AA or RAC?
AA or RAC?
Author
Discussion

nia198

Original Poster:

115 posts

227 months

Wednesday 12th March 2008
quotequote all
Anyone know if either is better for dealing with Chims? No problems right now, but wondering if I should join one just in case...

tvrbob

11,197 posts

286 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
I doubt there's anything between them. I'm with The AA and I have called them out three times. Every time they have managed to sort the problem at the road side and I have been able to carry on with my journey. The Chim/Griff are fairly simple motors using mechanicals from other manufacturers so specialist knowledge shouldn't come into the equation.

Bomber Denton

8,762 posts

299 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
If you join the AA and your car is under ten years old you can take out their warranty for around £50, this insures that if they cannot repair your car at the side of the road (starter, clutch etc) they will then pay up to £500 of any repair and as it's a TVR you can select the repairer. If you keep your car over ten years of age you can still keep the policy.

booty

25 posts

284 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
I had to call out the rac to have a look at my 1997 chim could not start it.
rac arrived started his usual checks, then he asked me to turn over the engine,i duly did to see a gush of petrol shoot over the engine, obviously he had disconnected the fuel pipe to make sure that fuel was coming through (believe me it was).
I had to take a business call that had come through and while i was taking that call i heard my engine turning over, turning toward the car i then saw flames shooting up to the garage roof, and the rac man frantically trying to pat the flames out with a rag which also caught on fire, then he ran past me with a look of horror on his face and returned with a fire extinguisher and doused the flames.
After a thousand apologies and his comments on why he had done such a stupid thing checking to see if there was a spark from the plug that he had removed,and his continuous (this has never happened to me before in all my 15 years service)
Anyway the only damage was superficial a couple of scorched wires and a very embarrassed rac man.
I did ok out of it, the chim was taken to my local dealer i had a full service, a nice dolly job and the car returned to me running perfectly,all paid for by the rac.
And to this day seven years on i'm still with them, i hope this gives you a little bit of help in deciding.
Happy motoring guys.



richy759

227 posts

234 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
booty said:
I had to call out the rac to have a look at my 1997 chim could not start it.
rac arrived started his usual checks, then he asked me to turn over the engine,i duly did to see a gush of petrol shoot over the engine, obviously he had disconnected the fuel pipe to make sure that fuel was coming through (believe me it was).
I had to take a business call that had come through and while i was taking that call i heard my engine turning over, turning toward the car i then saw flames shooting up to the garage roof, and the rac man frantically trying to pat the flames out with a rag which also caught on fire, then he ran past me with a look of horror on his face and returned with a fire extinguisher and doused the flames.
After a thousand apologies and his comments on why he had done such a stupid thing checking to see if there was a spark from the plug that he had removed,and his continuous (this has never happened to me before in all my 15 years service)
Anyway the only damage was superficial a couple of scorched wires and a very embarrassed rac man.
I did ok out of it, the chim was taken to my local dealer i had a full service, a nice dolly job and the car returned to me running perfectly,all paid for by the rac.
And to this day seven years on i'm still with them, i hope this gives you a little bit of help in deciding.
Happy motoring guys.
I'm sorry but that is the funniest story I have heard in a long time, I can't stop laughing.
Rich

booty

25 posts

284 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Hey Rich,
I'm glad you enjoyed my tale, at the time of the incident i didn't know wether to laugh or cry and i must admit there have been a few occasions when the chim has been playing up that i have wished that she had burnt out on that day.

Well not really!

Ubernoober

534 posts

241 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Just a snippet of info - if you have a Platinum Current a/c with LLoyds, you get AA Homestart Relay etc breakdown cover free (along with other freebies).

I've never had call to use it so have no idea how good/bad it is.

and no, I don't work for 'em

cloggy

4,959 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
I just got my renewal letter from the AA.(Been member for 13 years)
They are offering the following;

Roadside £50
Home Start £45
Relay £46
Joint cover£30 for Mrs Cloggy (Toyota Camry)

Total £171.00

Additional European cover Annual Multi Trip £85.00

I am trying to compare with the RAC but their web site give prices but not for the European cover.
So I cannot really compare if they are cheaper.
What discount do we get with the RAC for being a TVRCC member?

Timja

1,955 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Also, if you have Tesco Clubcard vouchers, they can be exchanged for 4 times their value to get RAC cover!

V8 GRF

7,299 posts

241 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Ubernoober said:
Just a snippet of info - if you have a Platinum Current a/c with LLoyds, you get AA Homestart Relay etc breakdown cover free (along with other freebies).

I've never had call to use it so have no idea how good/bad it is.

and no, I don't work for 'em
I get my RAC membership free with my Barclays Additions Plus account and that includes European cover too.

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
I have no idea if this is still true, but back in the 1980's the RAC patrols were recruited from experienced motor fitters. The AA recruited people with no prior motor trade experience and put them on a training course.

s5tuart

593 posts

234 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
So the AA have the most up to date training??

AlexanderV8

1,497 posts

234 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
V8 GRF said:
Ubernoober said:
Just a snippet of info - if you have a Platinum Current a/c with LLoyds, you get AA Homestart Relay etc breakdown cover free included in the monthly charge (along with other freebies stuff included in the charges).

I've never had call to use it so have no idea how good/bad it is.

and no, I don't work for 'em
I get my RAC membership free included in the monthly charge with my Barclays Additions Plus account and that includes European cover too.
EFA
biglaughwink


xxplod

2,269 posts

275 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Been with RAC for 10 years or so. Called them out a handful of times with the old Mini. Never had to wait too long - technicians always seem to know their stuff.

nia198

Original Poster:

115 posts

227 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Hmmm. Sounds like there's not a lot in it. Don't really want to pay any more than the basic roadside package, so it's £33 from RAC or £37.50 from The AA. Will make a decision and go ne way or the other in the next day or so...

Aubrey

1,157 posts

227 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
cloggy said:
What discount do we get with the RAC for being a TVRCC member?
I'm a TVRCC member and recently took out the top level RAC cover and got 25% off. This continues every year unlike the one-off discount on their website.

Aubrey

1,157 posts

227 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
By the way, what does EFA and ETA stand for? Probably a stupid question smile

nia198

Original Poster:

115 posts

227 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Ok - Decided on RAC. have joined the basic package with the 25% discount, but will definately make use of the TVRCC 15% discount for next year's renewal. I'm pretty sure you wouldn't be able to use both togther in teh first year.

Cheers.. Nick

Range Rover Blue

23 posts

224 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Personally I don't have any confidence in either the RAC or the AA. When I have had cause to use them I am often left stranded for an hour only to be confronted with a little patrol van that would go in my boot. I then get to wait another hour for the correct recovery vehicle as it is invariably a sub-contractor.

This last year I have been covered by the caravan club's mayday service, which is Green Flag. I called them out once and within the hour I was on my way home, the car was beyond repair at the roadside, the control centre took my word for it and sent a flat bed.

It's also cheaper than either the RAC or the AA with the added benefit that if my trailer develops a fault I am still covered, my trailer is covered right up to 23 feet in length which with the "big 2" it is not and for an extra bonus if they cannot repair my car then I get taken to my destination (holiday) then if the car still cannot be fixed in time, I get recovered home as well.

I thought it worth mentioning as I know some of you have TVRs as track day cars and tow them there, my cover is any car and any trailer, provided it has a 50mm ball hitch.

AlexanderV8

1,497 posts

234 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Aubrey said:
By the way, what does EFA and ETA stand for? Probably a stupid question smile

EFA = Edited For Accuracy.
ETA = Edited To Add (or Estimated Time of Arrival).
Mick