Stopping in a safe place
Author
Discussion

Matthew-TMM

Original Poster:

4,028 posts

268 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
HC Rule 106

Police stopping procedures. If the police want to stop your vehicle they will, where possible, attract your attention by flashing blue lights, headlights or sounding their siren or horn, usually from behind
directing you to pull over to the side by pointing and/or using the left indicator.

You MUST then pull over and stop as soon as it is safe to do so. Then switch off your engine.


[Law RTA 1988 sect 163]


So how do the BiB define a safe place? After all, there are stretches of road where I wouldn't consider it safe to stop for a few miles. If stopped, would you get a ticking off for taking a maybe a few miles to find somewhere you consider safe? In particular, I'm thinking of dual carriageways with fencing instead of a verge, somewhere I wouldn't personally want to stop, and nowhere to turn off for a while.

Andyr86

209 posts

230 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
happened to me once. Got flashed down a country road which it is not sutible to stop for 4 - 5 miles. Just raised my hand, carried on at speed limit and pulled over when safe. Mr Law didn't even mention not stopping.

Ricky_M

6,618 posts

250 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
I've also wondered about this, what is the recognised way of showing an Police Officer that you know they want you to stop but your finding a safe place?

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Saturday 15th March 2008
quotequote all
Heard of a few cases now with the prevalence of un marked cars (and scrotes immitating them) that it has been deemed acceptable to drive to a police station before stopping, something to do with the increase in car jacking or something?

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
If they indicate to you to stop, then stop. If they have a brain in their head they will try and stop you somewhere suitable. Don't go driving off to the nearest station, you are liable to be arrested for failing to stop when requested to do so. If you've stopped in a bad place they will no doubt tell you to move somewhere else.

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Hollywood Wheels said:
Don't go driving off to the nearest station, you are liable to be arrested for failing to stop when requested to do so.
I've heard about that as well, that if an unmarked car tried to pull you over you can drive to the nearest police station as you cannot tell for sure it actually is a police car behind you or not.

Any bibs that can confirm this ?

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Hollywood Wheels said:
If they indicate to you to stop, then stop. If they have a brain in their head they will try and stop you somewhere suitable. Don't go driving off to the nearest station, you are liable to be arrested for failing to stop when requested to do so. If you've stopped in a bad place they will no doubt tell you to move somewhere else.
I've had this.

Got pulled by an accident investigation van, for doing 80 on a four lane dual carriageway junction, where the workmen had left the 60 signs out from the night before, as they did every day, for months on end. I wasn't the fastest, many more doing nearly the ton, and my little car only does 85!!

It looks like a bit of a snotter, and I think he thought he'd get me on condition of the vehicle because he spent some time kicking the tyres.

Eventually, he came to the window, and asked me how fast I was going. To which I replied "80", and kinda suggested "come off it mate, we're going to cause an accident". By this time, I think he realised what he had done, and was getting a bit worried about the fast rush hour traffic, swerving to avoid him and me half on the verge, and half on the road so he let me go.

As we pulled away, I had to be in the far lane, and my car is about as fast as a snail, so what did he do, he pulled right into the view of my wing mirror, and then wondered why I wouldn't pull out.

Either he had little practical experience of traffic, or, he was an arse in a uniform.

Edited by dilbert on Sunday 16th March 02:06

AndyRw

740 posts

240 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Medic-one said:
if an unmarked car tried to pull you over you can drive to the nearest police station as you cannot tell for sure it actually is a police car behind you or not.
http://www.askthe.police.uk/Content/Q587.htm

Just make sure you acknowledge the request to stop. Chances are a marked vehicle will join you before you make it to a Police station.

