FPN for 'Unnecessary Obstruction' - Advice please!
FPN for 'Unnecessary Obstruction' - Advice please!
Author
Discussion

evomike

Original Poster:

45 posts

266 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

I'm hoping that you can help. I leave my car parked on a side road near to Tring station everyday. There are usually around 10 or so other cars also parked there. All of the cars park on the same side of the road and there are no parking restrictions (yellow lines, signs, etc). The road itself does not have a central white line, however, there is plenty of room for a single vehcile to pass (today I saw an HGV pass with no issue). Further up the road it is too narrow for more than 1 car at a time.

Anyway, this evening when I returned to my car I (along with all the other vehicles there) had an FPN for 'Unnecessary Obstruction'. Where do I stand if I contest this? I cannot find anything explaining exactly what 'unnessary obstruction' is defined as. I was more than 10m from any junctions, there are no marked parking bays anywhere near, there are no houses or any entrances, etc nearby and vehicles could easily pass?!?!

Thanks in advance

Mike

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
From what i can see this is the legislation:
Regulation 103 of the Road Vehicles (Construction and Use) Regulations 1986 creates the offence of unnecessary obstruction.
No person in charge of a motor vehicle or trailer shall cause or permit the vehicle to stand on a road so as to cause any unnecessary obstruction of the road.

I would say the obstruction is not defined as such but would be a wilfull positioning of the vehicle causing other road users to alter speed or direction to pass your vehicle.

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
I got find £8 for this offence in 1974. I was parked on part of the pavement outside a church, and the vicar reported me.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
Any vehicle parked on the road is an obstruction, what matters is whether it is deemed unnecessary or not. Circumstances can matter greatly in that & whilst you may not consider it an unnecessary obstruction when it was left, someone else later viewing it in different circumstances may view it as such.
The only way you'll know is see what circumstances they are alleging in the evidence.

Edited by vonhosen on Friday 7th March 19:26

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Any vehicle parked on the road is an obstruction, what matters is whether it is deemed unnecessary or not. Circumstances can matter greatly in that & whilst you may not consider it an unnecessary obstruction when it was left, someone else later viewing it in different circumstances may view it as such.
The only way you'll know is see what circumstances they are alleging in the evidence.
As you say, any vehicle parked on the road is an obstruction - as is any vehicle travelling on the road.

It sounds as if, in this case, the locals had for a good long time been using this road for what they thought was legal parking, whence commuters can do their bit by taking public transport.
If that is the history of the site, and if furthermore the parkers really were unwittingly causing an "unnecessary" obstruction, then surely the proper action by the council or whatever self-important collection of buffoons claimed responsibility would have been to put up warnings or signs for a few days before summarily slapping a FPN on everyone's windscreen and then sitting back to wait for the cheques to roll in.

Derek Smith

50,021 posts

279 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
There is a stated case from the 60s which is still current despite challenges.

The circumstances were that a car had parked in between two other cars at the side of the Embankment. The defence suggested, on appeal, that there was no obstruction as it could not be used for passing and repassing, i.e. as a bit of the road. The court felt otherwise. So the obstruction can be to that part of the road over which the vehicle is so the fact that other vehicles could get through is of no consideration.

Unnecessary is a matter of fact for the court to consider. But leaving it there in order to catch a train is, I would suggest, a no hoper.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Unnecessary is a matter of fact for the court to consider. But leaving it there in order to catch a train is, I would suggest, a no hoper.
A no hoper would be leaving it on the Embankment, which is a major thoroughfare well marked with double reds, or leaving it on what sounds like a trivial side road with no evident parking restrictions, apart from the newly-formed and unpublicised opinion of what probably was a minor agent for the council?

steventoon

5 posts

250 months

Friday 7th March 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
There is a stated case from the 60s which is still current despite challenges.

The circumstances were that a car had parked in between two other cars at the side of the Embankment. The defence suggested, on appeal, that there was no obstruction as it could not be used for passing and repassing, i.e. as a bit of the road. The court felt otherwise. So the obstruction can be to that part of the road over which the vehicle is so the fact that other vehicles could get through is of no consideration.

Unnecessary is a matter of fact for the court to consider. But leaving it there in order to catch a train is, I would suggest, a no hoper.
Not quite true, there is a bit more to it than that.
What amounts to an obstruction is a question of fact for the magistrates to decide in EACH case. Wade v Grange 1977, and DPP v Jones 1999. In arriving at decisions they will have regard to, amongst other things , the length of time the obstuction continued, the place where it occured, the purpse for which it was done and whether it caused an actual as oposed to a potential obstruction. (Lord parker CJ v Weston 1965.

evomike

Original Poster:

45 posts

266 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Thanks everyone,

It sounds as if I had better pay up and find somewhere else to park then. Although one FPN every 2 weeks would still be cheaper than the station car park!!!!

F i F

49,011 posts

282 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Can't unecessary obstruction only be decided by a court? In which case a FPN is not appropriate afaik.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
No it's a FPN offence.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 9th March 2008
quotequote all
Just makes you want to use public transport doesn't it?rolleyes

evomike

Original Poster:

45 posts

266 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
I'm not sure what to do really. As if a rail fare of £3K a year isn't enough, I just can't really afford the £650 they want to park in the car park!!!

Cheers
Mike

F i F

49,011 posts

282 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
No it's a FPN offence.
So my Wilkinson's must be out of date then. frown as that clearly states the decision as to whether an offence of UO has been committed (in the absence of a TRO) can only be decided by a court.

Which legislation brought that in?

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
Section 54 Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 (Driver present) mate.

Plod sees what he considers to be an unlawful obstruction and issues FPN.

Receipient, if he considers no offemnce committed, can refuse to accept FPN, or where issued can later elect a hearing at Mags Court and have the bench decide.

Or if he accepts offence committed pays FPN - job done and dusted.

dvd

evomike

Original Poster:

45 posts

266 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
I wasn't present when the FPN was issued if that makes a difference.

Also, what could I expect if I contest and lose?

Cheers
Mike

miggy man 3

1,916 posts

227 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
You don't have to be present for it to be issued as it is non endorsable.

You can choose to contest it and if found guilty the court can fine you.