Flashing speed signs, a question.
Flashing speed signs, a question.
Author
Discussion

R39S1

Original Poster:

2,391 posts

241 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
I would welcome the thoughts of our esteemed members on this forum over this little conundrum, which for some reason annoys me.

The scenario; on one of the approaches to our village you go from NSL country road to a 30mph limit built up area, all well and good. But because the country road is fairly wide people do tend to speed into the village, which is not so good. In order to reduce the speed on this stretch of 30mph limit, a few relatively low cost measures were installed, including one of this flashing signs that lights up if you are above the speed limit. So far so good, all perfectly laudable stuff and I fully support such things in general. However here’s the niggle. The flashing sign is so located that it picks you up while you are still in the NSL and starts flashing. Ok no big deal you might say it reminds you to slow down, except this annoys because I have tried it at various approach speeds and distances and it is perfectly reasonable to be slowing, not braking hard at the last minute, trigger the sign and still be well under 30mph when entering the speed limited area. But of course you then drive up to the sign with it flashing your supposed guilty transgression at you.

My questions are; is this sign complying with the legal requirements covering the use, setup, location etc for such things or should it only be detecting you in the speed limit it is supposed to be supporting. I ask this because if someone had an accident on this stretch and a witness said, “Well they must have been speeding, the sign was flashing” you’d be hard put to argue against it.

Anyway I welcome any comments, thoughts, questions etc thank you

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
There's one near to us....it doesn't matter what speed you approach,as soon as you are in range it will flash "Slow down 30mph" at you.....I think it's just to wake drivers up to the fact that they are about to enter a 30 limit...

wasted years

4,330 posts

240 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
It's just a friendly reminder that you are about to enter a 30 so I really wouldn't worry about it or any prosecution.

DIW35

4,205 posts

231 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
They always make me laugh. Damn thing is flashing 30 at me when I'm doing way more than that. Maybe someone will work out one day how to make them display the right speed. wink

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
No, that would annoy me too...

Indeed, there is a sign near us which is a "junction" sign, which flashes up when you are travelling at over about 47mph (yes, I'm sad enough to have tootled past it a few times at varying speeds) yet what gets my goat is, it's in an NSL......

simba1

547 posts

231 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
A few times i have witnessed teenagers speeding on their scooters and cars to see who clocks the highest speed in a 30 mph zone. They know flashing signs will do f*** all which could easily change if you had a patrol car cruising around regularly.

wiliferus

4,225 posts

229 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
There's one in Holyport nr Maidenhead thats been knackered for ages - When it lights up it simply flashes "DOWN"...... Unfortunatley Mrs Wilifierus wouldn't oblige.. wink

tigger1

8,483 posts

252 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
DIW35 said:
They always make me laugh. Damn thing is flashing 30 at me when I'm doing way more than that. Maybe someone will work out one day how to make them display the right speed. wink
There's plenty that do show your actual speed...and plenty of people willing to try to get it to display 3 figures (not me, I hasten to add)

Aubrey

1,157 posts

227 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
This is true, there is a machine that will display your exact speed and if you slow down or speed up, it will reflect it. I think these flashing signs do work, one of the alternatives is a GATSO....

will_

6,035 posts

234 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
DIW35 said:
They always make me laugh. Damn thing is flashing 30 at me when I'm doing way more than that. Maybe someone will work out one day how to make them display the right speed. wink
There's plenty that do show your actual speed...and plenty of people willing to try to get it to display 3 figures (not me, I hasten to add)
I think the maximum speed they will show has been fixed, to stop people trying to compete for the top speed. I think it's something like 40mph in a 30 limit?

I don't have a problem with the flashing junction signs which come on regardless of the speed - they are simply more obvious roadsigns.

DIW35

4,205 posts

231 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
There's plenty that do show your actual speed...and plenty of people willing to try to get it to display 3 figures (not me, I hasten to add)
I know. There was one in motorway roadworks near me a few years ago, which would display not only your speed but your registration number as well. The limit was 50 and a few of us would often drive past and try and get it to display 51. I never succeeded I have to say.

Denis O

2,141 posts

274 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
And here's one of the problems with these 30mph signs. They do flash before you hit the 30 zone and they pick up vehicles travelling the opposite way and also flash. Not a problem you may think except I went through one a while ago in the dark and there was a BiB behind me.

