stopped for no insurance
Author
Discussion

T_Pot

Original Poster:

2,542 posts

228 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
was out earlier for a quick spin, and as i was coming home, i passed an unmarked Volvo parked at road side, facing me.

Besides being totally legal, i check my mirror to see if he has moved. he is 2 cars behind me now. so carry on to my house and he is now behind me at every turn until we reach my drive and i reverse in.

He asked if the car was mine, yes it is, he then asked is it insured?
I replied of course, you just seen me driving.

This is when he says, the plate reader threw up, saying my car was not insured.

So in the house i go, and bring him my policy. he then rings MIB (motoring insurance bureau?)
who confirm, the vehicle has NO insurance.

he asks is my policy paid monthly, and suggests maybe i have a problem with billing. i assure him thats not possible, and i ring my insurance, who confirm the car is insured as it should be and no problems with anything, however the policeman cant accept this from them.

The policeman then spends a further 10 minutes making calls, untill finally, they agree the car was insured and he was fine and was on his way.

I will say, after the initial question about insurance when i told him i was insured, he was fine with me, and never gave the impression he didnt believe me or the such. but what a piss take to be sat in a police car outside my own house like a criminal, because of a bd computer.
had the policeman not been as nice, i would have been even more pissed.

so thats my first ever rant here, and i feel loads better now

i don't really, but id hate to think i bored you for nothing

bluepolarbear

1,666 posts

277 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
you are lucky, the car is often towed away on the basis of wrong data. Policing by numbers - it is why more extensive use of databases whether it be ANPR or ID cards is wrong.

eldar

25,351 posts

227 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Its a symptom of 'The computer says'. In this case at least the police used their common sense. Happens everywhere - No, you can't live there, then computer says so, and the like. Mostly its just an irritant, sometime much more than that.

FFS, the civil service is mostly incapable of organising a simple system, let alone a huge set of interlinked databases, networks and systems.

time2react

91 posts

231 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
At least as you say, it was an unmarked car.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
bluepolarbear said:
you are lucky, the car is often towed away on the basis of wrong data. Policing by numbers - it is why more extensive use of databases whether it be ANPR or ID cards is wrong.
We had some police force figures quoted here a little while ago. The number of incorrect seizures over a particular period was 2 out of 3000. That hardly qualifies as "often".

Macman

36 posts

225 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
bluepolarbear said:
you are lucky, the car is often towed away on the basis of wrong data. Policing by numbers - it is why more extensive use of databases whether it be ANPR or ID cards is wrong.
Really? If a vehicle is uninsured an Inspector's authority is required before it is recovered/seized. In North Yorkshire at least, if a driver states he has a policy of insurance covering his use of a vehicle on a road, an Inspector will not issue authority regardles what ANPR etc says. Instead the driver will be required to produce his certificate of insurance within seven days, and enquiries will be made with the company to establish the validity of the policy.

The Inspector will authorise however if the driver says he is insured say, with Norwich Union, and immediate contact with NU establishes that he isn't. I'm not aware of one vehicle seized in North Yorkshire for no insurance which subsequently turned out to be insured. (That's not to say 100% it hasn't happened, and of course North Yorkshire is only one County)

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Many years ago I got stopped on the way home from a club, I happened to be in a courtesy car (my TVR was unhappy).. I got out the car, gave my name and address, he checked. They came back negative, I apparantly didn't live where I thought I did, nor indeed where I was heading back to, so who gave me the key to their house I'll never know, but I digress... He then asks if the car is insured, I say of course, it's a courtesy car, my TVR is unhappy. He checks, and no, that car isn't insured on his computer either.... I gave him my TVR reg and he discovered that is insured, and I think it was registed at the address I gave him too (i.e. my damn house the computer said I don't live at). He then says, don't Sorry sir, it happens a lot, and sends me on my way.....

The day they rely too heavily on computers is the day the revolution comes.


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
All forces have a number of hoops to jump through before vehicles are taken. We take about 5-8 a month on my team and all have been perfectly legal so far.

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Macman said:
bluepolarbear said:
you are lucky, the car is often towed away on the basis of wrong data. Policing by numbers - it is why more extensive use of databases whether it be ANPR or ID cards is wrong.
Really? If a vehicle is uninsured an Inspector's authority is required before it is recovered/seized. In North Yorkshire at least, if a driver states he has a policy of insurance covering his use of a vehicle on a road, an Inspector will not issue authority regardles what ANPR etc says. Instead the driver will be required to produce his certificate of insurance within seven days, and enquiries will be made with the company to establish the validity of the policy.

