Hypothetical (sp) question...
Hypothetical (sp) question...
Author
Discussion

steve.c

Original Poster:

12,530 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
As title, If someone was driving to the speed/conditions of the road when another vehicle pulls out into your way, and the someone driving had the quick thought to swerve across the white line to avoid a collision but in doing so hits a vehicle coming in the opposite direction, could or would the driver who pulled out of the side road be held responsible for the accident if there were witnesses who could state the facts?

shocker-z

554 posts

249 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
I think it would be disputed between yourself and the driver that pulled out. If he clearly pulled out into the road as in in your way then i beleive all insurance would go via his but the car that you hit head on would claim off you then you reimburse off the car that pulled out.

If however he simply started pulling out slowly for a bettwer view and it was your miss judgment then i spose it could come down to you.

However all depends on the seriousness of the accident.

all my opinion nothing solid to it.

Liam

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Most likely your fault as you "should" have been able to stop. Not fair I know, but that is how it seems to work.

SamHH

5,078 posts

247 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
EU_Foreigner said:
Most likely your fault as you "should" have been able to stop. Not fair I know, but that is how it seems to work.
Why? If that were the case then you would have to drive very slowly when approaching a side turning.

Blimey!

759 posts

226 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
SamHH said:
EU_Foreigner said:
Most likely your fault as you "should" have been able to stop. Not fair I know, but that is how it seems to work.
Why? If that were the case then you would have to drive very slowly when approaching a side turning.
Exactly - try pulling out in front of a police car.

being able to stop in the distance you can see is all very well, but if someone decreases that distance through their carelessness, then all bets are off - they can be charged with driving without due care and attention even if they were not involved in the accident they caused.

JMGS4

8,935 posts

301 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
Happened to me in '72, driving a company car into Bath from Frome. A lorry pulled out from between a high-walled lane, without looking and forced me into the oncoming traffic. I rattled down the sides of 5 cars, and the lorry driver disappeared. BiB came and took my, and the other drivers' statements, they looked for and found the lorry driver (delivering building materials to a farm) and his insurance apparently paid for everything as well as he being prosecuted.

shocker-z

554 posts

249 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
JMGS4 said:
Happened to me in '72, driving a company car into Bath from Frome. A lorry pulled out from between a high-walled lane, without looking and forced me into the oncoming traffic. I rattled down the sides of 5 cars, and the lorry driver disappeared. BiB came and took my, and the other drivers' statements, they looked for and found the lorry driver (delivering building materials to a farm) and his insurance apparently paid for everything as well as he being prosecuted.
Just as i thought then, bet he got prosected with leaving the sean of an accident too didnt he?


Liam

JMGS4

8,935 posts

301 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
JMGS4 said:
Happened to me in '72, driving a company car into Bath from Frome. A lorry pulled out from between a high-walled lane, without looking and forced me into the oncoming traffic. I rattled down the sides of 5 cars, and the lorry driver disappeared. BiB came and took my, and the other drivers' statements, they looked for and found the lorry driver (delivering building materials to a farm) and his insurance apparently paid for everything as well as he being prosecuted.
Just as i thought then, bet he got prosected with leaving the sean of an accident too didnt he?Liam
IIRR he was done for dangerous driving (or without due care), leaving the scene, and something else..he lost his license for a year and paid over £500,-which was HUUUUGE in those days...

timskipper

1,306 posts

297 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
shocker-z said:
Just as i thought then, bet he got prosected with leaving the sean of an accident too didnt he?
What even if his name isn't Sean?

Rob_J

14,036 posts

252 months

Thursday 13th March 2008
quotequote all
JMGS4 said:
Happened to me in '72, driving a company car into Bath from Frome. A lorry pulled out from between a high-walled lane, without looking and forced me into the oncoming traffic. I rattled down the sides of 5 cars, and the lorry driver disappeared. BiB came and took my, and the other drivers' statements, they looked for and found the lorry driver (delivering building materials to a farm) and his insurance apparently paid for everything as well as he being prosecuted.
Similar thing here.

Car pulled out of junction, car coming other way braked & swerved to my side of road. Me & car coming other way have head on. Car that pulled out drives off. Fortunately we got the registration plate. Insurance company traced the driver that pulled out & his insurance paid on both claims even though his car was undamaged. No police involved so he never got prosecuted.