Secret motorways
Discussion
I'm sure that's the term, but it may be something different/similar.
I remember reading about them a while ago, and think I drove on one yesterday. Basically it's a dual carriageway, NSL road, with a hard shoulder, and a specific restriction (sign posted) on <50cc and farm vehicles. So basically it's a motorway, but it's not.

Can anyone shed any light on them? What's their purpose, and if I leave the M77 to travel to East Kilbride (forget the name of the road now!), is that a so called "secret motorway"?
There are a number of roads throughout Scotland (and probably England too but I can't be definitive) which the government decided in the early 1990s should be "near motorway standard" but not upgraded to motorways. Examples were the A9 between Stirling and Perth, and the A90 between Perth and Dundee.
The A725 between the M77 and East Kilbride (The Glasgow Southern Orbital) mentioned by the OP has only just been built, again to "near-motorway" standard. That route emerged from the same national study in the early 1990s.
The Design Manual has much more stringent requirements on motorway access junctions, which need a lot of land. "Near-motorway" junctions aren't any less safe but need less land. Also - those roads have some local accesses that you can't just close up, but which wouldn't be permitted from a motorway.
Main reason for not doing a full upgrade is that motorways are out of bounds to a whole range of vehicles including tractors learner drivers etc - if you "motorway" the road then you need a parallel distributor road for all the local traffic and all the local accesses etc. While that's what you would ideally like to do, the cost and programme for doing it is horrendous (and that's if you can get the land without demolishing half of the buildings along the route).
Sometimes that's the best option - the Highways Agency's A1 upgrading at Scotch Corner proposes such an arrangement - but the decision that was made on these other roads was to close as many of the local accesses as possible, grade-separate most the major junctions but leave them as dual carriageway - not motorways but better and safer dual carriageways than they were before.
The A725 between the M77 and East Kilbride (The Glasgow Southern Orbital) mentioned by the OP has only just been built, again to "near-motorway" standard. That route emerged from the same national study in the early 1990s.
The Design Manual has much more stringent requirements on motorway access junctions, which need a lot of land. "Near-motorway" junctions aren't any less safe but need less land. Also - those roads have some local accesses that you can't just close up, but which wouldn't be permitted from a motorway.
Main reason for not doing a full upgrade is that motorways are out of bounds to a whole range of vehicles including tractors learner drivers etc - if you "motorway" the road then you need a parallel distributor road for all the local traffic and all the local accesses etc. While that's what you would ideally like to do, the cost and programme for doing it is horrendous (and that's if you can get the land without demolishing half of the buildings along the route).
Sometimes that's the best option - the Highways Agency's A1 upgrading at Scotch Corner proposes such an arrangement - but the decision that was made on these other roads was to close as many of the local accesses as possible, grade-separate most the major junctions but leave them as dual carriageway - not motorways but better and safer dual carriageways than they were before.
Edited by tvrgit on Monday 17th March 11:33
10 Pence Short said:
It's about time the A1 north of Dishforth was upgraded. Over the past 10 years it's become a total nightmare.
That's the very bit I referred to above!! There is a scheme designed etc - I think they are waiting for the results of the public inquiry, and then finding the money.Yeah I know, over the past 12 years I used it 3 or 4 times a week up to Scotch Corner and across the '66 to Cumbria.
Sections of road such as the A1 and A66 highlight the total lack of forethought and investment by Parliament over the past 30 years. Both routes should have been fully upgraded a long time ago.
Sections of road such as the A1 and A66 highlight the total lack of forethought and investment by Parliament over the past 30 years. Both routes should have been fully upgraded a long time ago.
10 Pence Short said:
Yeah I know, over the past 12 years I used it 3 or 4 times a week up to Scotch Corner and across the '66 to Cumbria.
Sections of road such as the A1 and A66 highlight the total lack of forethought and investment by Parliament over the past 30 years. Both routes should have been fully upgraded a long time ago.
I think it's less than 30 years. 30 years ago roads and motorways were still being built like they were going out of fashion.Sections of road such as the A1 and A66 highlight the total lack of forethought and investment by Parliament over the past 30 years. Both routes should have been fully upgraded a long time ago.
Oh hang on... they were (but not till much later)!
10 Pence Short said:
Yeah I know, over the past 12 years I used it 3 or 4 times a week up to Scotch Corner and across the '66 to Cumbria.
Sections of road such as the A1 and A66 highlight the total lack of forethought and investment by Parliament over the past 30 years. Both routes should have been fully upgraded a long time ago.
Isn't there an e-petition running for that? Think I saw it while looking for the unfair VED one.Sections of road such as the A1 and A66 highlight the total lack of forethought and investment by Parliament over the past 30 years. Both routes should have been fully upgraded a long time ago.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