He pulled me once I got through the village on the basis I had exceeded the 30mph limit. I explained that I was not in the 30 and as I lived locallly I was well aware that the sign would flash before entering the 30 zone. He wasn't having any of it and having asked if I'd had a drink, which I had about 3 hours before he then decided to breathlyse me. Breath test proved negative, in fact it didn't even register any alchohol on my breath, and after a quick shufty round the car they let me on my way.

It wasn't a problem and the Bib handled the situation fine but it was all a result of a flashing sign that was giving eroneous readings and cost me 15 minutes of my life smile

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all

There are a couple signs here at the end of the A127 (coming into Southend) where the limit goes from 70 to 40 and those signs only flash when you are above that 40 limit which is handy as there's a camera a little further down the road.

Chris Type R

8,981 posts

280 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
Aubrey said:
This is true, there is a machine that will display your exact speed and if you slow down or speed up, it will reflect it. I think these flashing signs do work, one of the alternatives is a GATSO....
I used to think that until I moved to a house on on a road with two of these - probably 30% of the passing traffic set them off frown This is on a town road, houses, children, joggers, cyclists, childrens farm, etc. Quite often at night you can hear the odd hooligan roaring past at est. 60+ In the four years that we've lived here I've not once seen any speed enforcement.

Eliminator

762 posts

286 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
One in Cobham at the moment. I the 40mph before you get to the 30mph coming from Leatherhead. Sign flashes "40 slow down" whatever speed you approach it - tried at 24mph today (no otehr traffic).

Why "slow" to 40 if I am doing less?
Why 40 a few meters before it changes to 30?

Why waste the electricity?

biglepton

5,042 posts

232 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
The council here on the Isle of Wight have just invested in a few of these to supplement the one and a half policeman we have and have placed them a few hundred yards after entering a 30mph village zone. What's a little annoying is that when they show your speed, if you are doing 28mph or more they flash at you angrily in red, 27mph or below unflashing green. So now 28 in 30 zone is illegal is it? ranting

Ranger 6

7,735 posts

280 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
Eliminator said:
One in Cobham at the moment. I the 40mph before you get to the 30mph coming from Leatherhead. Sign flashes "40 slow down" whatever speed you approach it - tried at 24mph today (no otehr traffic).

Why "slow" to 40 if I am doing less?
Why 40 a few meters before it changes to 30?

Why waste the electricity?
There was one in Chobham recently too - the battery died after about a week and it flashed random ste at everyone - it was really a bad example of what these things are supposed to do as they even put it on the pavement outside someones house where they usually parked, so there was often a van infront of it anyway.....

rdjohn

7,196 posts

226 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
R39S1 said:
I would welcome the thoughts of our esteemed members on this forum over this little conundrum, which for some reason annoys me.

The scenario; on one of the approaches to our village you go from NSL country road to a 30mph limit built up area, all well and good. But because the country road is fairly wide people do tend to speed into the village, which is not so good. In order to reduce the speed on this stretch of 30mph limit, a few relatively low cost measures were installed, including one of this flashing signs that lights up if you are above the speed limit. So far so good, all perfectly laudable stuff and I fully support such things in general. However here’s the niggle. The flashing sign is so located that it picks you up while you are still in the NSL and starts flashing. Ok no big deal you might say it reminds you to slow down, except this annoys because I have tried it at various approach speeds and distances and it is perfectly reasonable to be slowing, not braking hard at the last minute, trigger the sign and still be well under 30mph when entering the speed limited area. But of course you then drive up to the sign with it flashing your supposed guilty transgression at you.

My questions are; is this sign complying with the legal requirements covering the use, setup, location etc for such things or should it only be detecting you in the speed limit it is supposed to be supporting. I ask this because if someone had an accident on this stretch and a witness said, “Well they must have been speeding, the sign was flashing” you’d be hard put to argue against it.

Anyway I welcome any comments, thoughts, questions etc thank you
I sugest that you speak with you local Highway Authority i.e. your Local Council or Highways Agency and ask them to re-align the radar speed detector to obviate the problem that you are getting.

Studies have suggested that these signs can be as effective as a speed camera in reducing speed realted road casualties

eldar

25,351 posts

227 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
These signs do work.

If they are accurate - don't tell you to slow down when you don't need to. And for the first 4 or 5 days they are there. After that, very little effect.

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Monday 3rd March 2008
quotequote all
often driving and see these, I do slow down to the right speed for the area when inside it, all it takes is for a mobile to be in the area, plus if not know the area, might have a school around the corner....