Census Questions ?
Author
Discussion

Earl Grey

Original Poster:

1,370 posts

241 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
If you know your car is Legal Etc. can you refuse to take part ?

what can they do ?

Can they really stop you ?

Does any one have the answer ?

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Earl Grey said:
If you know your car is Legal Etc. can you refuse to take part ?
In a census, yes.

Earl Grey said:
what can they do ?
As soon as you have made it clear that you do not wish to participate, they must allow you on your way without unreasonable delay.

Earl Grey said:
Can they really stop you ?
Yes. You must stop if the signs say so or if directed to do so by a constable in uniform.

Earl Grey said:
Does any one have the answer ?
See above..wink

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Earl Grey said:
If you know your car is Legal Etc. can you refuse to take part ?

what can they do ?

Can they really stop you ?

Does any one have the answer ?
If directed into a census queue by a police office you cannot disobey the instruction. You are under no obligation to assist the census taker and can refuse to speak to them. I usually smile and say 'no comment'

tigger1

8,484 posts

252 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
Earl Grey said:
If you know your car is Legal Etc. can you refuse to take part ?

what can they do ?

Can they really stop you ?

Does any one have the answer ?
If directed into a census queue by a police office you cannot disobey the instruction. You are under no obligation to assist the census taker and can refuse to speak to them. I usually smile and say 'no comment'
hehe

It's true - you MUST stop, but you don't have to take part, "I'm in a hurry, this bombs on a timer mate" might not be the best answer though

Trax

1,601 posts

263 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Bloody hate these, my partner was late for work a few weeks ago after we were held in traffic for 30 mins because of one of these.

Surley once past the officer that is dirtecting you into the layby, his responsability has gone, I would just drive past the numpty census guy, and back out into traffic, that way I would have satisfied the officer direction to pull in?

We werent asked to stop this time but I would have just ignored him. Cretins!

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
I got suckered into one of these a few years ago going into Aberdeen, Dual carriageway with right hand lane closure signs in advance, so me being the compliant guy that I am move to the left hand lane in plenty of time only to get filtered into the census area, right hand lane open and everyone in the right hand lane not complying with the signage on their merry way!!! Totally stupid questions and made me late for an appointment at hospital!!

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Pull in, hand them a bill for your wasted time, and get the name of the Police Officer who abused his power in stopping your vehicle when you were under no legal obligation to answer their questions.

Chrispy Porker

17,760 posts

259 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Pull in, hand them a bill for your wasted time, and get the name of the Police Officer who abused his power in stopping your vehicle when you were under no legal obligation to answer their questions.
Quite right
Sue the police.
And don't forget to let me know how much money you receive in damages.
Would anyone care to guess?

spikeyhead

20,640 posts

228 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Would anyone care to guess?
It would be a nice round figure, very similar to a donut.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Quite right
Sue the police.
And don't forget to let me know how much money you receive in damages.
Would anyone care to guess?
Sorry, but simply put, if the Police are being used in this way, that is not acceptable. Abusing the power of stop to answer a few questions the Govt want answered is not right. The only way to deal with it, is to cause them more hassle so it isn't worth their while. This is how to do that.

Consequential loss of the action in making you stop, for some that could be rather valuable...

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Who cares? Oh no I have to pull in, refuse and pull out again. Life is so hard!

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Aren't they gathering information that would used to improve the roads?

colin_p

4,503 posts

243 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Aren't they gathering information that would used to improve the roads?
Probably quite the opposite.

Chrispy Porker

17,760 posts

259 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Chrispy Porker said:
Quite right
Sue the police.
And don't forget to let me know how much money you receive in damages.
Would anyone care to guess?
Sorry, but simply put, if the Police are being used in this way, that is not acceptable. Abusing the power of stop to answer a few questions the Govt want answered is not right. The only way to deal with it, is to cause them more hassle so it isn't worth their while. This is how to do that.

Consequential loss of the action in making you stop, for some that could be rather valuable...
Well I await with interest the result of an action against the police.
A lot of fuss about nothing if you ask me.

AndrewTait

1,849 posts

225 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
I had the misfortune to get "ordered" into a census about 7 years ago! I must have totally screwed their figures up though, as I was working as a field specialist for a large engineering company, and had travelled from High Wycombe to Manchester for a meeting, and then travelling back to High Wycombe due to an on going problem.

However, my home address was in Manchester, so due to the questions they asked/were phrased, it looked as though I had travelled from Manchester to H.W., back to Manchester, and then to H.W. and back again in the same day.

I'm sure they must have reviewed/changed the questions by now, to stop this kind of problem.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Well I await with interest the result of an action against the police.
A lot of fuss about nothing if you ask me.
I hope someone does.

I don't believe the police should use their powers for such a purpose. It isn't a legitimate use of the power.

Do you think you should also have the right to stop and search us in the street whilst asking about Census questions? It's the same thing to me.

Poledriver

29,623 posts

225 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
bounce OOOHH I hope they wave me into one when I'm out in my TVR wedge, I'll sit there and hold a long discussion, while holding the engine at about 2,000 revs! Hope they've been issued with ear defenders! evil

Chrispy Porker

17,760 posts

259 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Chrispy Porker said:
Well I await with interest the result of an action against the police.
A lot of fuss about nothing if you ask me.
I hope someone does.

I don't believe the police should use their powers for such a purpose. It isn't a legitimate use of the power.

Do you think you should also have the right to stop and search us in the street whilst asking about Census questions? It's the same thing to me.
Really?
A voluntary census equals a search.
How peculiar.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Jasandjules said:
Chrispy Porker said:
Well I await with interest the result of an action against the police.
A lot of fuss about nothing if you ask me.
I hope someone does.

I don't believe the police should use their powers for such a purpose. It isn't a legitimate use of the power.

Do you think you should also have the right to stop and search us in the street whilst asking about Census questions? It's the same thing to me.
Really?
A voluntary census equals a search.
How peculiar.
Maybe we, as law abiding citizens, are sick of being treated like we have something to hide, and the constant intrusion into our private details by the State (which they aren't so feck off Labour).

That, and it's a complete waste of Police manpower.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Really?
A voluntary census equals a search.
How peculiar.
It is indeed peculiar that you call it a "voluntary census".

Tell me, if it's voluntary, why there isn't a sign which says "voluntary census, pull in at the next layby", why is there a Police Officer, whom you commit a criminal offence if you do NOT obey his direction to pull in?
THAT'S Voluntary?

Then explain why the person asking the questions doesn't start with "This is purely voluntary sir".

Not a bit of it, the police are used so that people pull in, and then they are interrogated for no lawful reason. The fact that it is not police business should make it an offence for the officer to abuse his powers in that way (hell, it might be actually, a police officer using his powers for non-police business).