Parked Car opening door into passing traffic - No Witnesses
Parked Car opening door into passing traffic - No Witnesses
Author
Discussion

bridgland

Original Poster:

514 posts

255 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
Hope someone can help.

My wife was on the way to dropping off our youngest at school, when the car in front of her pulled to the side of a one way street to park by her house and as my wife started to pass the car (very narrow road so unable to swing wide), the woman in the parked car opened up the door straight into my wife's car. It had done damage to the bumper and down the front wing and has trashed the woman's door. She admitted liability at the scene, but there were no witnesses who were prepared to stop and assist (the weather this morning didn't help that cause either).

My wife has her details and has also gone back to the woman's car to take pictures of her damage. Once she gets a quote from Mercedes she will contact the woman and dicuss pursuing the insurance claim route.

However, I know from experience that insurance companies will fight the liability claim especially with no witness to rely on, so with photographic evidence, can we be assured of a complete recovery of costs, or should we be expecting a fight especially if the lady denies fault?

Just being paranoid but any advice would be welcome.

Chris

tigger1

8,483 posts

252 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
Is it possible to show, with photos that your wife's car HAD to pass close to the parked vehicle?


bridgland

Original Poster:

514 posts

255 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
I am sure that it is. I will see what photos she took when I get home.

bimsb6

8,808 posts

252 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
http://maps.live.com/ this is useful for a different angle on the location.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Monday 10th March 2008
quotequote all
All you can do is send your claim in and see what happens.

A lot will depend on what the other lady writes. If she tries to argue you swerved too close and left her no room to open the door, they may try it on.

Problem is, the law does state you should pass parked cars at a door's length ( even if this is not possible, as a law it supports the door opener at the start ) and they may argue the fact she had passed and pulled in made it obvious she was going to get out.

You can counterclaim that it was impossible to drive past at 3 yards gap, and that as she had overtook and cut in KNOWING she was about to open the door after such an action, the onus was upon her to check and wait. She was aware you were there; you could not be aware she was so stupid. ( Best not to put it like that )

They will then want evidence you trickled past - which may be in the damage caused only, as there were no witnesses.

You will probably have good odds if it went to court, but many insurers know you and I have not the time nor energy to go this way....so they may drag it out until you give up.

But send a claim in, see what happens.

( A good plan B is to get some quotes - do NOT tell the garage it is for insurance work - and offer the lady an out of court/insurance settlement. You need to be quick, though. )

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
"Law requires you must give at least a doors length of clearance"?? I've never heard of that before, I was under the impression that the person opening the door into the path of traffic (or cyclists) had a responsibility to ensure it was safe to do so?

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
I'll double check - I think it may be a Highway Code recommendation, which means it is not an actual law.....but it is ( the HC ) still used by courts as the 'law' when they are in doubt.

So if you have the HC on your side, even if it is not an actual road traffic law, you start the argument 30-o up...( as in tennis. )

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
The law says it's an offence to open a car door to the damage or danger of another (it's in the Road Vehicle (Construction & Use) Regs 1986. It is advice (not law) that driver's should attempt to give a doors width to parked cars. Of course depending on circumstances not doing so may be evidence towards a without due care.

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
Highway Code Rule 239 yes says you MUST ensure you you not hit anyone when you open door. It quotes which laws apply in the small print wink

Rule 242 say you MUST NOT park dangerously : (woman convicted of this.. it caused another driver to lose control .. a baby in a pram died.) or leave vehicle where it cause obstruction or severe und unnecessary nuisance. (I do wish one pratster around Lancs area would read his Highway Code on this... the one with the speed scam whistle) )

if it go to court if she dispute liablity .. she on sticky wicket. I do not think insurers will dispute based on parked car occupants are supposed to look before they set off or get out of cars. wink

bridgland

Original Poster:

514 posts

255 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
Thanks everyone for your responses.

The road is only about 8 feet wide with cars parked down the left hand side enough for a car or van to pass but not much else and certainly not enough space to give an open door's width. Looking at the damage last night, it it clear that this was a very low speed scrape with damage to bumper starting 4 inches back from the front of the bumper, damage to wing and alloy wheel, with only a very small dent in the wing. The Volvo has the trailing edge of the door bent backward, a dent in the middle of the door (due to the trailing edge folding) and the door trim hanging off slightly.

It is clear from the fact that the damage starts part of the way back along the side of the bumper, that my wife was already by the woman's door when she opened it.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
The law says it's an offence to open a car door to the damage or danger of another (it's in the Road Vehicle (Construction & Use) Regs 1986. It is advice (not law) that driver's should attempt to give a doors width to parked cars. Of course depending on circumstances not doing so may be evidence towards a without due care.
Good update.

I had them mixed! The above does sound far more reasonable as the starting point, with more responsibility and onus on the person opening the door.