When your house damages your car - where to claim?
Discussion
In the recent storms i.e this morning! some tiles from my parents roof came a tumbling down and one managed to strike the bonnet of their car causing some damage.
Both the house and the car are insured by Norwich Union.
The House side told my dad to claim against the house via the car insurance, but the car insurance side said that because th house is his and the car is his he cant claim against himself. So he'll have to just swallow the XS and get rodgered next time he renews cos he's had a claim.
Surely that can't be right?? He's got 2 seperate policies, why cant he make a claim for the damages to the car from his buildings policy? Or is this yet another case of NU being arses when it comes to claiming against themselves??
If the tile had hit the next door neighbours car I'm sure they'd pursue the claim against dads buildings policy?
Can anyone shed some light on what the is correct?
Both the house and the car are insured by Norwich Union.
The House side told my dad to claim against the house via the car insurance, but the car insurance side said that because th house is his and the car is his he cant claim against himself. So he'll have to just swallow the XS and get rodgered next time he renews cos he's had a claim.
Surely that can't be right?? He's got 2 seperate policies, why cant he make a claim for the damages to the car from his buildings policy? Or is this yet another case of NU being arses when it comes to claiming against themselves??
If the tile had hit the next door neighbours car I'm sure they'd pursue the claim against dads buildings policy?
Can anyone shed some light on what the is correct?
Not certain, but I think it's because you've already got insurance on the car that the house policy won't pay out as that would be doubly-insuring something.
Worth checking with someone who knows for sure though...AnniesDad is always a mine of information on this sort of thing.
Oh...and they'll need to declare the claim come car ins. renewal regardless...which will load the premium by 5-8% (vs 10-20% for a fault claim).
Worth checking with someone who knows for sure though...AnniesDad is always a mine of information on this sort of thing.
Oh...and they'll need to declare the claim come car ins. renewal regardless...which will load the premium by 5-8% (vs 10-20% for a fault claim).
Nurburgsingh said:
why cant he make a claim for the damages to the car from his buildings policy?
Because he would have to claim on the Third Party Liabilty section on the policy. And he isn't a third party !Put it another way, why doesn't he just sue himself ? Aha, that won't work
And nor will trying to claim you were negligent towards yourself.Sorry, but he is going to have to claim on the Motor Insurance policy.
Even if it were another party's roof, then being a big storm it will probably be act of god anyway. No negligence, no claim.
Bsmithmilne said:
house insurance is in her name car in mine so in theory i could claim from her?
More importantly, who owns the car (not necessarily the RK)? If not the householder, surely they would be a TP in the claim against the householder's policy. This begs the question of whether a spouse (resident or not with the householder) can be a TP when a policy is in one name only. Can any insurers or lawyers on here address that one? - StreakyHousehold policies usually have a clause regarding damage to property insured elsewhere (so that they can try and get the other insurance to chip in). Have a look at the policy rather than rely on some call centre agent.
Don't forget that insurers are in business to make a profit even within their different insurance activities so if one claims team can shove the claim elsewhere they'll be happy to do so.
Might it be economic to retain a Loss Assessor to fight your corner?
Don't forget that insurers are in business to make a profit even within their different insurance activities so if one claims team can shove the claim elsewhere they'll be happy to do so.
Might it be economic to retain a Loss Assessor to fight your corner?
The contibution clause doesn't apply, as there is no dual insurance as the perils are different (Storm damage and Public Liability). Contributions are more to do with items that are covered both on your travel and household anyway.
TP liabilty sections of either buildings or contents are more than likely to have an exclusion on the lines of "Loss or damage to property owned by your or members of your family". You can't claim on your Contents, as vehicles are usually excluded. So that leaves the Motor Policy.
And as previously stated, unless there is negligence, there is no case to answer. If you chimney was wobbly, and you did nothing, and it fell down on someone, you may be liable. However if some slates fall off, and you could not have reasonbly foreseen this happening, then you will not be negligent.
TP liabilty sections of either buildings or contents are more than likely to have an exclusion on the lines of "Loss or damage to property owned by your or members of your family". You can't claim on your Contents, as vehicles are usually excluded. So that leaves the Motor Policy.
And as previously stated, unless there is negligence, there is no case to answer. If you chimney was wobbly, and you did nothing, and it fell down on someone, you may be liable. However if some slates fall off, and you could not have reasonbly foreseen this happening, then you will not be negligent.
Nurburgsingh said:
I'll check the small print on the policy and see what's afoot....
So does that mean that if My mum crashes into my dad they wont be able to claim for anything on that either as both cars are insured in his name??
Thats slightly different if your Mum is a named driver, as technically it is her negligence which is covered too.So does that mean that if My mum crashes into my dad they wont be able to claim for anything on that either as both cars are insured in his name??
streaky said:
This begs the question of whether a spouse (resident or not with the householder) can be a TP when a policy is in one name only.
IANAIOAL, but I think the answer to this is Yes. Some years ago my parents had a motorcycle accident. My dad was riding and my mum pillion. Dad lost it on some black ice and went down, nobody else involved. My mum broke her wrist quite badly trying to break her fall, and at the time was a self-employed hairdresser so couldn't work for 2-3 months as a result.
She successfully claimed off my Dad's motorcycle insurance (NU!) for her loss of earnings.
timskipper said:
streaky said:
This begs the question of whether a spouse (resident or not with the householder) can be a TP when a policy is in one name only.
IANAIOAL, but I think the answer to this is Yes. Some years ago my parents had a motorcycle accident. My dad was riding and my mum pillion. Dad lost it on some black ice and went down, nobody else involved. My mum broke her wrist quite badly trying to break her fall, and at the time was a self-employed hairdresser so couldn't work for 2-3 months as a result.
She successfully claimed off my Dad's motorcycle insurance (NU!) for her loss of earnings.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