Quinny said:
I've seen people pulled over in some pretty unsuitable locations. Examples, next to a junctionrolleyes also where there are double solid white linesrolleyes
I'm sure there will be some who choose inappropriate places to switch on the lights, but equally:
  • sometimes the standard of driving seen is so bad that they need stopping straight away - often true of the drink drivers, who weave all over the place and bounce off the kerbs
  • there are alot of inattentive drivers who blissfully continue along past the layby that the Officer wanted them to pull into, etc..., without noticing the blue lights that came on several hundred yards before it, then suddenly notice them and stop in a poor place (or don't and end up being pursued at low speed). Trafpol seem to have more luck than us - I would imagine because their LED lightbars are far more effective both day and night.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
Unmarked car? - not sure I'd be stopping unless I was 100% it had uniformed officers inside.

But...think of it from the other point of view. Your pet dog might be running along behind the car, lead trapped in the boot and you might need to stop urgently to avoid injury etc. You might be a complete scrote about to run. You might be blind (drunk) and not have seen him. You might be the chap they are looking for who just produced a knife at a petrol station.

At least acknowledging the other car's request indicates that you are not in the upper echelons of scumbag society and the officer can move onto "let's all be reasonable" setting rather than a "I'm about to get stabbed and need to control this situation by being the biggest most aggressive terrier" setting.

a boardman

1,316 posts

231 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
and I assume that stopping like a small kid had just run out in front of you would also not be the best idea,

Furberger

719 posts

230 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
I say you stop where you like as long as you can justify your actions. I'm not having someone stop me in a dangerous place and put my life in danger.
If asked why I carried on half a mile to the layby instead of stopping then and there I'd explain my actions and be happy to live with the consequences.

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Sunday 16th March 2008
quotequote all
The only times I've been pulled over they waited for a safe place. 2 of those were for having a defective tail light (different cars 2 years apart) which I hadnt noticed. They waited for a long straight on an A road both times before doing the stop. The other one was speeding , got pulled for 90 on an NSL DC, but no blues until I left the DC and was about a mile down an A road, lights on just as a parking bay came up. Sensible chaps !

No matter if its marked or unmarked I would stay in the car with doors locked (as they always are when driving). if marked car and uniform plod then window down, follow instructions. If unmarked crack window , keep engine on and in gear, if its plod then switch off and follow instruction.

To be honest there must be thousands of stops every day in the UK, but only once every few years do we hear about someone pretending to be the police and stopping people so I'd say your chances are so slim of it NOT being plod you shouldnt really worry about it....




jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Correct me if i haven't noticed but there doesn't appear to have been any bib responses to this one, be nice to find out what the official stance is on this , whether they want you to stop right away or if unmarked it is permissable to carry on to somewhere more populated or a police station to stop, i do believe with better alarms and stuff that carjacking is becoming a more prevalent way of getting their mitts on good cars (criminals that is)

Matthew-TMM

Original Poster:

4,028 posts

268 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Sorry I haven't responded, I forgot I'd started this thread. I'm talking about the sort of place where there's a dual carriageway with fencing to the left, so to stop you'd be stationary in the left hand lane - unsafe in my opinion.

I've now asked the same question on that ask the police a question website.

Edited by Matthew-TMM on Monday 17th March 21:02

erdnase

1,963 posts

232 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all

If someone who were a very good driver were flashed to stop on an NSL road, but decided, after acknowledging the request, to continue to a safer place...

...then the askpolice website states to continue to the safer stopping place, but do not speed away. So if it were a road where most drivers could do 40mph say, but our expert driver can carry on at 60mph, thus leaving the police car behind, but not speeding.. smile

Matthew-TMM

Original Poster:

4,028 posts

268 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Here's the response I got:

Matthew

This is really a matter where common sense should be exercised. If it
was
necessary for the police to pull you over, they will be well aware of
the
restrictions on that stretch of road. You would not be penalised for
driving further on to a safe area as long as it was 'reasonable'.

Please note:
PNLD does not have the resources to research every email in depth. This
reply is intended as a guide only. The advice you are given is based on
the
information provided. You are advised to seek professional advice
before
any further action is taken, see Terms and Conditions for further
information.

Regards PNLD


So the sort of answer I'd hoped for really. thumbup