Burglary - Blood found
Discussion
I had my house broken into and my TV was stolen. 
The police & SOCO turned up. SOCA found some blood on the outside of the window and there was also a foot print on the inside window ledge.
To gain access to the window they would have to walk onto the drive either from the road or footpath leading to my front door.
They have arrested someone and taken there shoes to see if they match (finger crossed).
The only problem i have at the moment is they are local. I don't know them and have never met them. There is no reason for them to be near my property. So the question is if the foot print doesn't match what are the chances of them getting done for breaking into my house?

The police & SOCO turned up. SOCA found some blood on the outside of the window and there was also a foot print on the inside window ledge.
To gain access to the window they would have to walk onto the drive either from the road or footpath leading to my front door.
They have arrested someone and taken there shoes to see if they match (finger crossed).
The only problem i have at the moment is they are local. I don't know them and have never met them. There is no reason for them to be near my property. So the question is if the foot print doesn't match what are the chances of them getting done for breaking into my house?
DNA is enough. My burglar got caught by a cigarette butt he left behind (stupid idiot). He was wearing gloves so no fingerprint, but was stupid enough to smoke ...
The soco team is about the only police team in the UK I have respect for (together with the inspectors that were with them). They were human, did a superb job and as a bonus - have an intense dislike for a certain branch that their collegues work in
The soco team is about the only police team in the UK I have respect for (together with the inspectors that were with them). They were human, did a superb job and as a bonus - have an intense dislike for a certain branch that their collegues work in

EU_Foreigner said:
DNA is enough. My burglar got caught by a cigarette butt he left behind (stupid idiot). He was wearing gloves so no fingerprint, but was stupid enough to smoke ...
The soco team is about the only police team in the UK I have respect for (together with the inspectors that were with them). They were human, did a superb job and as a bonus - have an intense dislike for a certain branch that their collegues work in
Crims are now collecting cigarette butts off the street to leave at the scenes of crimes to leave a false DNA trail... maybe your burglar wasn't stupid?!The soco team is about the only police team in the UK I have respect for (together with the inspectors that were with them). They were human, did a superb job and as a bonus - have an intense dislike for a certain branch that their collegues work in

FishFace said:
DNA isn't enough. It's enshrined in law.
In what UK Act(s)? Every reference I have found refers only to the police/CPS stating that they would never prosecute on DNA evidence alone. There are also reports of a private agreement between the CPS and FSS. In Ireland, however, it it is the law that it cannot be used exclusively.With one or more DNA samples from the scene, the police are likely to conclude on the basis of a database match that, more likely than not, they are investigating the guilty party. The investigative process can then accumulate corroborating evidence.
It is clear that there are cases where DNA alone could provide compelling evidence for a prosecution (for instance, a full profile obtained from an intimate sample from a rape victim when the defendant claims no contact) and there are cases where the DNA is irrelevant.
Streaky
Edited by streaky on Friday 7th March 15:04
EU_Foreigner said:
I saw his mug shot after he was arrested ... he was that stupid indeed. Also, he confessed as well.
Never got anything of the stolen stuff back mind you.
You said earlier DNA was enough and gave your example then you say he admitted it.Never got anything of the stolen stuff back mind you.
DNA on it's own will never be enough but in conjunction with other evidence even circumstantial or previous convictions for similar offences will probably get the job home.
However DNA found + circumstances of how it got there could be enough on it's own, obviously blood found at the scene is stronger evidence than a cigarette but especially if the blood is fresh
DNA is similar to fingerprints in many ways. All it does is prove that the blood/body fluid/whatever belongs to that specific person. It does nothing else.
Even with, for instance, sperm it does not prove rape. There must be additional evidence.
In the same way as a fingerprint on a glass found at the scene of a crime proves nothing other than the person whose print it is touched that glass, DNA proves just that it is the person's DNA.
Circumstantial evidence is evidence of the circumstances surrounding the incident. A rape victim might well (but by no means always) be bruised. This would be circumstantial evidence supporting his/her allegation of rape. The sperm will, depending on location, prove that there was penetration. So allegation of rape made immedately after the incident, circumstantial evidence supporting the fact that the offence took place against the victim's will, evidence of penetration and DNA is enough for a prima face case of rape, i.e. there is a case to answer.
Even with, for instance, sperm it does not prove rape. There must be additional evidence.
In the same way as a fingerprint on a glass found at the scene of a crime proves nothing other than the person whose print it is touched that glass, DNA proves just that it is the person's DNA.
Circumstantial evidence is evidence of the circumstances surrounding the incident. A rape victim might well (but by no means always) be bruised. This would be circumstantial evidence supporting his/her allegation of rape. The sperm will, depending on location, prove that there was penetration. So allegation of rape made immedately after the incident, circumstantial evidence supporting the fact that the offence took place against the victim's will, evidence of penetration and DNA is enough for a prima face case of rape, i.e. there is a case to answer.
Thudd said:
I thought DNA was only 1/1000000 accurate?
ie there could be 60 people in the UK alone with a match for my DNA.
The answer to that is: Yes, or to be more exact, No. It's the DNA recording for the police files that is 1/10000000 accurate. The checks that are completed once the suspect is known are much more accurate. Identical twins have identical DNA but not fingerprints.ie there could be 60 people in the UK alone with a match for my DNA.
An interesting but useless bit of information is that the only creature to have fingerprints is the koala bear. They are indistinguishable from human’s.
Thudd said:
I thought DNA was only 1/1000000 accurate?
ie there could be 60 people in the UK alone with a match for my DNA.
The older SGM method of DNA recording is one in 50 million. ie there could be 60 people in the UK alone with a match for my DNA.
SGM Plus = one in a billion.
streaky said:
FishFace said:
DNA isn't enough. It's enshrined in law.
In what UK Act(s)? Every reference I have found refers only to the police/CPS stating that they would never prosecute on DNA evidence alone. There are also reports of a private agreement between the CPS and FSS. In Ireland, however, it it is the law that it cannot be used exclusively.With one or more DNA samples from the scene, the police are likely to conclude on the basis of a database match that, more likely than not, they are investigating the guilty party. The investigative process can then accumulate corroborating evidence.
It is clear that there are cases where DNA alone could provide compelling evidence for a prosecution (for instance, a full profile obtained from an intimate sample from a rape victim when the defendant claims no contact) and there are cases where the DNA is irrelevant.
Streaky
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


