:
I was speaking to a tester today, and he informed me they can now fail an MOT for an excessively noisy exhaust.
can you ask him what the limit is?how they test etc?
not being funny but if I got pulled for a loud exhaust (hardly possible on my current steed!) i wouldn't be very polite about it at all.

Ask them the db limit as laid down in law and you'll willingly comply

dougc said:
Vixpy1 said:
I was speaking to a tester today, and he informed me they can now fail an MOT for an excessively noisy exhaust.
You use the wrong tester. The bloke that does mine is happy to have something that sounds like a car rather than a hairdryer when the Tiv goes in 
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


