Need advice ...
Author
Discussion

bones33

Original Poster:

411 posts

226 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
Ok sold a car last year to an 18 year old.

Sent of my part of the V5 form to DVLA and as i was getting married not long after had a lot on my mind and did not notice that i did not get the usual reply from them.

6 months later get the 80 pound fine from themselves.

K now its starts i wrote to them saying that i had sold the car blar blar and showed them proof from bank statements of the car going in and out of my bank. Gave them the number of the boy who i sold the car to and the firm he worked for.

I then get a reply from then saying thanks for my reply but i still need to pay the 80 pound.

This anoys me so i write to them again saying....If i pay this 80 pound is this not agreeing that i still own the vehicle and that every 6 months i will get a fine. I did some cheaks on the car to see if it was not insured and did not have a valid MOT. It did not have either so sent this with the letter stating... Instead of chasing me should you not be worrying about the 18 year old running around without any Tax, Mot or insurance which i have given you details of where he lives, works and his mobile.

I get a letter back saying... Thank you for your details but you still need to pay the 80 pound fine.

Like OMG they still did not answer my question. So i thought i would ask for some advice here.

Am i liable for the 80 pounds?
Am i liable again in 6 months and continued?
What if i do not pay this 80 pounds. what will they do come cube a vehicle i do not own?

Thanks for you time as this is beyond me how they can target someone whos always payed for everything on time.

Edited by bones33 on Tuesday 26th February 09:27

MarcusRx8

22 posts

225 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
O_o interesting.

My personal suggestion would be to ring citizens advice bureau and ask where you stand legally. I would think that if you can prove beyond reasonable doubt that the car is not yours anymore then I do not understand why the DVLA are still chasing you for this £80. You have sent off your registration documents? did you send this recorded? Sounds sad when someone gets caught out like this.

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
Perhaps worth writing back one more time, keeping it VERY concise. Along the lines of: -

"1) I sold the car to xxxxxxx of xxx Road, employed by xxxxxx, on Day of Month 2007.

2) I posted to you the part of the V5 required on Day of Month 2007. If necessary I am willing to make a sworn statement to this effect.

As a result, I have already fulfilled all my legal obligations in this matter, and as far as I am concerned no fine is due from me as the car was no longer registered to me. Any more requests for money in this matter will be treated as unnecessary harassment - and I will act accordingly."


Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
Perhaps worth writing back one more time, keeping it VERY concise. Along the lines of: -

"1) I sold the car to xxxxxxx of xxx Road, employed by xxxxxx, on Day of Month 2007.

2) I posted to you the part of the V5 required on Day of Month 2007. If necessary I am willing to make a sworn statement to this effect.

As a result, I have already fulfilled all my legal obligations in this matter, and as far as I am concerned no fine is due from me as the car was no longer registered to me. Any more requests for money in this matter will be treated as unnecessary harassment - and I will act accordingly."
That would be my course of action as well. You've done what you're required to do, hopefully you have either

1. Proof of posting of the V5
2. Photocopy of the V5 you sent

If not, a sworn statement will suffice.

Also ask for the name of their data protection officer.

Derek Smith

50,026 posts

279 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
"You must notify the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) of the exact date of sale or transfer of your vehicle using the registration document or certificate. You and the buyer should follow the procedures correctly or you will remain liable for the vehicle until DVLA records have been updated."

The £80 fine is probably for failing to notify the DVLA of the fact you sold the vehicle. The only defence to this is if you have proof that you posted the V5 part filled in correctly (if you failed to fill it in correctly, you can still be fined).

Unless you have evidence that you did post the document then I would suggest that you have little option but to pay. At the same time you can include notification of sale of your vehicle in the same envelope so if they cash your cheque you have proof they received it.

However, as it is not on the correct form there may well be further documentation you will be required to complete.

I am unaware of any on-line form that can be completed in this case. www.dvla.gov.uk  It's not the easiest of websites to find a specific document on.

Request acknowledgement of receipt of the notification of sale/transfer.

Stable door and bolting horses time: when selling your car, if there is no acknowledgement of receipt of the V5 ater four weeks, write to the DVLA using registered post or similar, saying that you have sent it and have they received it. This 'covers' you in any future argument about liability as it is taken as proof of posting the original document.

bones33

Original Poster:

411 posts

226 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
Thanks very much for your advice in all this.

I unfortunatley i have no proof of posting *i know my bad* so i think i will pay the 80 and fight for them to write in writting to me that the car is sold.

Thanks again.

Edited by bones33 on Tuesday 26th February 10:17

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
bones33 said:
Thanks very much for your advice in all this.

I unfortunatley i have no proof of posting *i know my bad* so i think i will pay the 80 and fight for them to write in writting to me that the car is sold.

Thanks again.
In the first instance I really REALLY would not pay and then try to argue. If you have (and it seems you do) a valid reason to believe you have complied in every way you need to, then it's perfectly reasonable for you to explain this and have them bin the fine.

It's not your responsibility to prove you sent it - although as stated, you can still do this even without having an "actual proof of postage" IYSWIM. You have told them that you have...that's all you *should* need to do. Don't be forced to pay just because of their (likely) admin error...unless you think that it might have been *your* admin error.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
It would appear you have fallen foul of the expired Licence/No sorn £80 supplement.

DVLA have no power to impose a supplement for failing to notify change of ownership - it is a criminal offence and therefore has to be dealt with by Magistrates Court.

The car was sold. At this time I presume a current Licence was in force but apparently with little shelf life. Whilst in the possession of the new owner the Licence expired and was not immediately renewed neither was SORN completed. At the end of the month plus days DVLA did a computor cull and came up the vehicle unlicensed and un sorned so supplement off to the REG KEEPER - the Poster.

