Accident is your fault, but 3rd party is ****ed...
Accident is your fault, but 3rd party is ****ed...
Author
Discussion

davido140

Original Poster:

9,617 posts

257 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Hypothetical question,

I drive into someone, lets say a shunt from behind, no question its my fault.

But the driver of the other vehicle seems to be a bit sozzled, call the BiB, they are drunk and carted away.

does the liability for insurance purposes still lay with me, or is it automatically thier fault as they were pissed?

Cheers


RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
They might get done for DUI, but the accident would still be your fault...

tigger1

8,484 posts

252 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
RichBurley said:
They might get done for DUI, but the accident would still be your fault...
Yes, but they would (possibly) be contributory in their negligence

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Just say they reversed into you.

LaSarthe+Back

2,084 posts

244 months

Friday 14th March 2008
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
Just say they reversed into you.
rofl

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
RichBurley said:
They might get done for DUI, but the accident would still be your fault...
Yes, but they would (possibly) be contributory in their negligence
How? They stop. You behind. You should be at distance to stop safely if they stop for any reason. wink


If they change lane on you without a signal .. or do emergency sto on roundabout (obvious scam if an oldish zero value car rolleyes) - then this may be viewed differently by insurers who are now wise to the scammers who try these on wink (based on R4 prog about 4 month ago.. Told you .. teacher .. I have longest curse of memory laugh

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all

Don't must insurers state that you have to be driving within the law for the policy to be valid. I think mine says something that i've you're drunk driving the policy isn't valid so they wouln't be able to claim the money of you as the person you bumped into has breached the insurence policy at that moment.


FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
If they invalidate their insurance then are they insured for the accident? Thus meaning your insurance company don't have to pay a penny to him.

You need to do some research. Do you have their insurance details? (as you should by now - if not get in touch to the officer in charge of the accident). If so you can ask "theoretical" questions to their insurance companies. Find out what your own company will say with likewise "theoretical" questions.

fat tony

392 posts

238 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
tigger1 said:
RichBurley said:
They might get done for DUI, but the accident would still be your fault...
Yes, but they would (possibly) be contributory in their negligence
How? They stop. You behind. You should be at distance to stop safely if they stop for any reason. wink


If they change lane on you without a signal .. or do emergency sto on roundabout (obvious scam if an oldish zero value car rolleyes) - then this may be viewed differently by insurers who are now wise to the scammers who try these on wink (based on R4 prog about 4 month ago.. Told you .. teacher .. I have longest curse of memory laugh
Not always low or zero value cars now. Been using newer motors for the cash back!

Bibs_LEF

790 posts

238 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Medic-one said:
Don't must insurers state that you have to be driving within the law for the policy to be valid. I think mine says something that i've you're drunk driving the policy isn't valid so they wouln't be able to claim the money of you as the person you bumped into has breached the insurence policy at that moment.
I would imagine that if this were the case the ins co would only invalid the full comp part of the cover, not the third party.

Pissed people running over pedestrians would still be covered for the damage to the 3rd party.

Bibs_LEF

790 posts

238 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Oh, and everyone done for DUI isn't done for no insurance, as they would be if their insurance was invalidated by their sozzled state.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Was there not a change of emphasis some years ago, which could require the driver in front to show that they had reason to stop abruptly? - Streaky

davido140

Original Poster:

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Was there not a change of emphasis some years ago, which could require the driver in front to show that they had reason to stop abruptly? - Streaky
is Slowing down for a safety camera a valid reason?! wink

Not actually happened to me or anyone else, 100% hypothecital! honest!

I was just curious thats all!

Im finally at an age and no-claims level where I can get insured on group 20 stuff and its not too horrific so I get worried about my no claims status with so many plebs on the road! smile not you lot of course! smile

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
If they're drunk, it's their fault, end of.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Bibs_LEF said:
Medic-one said:
Don't must insurers state that you have to be driving within the law for the policy to be valid. I think mine says something that i've you're drunk driving the policy isn't valid so they wouln't be able to claim the money of you as the person you bumped into has breached the insurence policy at that moment.
I would imagine that if this were the case the ins co would only invalid the full comp part of the cover, not the third party.
That's exactly right - quite a few insurance companies do this now and the third party cover remains intact, but they won't pay for damage to your own vehicle.

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Was there not a change of emphasis some years ago, which could require the driver in front to show that they had reason to stop abruptly? - Streaky
I think it relate to jay-walker or some other idiot who would end up very dead if you did not brake sharpish for them.

Per the insurers - the commonest scam ist at roundabout whereby person enter roundabout und then stop. Or suddenly sto at the one which has the zebra or other crossing claiming mythical pedestrian there. In the split second confusion und no witnessses .. this ist easiest scam und why the plans to bring in single lanes und these crossings must be FOUGHT with straightforward common sense argument against. (This in the sexpressed waily stunned und mirrored - then telegraphed .. timed und treated with independence but impressed nanny grauniad .. wink . getmecoat

.. wild feline ist at family party. I think there was brandy in my saucer of milk .. wobbleblablarotatepartyhippybiggrin But no matter - hic .. miaow .. drink

davido140

Original Poster:

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
streaky said:
Was there not a change of emphasis some years ago, which could require the driver in front to show that they had reason to stop abruptly? - Streaky
I think it relate to jay-walker or some other idiot who would end up very dead if you did not brake sharpish for them.

Per the insurers - the commonest scam ist at roundabout whereby person enter roundabout und then stop. Or suddenly sto at the one which has the zebra or other crossing claiming mythical pedestrian there. In the split second confusion und no witnessses .. this ist easiest scam und why the plans to bring in single lanes und these crossings must be FOUGHT with straightforward common sense argument against. (This in the sexpressed waily stunned und mirrored - then telegraphed .. timed und treated with independence but impressed nanny grauniad .. wink . getmecoat

.. wild feline ist at family party. I think there was brandy in my saucer of milk .. wobbleblablarotatepartyhippybiggrin But no matter - hic .. miaow .. drink
At the risk of sounding like an utter sycophant I do love the way you write your posts!

Always littered with ist, und and a million smilies!

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
davido140 replying to me said:
At the risk of sounding like an utter sycophant I do love the way you write your posts!

Always littered with ist, und and a million smilies!
Merci vilmal love


English .. ?

Mama was actually from Yorkshire Dales. She learn German. By time I arrive in family - she too busy to immerse me like the rest in English.. or Yorkshire version laugh

I mucked around in class.. I suppose I never learned to speak or write proper as result. I used to spell check everything. It take too much time. rolleyes

But no matter . if I make folk smile or smile und still grit teeth und clench typing fingers.. laugh - I still cheer them up a bit wink perhaps .. confused

mikechandler

1,998 posts

233 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Fort Jefferson said:
If they're drunk, it's their fault, end of.
If only it was that simple

There used to be a claims company near Levenshulme IIRC that had a massive sign outside the front actively chasing claims from people who had non-fault accidents if they had no insurance.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Indeed. If you are drunk and a building falls on your head, because it was unsafe, what has your state got to do with the negligence ?

Fault is fault. You were negligent, end of. However there are some situations whereby contributory negligence might come into play. You were not wearing your seat belt, for example. But contibutory negligence is NOT fault. Yes, if perhaps you were more severely injured because you were drunk, then there might be contrib. But it would not be 100% if you got any at all.

The TP liability insurance part of your policy will continue, no matter what your state. That is laid down in the Road Traffic Act.

Knowingly being a passenger with someone drunk is another matter, however.



Edited by Noger on Sunday 16th March 17:06