The Inspector will authorise however if the driver says he is insured say, with Norwich Union, and immediate contact with NU establishes that he isn't. I'm not aware of one vehicle seized in North Yorkshire for no insurance which subsequently turned out to be insured. (That's not to say 100% it hasn't happened, and of course North Yorkshire is only one County)
IIRC Merseyside only seized 3 cars out of 3000 incorrectly. We don't like perspective on this forum. Evil big brother Police state ANPR etc etc.

Shootingbiker

3,598 posts

225 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
I think we would all agree that uninsured drivers are bad people??

Many years ago one such person hit the back of my car which was stopped at a Zebra crossing!
Must have been doing 40mph and knocked my Rover 3.5 into the car in front!!!
They were playing cricket on the green next to us so I suspect he was watching that!

His car was a write-off and after givings both of us false name and address he just dissapeared!
Never got any pay out, but being in a Rover it was just the bumper and new ally boot lid required.

Recently my son got stopped and told he was not insured in my car, but the officer knew the policy had been changed on the date I changed it to any driver. (much cheaper than naming him!)

After the son called me and I said I had the policy in my hands with "Any Driver" on it he let him go.
I called my broker, who went a bit loopy and said get the Police to ring them, but I said why is the database wrong?? Down to Norwich Union who had not bothered to update it.

So I'm all in favoure of these checks, as its the insurence company that is at fault, not the Police!!
And it means we might pay a bit less if we get all the parasites off the road!
How many hit and runs are for this very reason???

Steve



Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
IIRC Merseyside only seized 3 cars out of 3000 incorrectly. We don't like perspective on this forum. Evil big brother Police state ANPR etc etc.
If it was your car wrongly seized how happy would you be though? One in 1 thousand is a pretty high rate to my mind for something like that.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
IIRC Merseyside only seized 3 cars out of 3000 incorrectly. We don't like perspective on this forum. Evil big brother Police state ANPR etc etc.
Merseyside are siezing 10,000 cars per year.

I have seen very low figures (like 2 or 3) quoted for incorrect siezes, but what they actually say is that the Police acted correctly and lawfully. So if it turns out that a siezed car was in fact insured, as long as the Police follow procedure, then that's OK?

I've read about several cases locally, including where a young girl was left at the side of the road and the Police wouldn't wait for her Dad to arrive with the certificate, and I think it's beyond anyone's imagination to think that in 10,000 cases of anything involving a combination of humans and computers that there would only be 2 or 3 errors.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
FishFace said:
IIRC Merseyside only seized 3 cars out of 3000 incorrectly. We don't like perspective on this forum. Evil big brother Police state ANPR etc etc.
Merseyside are siezing 10,000 cars per year.

I have seen very low figures (like 2 or 3) quoted for incorrect siezes, but what they actually say is that the Police acted correctly and lawfully. So if it turns out that a siezed car was in fact insured, as long as the Police follow procedure, then that's OK?

I've read about several cases locally, including where a young girl was left at the side of the road and the Police wouldn't wait for her Dad to arrive with the certificate, and I think it's beyond anyone's imagination to think that in 10,000 cases of anything involving a combination of humans and computers that there would only be 2 or 3 errors.
Shows you how good the officers implementing it are.

Its not 100 percent perfect but then nothing in life is. What it does mean with that 2997 less un-insured vehicles are driving about, those that in general probably as a proportion commit more traffic offences and cause more crashes.

There will be errors in every system. Its how the errors are rectified. The mistake cases should also be looked at with some pinches of salt as they are not always as innocent as they seem.

If the alternative is what we had before where I watch the un-insured or un-licensed driver drive off then I prefer it this way.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Shows you how good the officers implementing it are.
I don't think blindly following a system is "good". It tells them what to do, and they do it. It doesn't need expensive Police Officers to do that.
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Its not 100 percent perfect but then nothing in life is. What it does mean with that 2997 less un-insured vehicles are driving about, those that in general probably as a proportion commit more traffic offences and cause more crashes.
It's 10000 per year in Merseyside (20000 over a 2 year period) http://www.merseyside.police.uk/html/news/news/dec...
however the insurance industry said they sold an additional 100,000 insurance policies in Merseyside in that time.