Authority for this course of action:

http://www.tinyurl.com/wslq

The only way to get out of this is to convince DVLA that you were not the owner at the time the Licence expired so you had no obligation to relicence or declare SORN. That lay with the new Keeper.

If change of ownership was notified by the poster and DVLA claim no, then refer them to Section 7 Interpretation Act 1978 :

Where an Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post (whether the expression “serve” or the expression “give” or “send” or ANY OTHER other expression is used) then, unless the contrary intention appears, the service is deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting a letter containing the document and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post.

Road Vehicles (Reg & Lic) Regs, 2002 requires V5 to be delivered to DVLA on change of ownership.

Back to them to prove to the contrary?

dvd

Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Tuesday 26th February 15:01

Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
Back to them to prove to the contrary?

dvd
Indeed. It is the argument used by Scamera Partnerships but in reverse.


bones33

Original Poster:

411 posts

226 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
ok i have sent them a letter stating all of above and i am not paying them anything yet.

I have asked them to reply by the 6th as this is the due date so i shall keep you all informed.

Much thanks again it was very upsetting the treatment i was getting with no way of discussing this as they say "all arugments must be done via paper".

Thanks again

Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Tuesday 26th February 2008
quotequote all
bones33 said:
Much thanks again it was very upsetting the treatment i was getting with no way of discussing this as they say "all arugments must be done via paper".
Tell them you charge £25 per letter.

SLCZ3

1,295 posts

236 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
bones33 said:
showed them proof from bank statements of the car going in and out of my bank. Gave [/footnote]
So how does that work then??scratchchin

SLCZ3

1,295 posts

236 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
bones33 said:
showed them proof from bank statements of the car going in and out of my bank. Gave [/footnote]
So how does that work then??scratchchin

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
SLCZ3 said:
bones33 said:
showed them proof from bank statements of the car going in and out of my bank. Gave [/footnote]
So how does that work then??scratchchin
It was on camera in the bank...


I think he mean the sale of car.

He sent off the form to inform of the sale.


They once send us new licence after a water burst destroy Ted' old paper licence in cubboard in room below. It get lost in post. When asking about it.. they said "it not their responsibility once it go in post bag. It onus of Royal Mail und not for them to prove posting" even though this ist important document which can be used to steal an identity confused

So :sctatchchin: They not have to provide proof .. but everyone else has to? rolleyes

His word against theirs in court. He said he sent it. They said they not receive it. It has then got lost in post und thus out of his hands.


He does not have the official form any more as this lost in post now. Other party must not have sent his part of the paperwork. rolleyes He has written to tell them. He speaking to a computer. rolleyes


kazgti

3 posts

223 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi
I have also been caught by DVLA after over 25 years of motoring. I part exchanged a car at a dealer 28 August 07 leaving on it 5 months road tax. I have just received £80 fine which it seems you CANNOT contest. Does not matter what happened to the yellow slip it seems. I have asked Carcraft to send my written proof with reg number and fact that they took car in with the tax (DVLA should surely have a record that I purchased it and to whom they sent a refund, which they must have if it was not taxed on 21 Sept 07, date of said offence).
I have no problem with them sending fines to people to don't pay at all, but where is this fair?
I'm a lone parent, I set aside money to cover insurance, tax etc., I don't have the money to pay this even if I wanted to.
The worst thing is these people don't even want to listen, computer has produced a fine, your name was still down as owner for whatever reason and thats that.
Any other ideas or advice be really appreciated.
Karen

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
If its any consolation despite having sent mine off I also got one of these fines. Nothing I said got me out. I paid. Not happy but I do agree with the aims of the legislation as it will eventually cut down on properly un-registered vehicles.

Howitzer

2,865 posts

247 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
I had this on a MK1 Golf I sold to a friend.

I phoned them up in the end and the lady on the phone sorted it out. A previous phonecall my Mum made on my beahlf as I was away working ended up with her speaking to a tt who was being deliberately unhelpful.

Dave!

kazgti

3 posts

223 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi Dave
Sounds like I spoke to same person that your Mum did lol.
I did think of something else. They refunded the tax I paid for before 21 Sept obviously, so whoever got the refund it was not me, therefore, that person must have signed a form to say that the vehicle was now with them. If they believed at that time I was still the owner I should surely be entitled to the road tax refund.
Thanks for replies on this, will post if I have any success, but surely there is another way of doing things without charging fines on people that are actually doing the right thing.
Next time yellow slip goes into envelope with recorded delivery!! Calender gets marked for four weeks after event and DVLA gets phone call.
Thanks again all
Karen

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
... I do agree with the aims of the legislation as it will eventually cut down on properly un-registered vehicles.
We've had SORN for, ooh, 10 years now? I would define 'eventually' as much less than a decade wink , meself. Of course, the only people that get stung like this are the honest majority who previously registered the car to themselves.

Meanwhile, the dishonest people who never register their vehicles to themselves largely continue to get off SORN-penalty-free as reward for doing so - as well as being able to speed past speed cameras and park illegally with impunity knowing that they can't be traced. What are their chances of being dealt with by a policeman nowadays? Small.

Seems a bit back-to-front to me, that one...

kazgti

3 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi all,
Been told case is now on hold whilst DVLA investigate until 23 April. In meantime have emailed local Tory Councillor and asked him to pass my comments forward to the MP in the hope that someone may take this further to get some changes made to the whole system.
Maybe any other honest people out there that have been caught the same way would also like to write/email their local MP and make some noise to get some change (or at least hope to).