Speed awareness course..pass or fail?
Speed awareness course..pass or fail?
Author
Discussion

Brown and Boris

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
Anybody been on one of the obligatory ones, when you have the choice of points/totter disq or the course?

I was wondering if you felt it had any effect on your attitude to speed/risk and if you changed your behaviour as a result of the course of the simply worry about more points so soon after?

Can you 'fail' by being a knob head or just refusing to take it on board is 'failing' just what they threten you with to get you to pay attention?

A colleague went on one recently and said one guy just st there contadicting the whole time but was allowed to leave with the course 'passed' even though his attitide clearly hadn't changed.

Can they change an attitude?

qooqiiu

753 posts

228 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
As i understand it you can`t attend one if you already have any points. Its for 1st time "offenders" only. (I stand to be corrected)

Its designed for people who are caught over the limit by a very small margin as well. Caught doing 40 in a 30 and you've no chance of getting on one.

Can it change attitudes?

That would be up to the individual, wouldn't it...



JohnnyPanic

1,282 posts

240 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
qooqiiu said:
As i understand it you can`t attend one if you already have any points. Its for 1st time "offenders" only. (I stand to be corrected)

Its designed for people who are caught over the limit by a very small margin as well. Caught doing 40 in a 30 and you've no chance of getting on one.
I think the rules may depend on region. I know of someone who already had 9 points, got caught a fourth time and was offered the course. It made me think that they make as much money from you as possible on the standard fines before finally offering the course. Or maybe I'm just cynical...

buggalugs

9,296 posts

268 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
There was a fair ammount of 'healthy discussion' on mine in Staffs, its not really a pass or fail thing. You just have to go and sit through it, as long as you're not disruptive to the point that the course can't continue I think you'll be fine. FWIW my main lecturer dude was allright and the course wasn't quite what I expected! Lots of emphasis on observation, forward planning etc. and we had to do some commentary during our drives etc. It was allmost like a one-off IAM lesson.

Brown and Boris

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
The ACPO guidance says:

What is required of the clients? To successfully complete the course the clients must:

• Attend all sessions
• Complete all course paperwork, including any relevant questionnaires
• Make a positive contribution
• Demonstrate a willingness to make a commitment to improve speed awareness
skills and attitudes

Seems they want a personal debrief with your plans for what you intend to do to stop yourself reoffending. The ACPO document sugests pre-cons don't come into it but you can only do a course once every 3 years: you get prosecuted next time.

From what I have heard the companies runnuing the courses don't always press home the advantage so to speak.

http://www.acpo.police.uk/asp/policies/Data/nation...

http://www.lancashire.gov.uk/environment/roadsafet...



WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
qooqiiu said:
As i understand it you can`t attend one if you already have any points. Its for 1st time "offenders" only. (I stand to be corrected)

Its designed for people who are caught over the limit by a very small margin as well. Caught doing 40 in a 30 and you've no chance of getting on one.

Can it change attitudes?

That would be up to the individual, wouldn't it...
We do lot of research on this - especially since Manchester/Lancs und Staffs are COAST based courses wink (We owe this to the late CC Todd who declared that there should be no war on motorists three month ago und we hear he insisted that the invites be widened to better margins as directive. We do have FOI on this wink. I can source all things I state on here wink )

Each area depend on "cut off speeds". They all vary but generally the above areas allow 10% + 5 to 7 (7 in case of GMP after the late CC's input .. making 40 mph in 30 mph eligible.. but points at 41 mph wink)

You are not eligible if completed either DIS or Speed Aware in past three years or a novice driver.

Nine pointers vary .. but it depend on if you already have 9 points or if the 9-2 points were earned on same run or in rapid succession. Investigation lead us to suggest anyone in this situation should plead for inclusion to the course to save mobility. We find many have managed to save licences by doing so. .. when we make enquiries on this. wink

If you are disruptive "pupil".. "bolshy" .. "offensive und unprepared to learn und an arrogant know-itall" - then they will pass file back to CPS und you are offered again the conditional fixed points/fine or day in court.

Usually . per the folk we know attend such courses.. they not rub noses into anything. Most seem to enjoy und our (my entire family here who are IAM observers) seem to find many are enthused enough to learn more as result of all this.

I think I should do FOI of IAM to see if they have statistical proof.. given I am basing on the punters we see seeking IAM from our local branch wink

qooqiiu

753 posts

228 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
[quote=WildCat

We do lot of research on this - especially since Manchester/Lancs und Staffs are COAST based courses wink (We owe this to the late CC Todd who declared that there should be no war on motorists three month ago und we hear he insisted that the invites be widened to better margins as directive. We do have FOI on this wink. I can source all things I state on here wink )

Each area depend on "cut off speeds". They all vary but generally the above areas allow 10% + 5 to 7 (7 in case of GMP after the late CC's input .. making 40 mph in 30 mph eligible.. but points at 41 mph wink)

You are not eligible if completed either DIS or Speed Aware in past three years or a novice driver.