That has to be all good, but it must be hard to see the positive side of having your vehicle siezed in error.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Shows you how good the officers implementing it are.
I don't think blindly following a system is "good". It tells them what to do, and they do it. It doesn't need expensive Police Officers to do that.
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Its not 100 percent perfect but then nothing in life is. What it does mean with that 2997 less un-insured vehicles are driving about, those that in general probably as a proportion commit more traffic offences and cause more crashes.
It's 10000 per year in Merseyside (20000 over a 2 year period) http://www.merseyside.police.uk/html/news/news/dec...
however the insurance industry said they sold an additional 100,000 insurance policies in Merseyside in that time.

That has to be all good, but it must be hard to see the positive side of having your vehicle siezed in error.
Indeed or the positive side to having an un-insured driver crash into you and then run away . I know which I would prefer.

Its not just about following a system, there is actually some investigation and common sense applied. Thats why the error rate is so low. Just following the system would see far more cars taken but at an increased error rate. I can think of countless stops for no insurance that I have been involved with that have not lead to a car being taken as we were not satisfied that they did not have insurance. Would you rather officers did not focus on un-insured drivers?

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Thats why the error rate is so low.
I think you're missing my point that the error rate is not as low as stated (2 or 3 out of thousands of vehicles).

The Police only recognise it as an error if they did something wrong. If it turns out the car was insured then as long as they followed proceedure it's not noted as error.

There are cases almost weekly in the local paper of cars being siezed for no insurance when they were in fact insured.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Thats why the error rate is so low.
I think you're missing my point that the error rate is not as low as stated (2 or 3 out of thousands of vehicles).
Sounds like a statistics "frig" then to me.


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Deva Link said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Thats why the error rate is so low.
I think you're missing my point that the error rate is not as low as stated (2 or 3 out of thousands of vehicles).
Sounds like a statistics "frig" then to me.
Whose to know. What I do know is that on the face of it 100.000 extra policies have been taken out and 2997 cars off the road. Thats more of an impact than the HORT1 system ever had. In one month in a London borough I understand they took 5000 cars.

Mistakes are not the issue its what is done to rectify that mistake and that people are not left off worse than they were before the mistake. As time goes on things will improve. I would still rather have my car taken than be hit by an un-insured driver. One way I get the car back the other I may well not or it will very much financially impact upon me.

Rubber-Ducky

284 posts

236 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Shootingbiker said:
I think we would all agree that uninsured drivers are bad people??

Many years ago one such person hit the back of my car which was stopped at a Zebra crossing!
Must have been doing 40mph and knocked my Rover 3.5 into the car in front!!!
They were playing cricket on the green next to us so I suspect he was watching that!

His car was a write-off and after givings both of us false name and address he just dissapeared!
Never got any pay out, but being in a Rover it was just the bumper and new ally boot lid required.

Recently my son got stopped and told he was not insured in my car, but the officer knew the policy had been changed on the date I changed it to any driver. (much cheaper than naming him!)

After the son called me and I said I had the policy in my hands with "Any Driver" on it he let him go.
I called my broker, who went a bit loopy and said get the Police to ring them, but I said why is the database wrong?? Down to Norwich Union who had not bothered to update it.

So I'm all in favoure of these checks, as its the insurence company that is at fault, not the Police!!
And it means we might pay a bit less if we get all the parasites off the road!
How many hit and runs are for this very reason???

Steve
Why would ANPR flag your son up - either the car was insured or it wasn't? As far as I know the system doesn't say who is allowed to drive it.

G51CAV

926 posts

229 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
FishFace said:
IIRC Merseyside only seized 3 cars out of 3000 incorrectly. We don't like perspective on this forum. Evil big brother Police state ANPR etc etc.
If it was your car wrongly seized how happy would you be though? One in 1 thousand is a pretty high rate to my mind for something like that.
About as happy as when the DVLA made a mess of recording my wife as the new keeper of her car forcing us to have it sat on the drive for 8 and a bit weeks as we couldn't tax it while they got it sorted out!!!!!

I do understand though that they have tightened up the legislation for the greater good to try and combat the idiots who choose to drive about without documentation, I also understand that mistakes can and will happen!