Nine pointers vary .. but it depend on if you already have 9 points or if the 9-2 points were earned on same run or in rapid succession. Investigation lead us to suggest anyone in this situation should plead for inclusion to the course to save mobility. We find many have managed to save licences by doing so. .. when we make enquiries on this. wink

If you are disruptive "pupil".. "bolshy" .. "offensive und unprepared to learn und an arrogant know-itall" - then they will pass file back to CPS und you are offered again the conditional fixed points/fine or day in court.

Usually . per the folk we know attend such courses.. they not rub noses into anything. Most seem to enjoy und our (my entire family here who are IAM observers) seem to find many are enthused enough to learn more as result of all this.

I think I should do FOI of IAM to see if they have statistical proof.. given I am basing on the punters we see seeking IAM from our local branch wink
[/quote]

Well thats very interesting thank you.

You state that the cut offs vary from region to region, so like most things in this country there's no consistency.

Its a postcode lottery.......again!

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Tuesday 11th March 2008
quotequote all
qooqiiu said:
WildCat said:
We do lot of research on this - especially since Manchester/Lancs und Staffs are COAST based courses wink (We owe this to the late CC Todd who declared that there should be no war on motorists three month ago und we hear he insisted that the invites be widened to better margins as directive. We do have FOI on this wink. I can source all things I state on here wink )

Each area depend on "cut off speeds". They all vary but generally the above areas allow 10% + 5 to 7 (7 in case of GMP after the late CC's input .. making 40 mph in 30 mph eligible.. but points at 41 mph wink)

You are not eligible if completed either DIS or Speed Aware in past three years or a novice driver.

Nine pointers vary .. but it depend on if you already have 9 points or if the 9-2 points were earned on same run or in rapid succession. Investigation lead us to suggest anyone in this situation should plead for inclusion to the course to save mobility. We find many have managed to save licences by doing so. .. when we make enquiries on this. wink

If you are disruptive "pupil".. "bolshy" .. "offensive und unprepared to learn und an arrogant know-itall" - then they will pass file back to CPS und you are offered again the conditional fixed points/fine or day in court.

Usually . per the folk we know attend such courses.. they not rub noses into anything. Most seem to enjoy und our (my entire family here who are IAM observers) seem to find many are enthused enough to learn more as result of all this.

I think I should do FOI of IAM to see if they have statistical proof.. given I am basing on the punters we see seeking IAM from our local branch wink
Well thats very interesting thank you.

You state that the cut offs vary from region to region, so like most things in this country there's no consistency.

Its a postcode lottery.......again!
Well yes .. I agree.

It something which get me ranting as I want justice und fair plays und the SAME laws to apply to all here.

I also have a thing about NHS postcode lotteries und the pricing of the drugs I design to cure things. I am a natural born rebel .. und I will fight for fair play on many fronts here wink

Brown and Boris

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
The ACPO doc seemed clear about the cases that were suitable, can some forces just not be arsed to arrange them?

JohnnyPanic

1,282 posts

240 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
Each area depend on "cut off speeds". They all vary but generally the above areas allow 10% + 5 to 7 (7 in case of GMP after the late CC's input .. making 40 mph in 30 mph eligible.. but points at 41 mph wink)

You are not eligible if completed either DIS or Speed Aware in past three years or a novice driver.
I would have thought that both those going above the 'cut off' and novice drivers (who are probably driving on roads faster than anything they were taught on ... at least that's the first (and last time thus far) that I've been done/caught) are the ones most in need of a course.

XMG5

1,082 posts

258 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Brown and Boris said:
Anybody been on one of the obligatory ones, when you have the choice of points/totter disq or the course?

I was wondering if you felt it had any effect on your attitude to speed/risk and if you changed your behaviour as a result of the course of the simply worry about more points so soon after?

Can you 'fail' by being a knob head or just refusing to take it on board is 'failing' just what they threten you with to get you to pay attention?

A colleague went on one recently and said one guy just st there contadicting the whole time but was allowed to leave with the course 'passed' even though his attitide clearly hadn't changed.

Can they change an attitude?
A workmate of mine was caught speeding by a mobile scamera van, in his words "I was day-dreaming, it was my own fault"

He was offered a Speed Awareness Course instead of points and took it. He came back from it spouting about how he would drive better in future and concentrate much more. He spouted about speed limits and stopping distances Blah! Blah!

A week later he was clobbered again!!!!

In his words [i]"I was caught again, it was my fault, I was day dreaming again. I reckon I'll get the points this time"

[/i] Laugh? I nearly pis*ed myself!! roflroflroflroflroflroflrofl

Edited by XMG5 on Friday 14th March 14:04