Speed cameras collect over £100m in fines.......
Speed cameras collect over £100m in fines.......
Author
Discussion

catso

Original Poster:

16,561 posts

298 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Well done, bravo, congratulations..... claprolleyes

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/ne...


Speed cameras collect over £100m in fines
By Gary Cleland
Last Updated: 2:36am GMT 16/03/2008

Speed cameras made more than £100 million last year, leading campaigners to call for an end to the “war on motorists”.

Budget 2008: Higher tax for 9 in 10 drivers
DVLA made £9 million selling drivers' details

New figures released by the Department for Transport (DfT) revealed that the 38 safety camera partnerships in England and Wales raised £104.4m in 2006/07.

Critics say motorists are being 'punished for driving'
Motorists in London were hit the hardest, paying £7.5m in fines, while drivers in Mid and South Wales paid up £5.9m and those in the Thames Valley paid £4.5m.

In contrast, just £724,860 was raised in camera fines in Gloucestershire.

The figures cover the financial year until April 2007 and the partnerships were able to keep the profit they made for themselves.

Motoring groups said that speed cameras are being used to punish people for driving, and that real road safety issues are being ignored.

Nigel Humphries, spokesman for the Association of British Drivers, said: “To raise more than £100m, these cameras have caused a lot of anguish, heartbreak and anger and have had absolutely no benefit for road safety.

“The whole safety issue is being used as an excuse to bring in restrictions for motorists.

“They are not looking at the real causes of accidents, which are observation and judgement related.”
A spokesman for campaign group speedcameras.org said: “According to the DfT’s own figures, only five per cent of all traffic accidents are caused by drivers exceeding the speed limit.

“You have to ask yourself what is being done about the 95 per cent of accidents that speed cameras cannot possibly do anything about.

“Drivers without a licence, insurance or tax are four to five times more likely to be involved in an accident - they should be the top priority for the police.”

The new figures come at a time when motorists are increasingly unhappy with the soaring cost of driving.

The Daily Telegraph has revealed that nine out of ten cars would be affected by higher rates of tax under plans announced in the Budget.

The Department for Transport said that once operating costs were accounted for, speed cameras in England and Wales brought in a profit of £6.4m, down from £15m the previous year, when £114.6m was collected in fines altogether.

New rules mean that profit raised this year will not be kept by individual partnerships, but handed to the Government.

The money will then be redistributed back to the partnerships in the form of grants.

Edmund King, president of the AA, said: “Perhaps some of the partnerships lost their enthusiasm for cameras last year, knowing that at the beginning of the next year the system was going to change.”

Mr King added that drivers were increasingly aware of where speed cameras were situated.

A DfT spokeswoman said: “Safety cameras are there to save lives, not make money.

“Independent research has shown there are 1,745 fewer deaths and serious injuries at camera sites each year.

“These figures show the total amount paid in fines has fallen by more than £10m, which is good news for everyone.

“The Government has always been clear that the best safety camera is the one which doesn’t issue a single ticket as it means that people are driving safely and within the speed limit.”






supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
"Independent research has shown there are 1,745 fewer deaths and serious injuries at camera sites each year."

No st sherlock.

Two years ago a car crashed on the road outside my house for the first time in living memory. I immediately dressed the tree nearby with a brown ribbon and guess what? Independant research has shown that there is one fewer serious injury at my brown ribbon site for each year since. That's two lives/serious injuries saved.

Where's my grant?

SM

Soren2

251 posts

226 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
"Independent research has shown there are 1,745 fewer deaths and serious injuries at camera sites each year."


Camera zones of influence cover about 2% of the road network, on which there will be on average 637 KSIs each year. (31,845/50)

How many of these can cameras reduce?

Apparently 1745!!

Does anyone actually believe this anymore!

Independent research my arse!


Edited to correct figures!



Edited by Soren2 on Monday 17th March 20:23

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
I guess some people really will never be convinced about speed cameras. The government obviously invented the "independent" research as part of the whole revenue raising conspiracy.

It's not a war on motorists, it's a war on bad motorists.

Soren2 said:
Camera zones of influence cover about 2% of the road network, on which there will be on average 637 KSIs each year. (31,845/50)
Speed cameras are not placed on average parts of the road network, so those average statistics are irrelevant to camera sites.

Edited by thewurzel on Monday 17th March 20:28

alphadog

2,049 posts

264 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
Speed cameras are not placed on average parts of the road network, so those average statistics are irrelevant to camera sites.
Like the M6 in Cumbria for instance? Typical fatal accidents caused by drunks walking across road, cars leaving road (driver asleep?), trucks (limited to less than their legal max speed). The answer is speed cameras, now what's the question?

Show me a sensible and prudent location for a speed camera and I'll show you a pointless one. It's not the universal panacaea that I fear you believe it is!

Taita

8,019 posts

234 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I guess some people really will never be convinced about speed cameras. The government obviously invented the "independent" research as part of the whole revenue raising conspiracy.

It's not a war on motorists, it's a war on bad motorists.

Soren2 said:
Camera zones of influence cover about 2% of the road network, on which there will be on average 637 KSIs each year. (31,845/50)
Speed cameras are not placed on average parts of the road network, so those average statistics are irrelevant to camera sites.

Edited by thewurzel on Monday 17th March 20:28
Mods please excuse me momentarily.

Wurzel, will you please fking shut up, you are chatting st on every speed related post and you are getting on mine, and many others, hairy tits. Button up, and feck off under the bridge.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Taita said:
Wurzel, will you please fking shut up, you are chatting st on every speed related post and you are getting on mine, and many others, hairy tits. Button up, and feck off under the bridge.
rolleyes I don't agree with the opinions of some posters here either, but I like to actually debate the issues, not just shout abuse when I can't refute an opinion wink

alphadog said:
Like the M6 in Cumbria for instance? Typical fatal accidents caused by drunks walking across road, cars leaving road (driver asleep?), trucks (limited to less than their legal max speed). The answer is speed cameras, now what's the question?

Show me a sensible and prudent location for a speed camera and I'll show you a pointless one. It's not the universal panacaea that I fear you believe it is!
I don't doubt that there are some in less useful locations than others, but this doesn't make them all bad. I'd rather have some in crap locations and some in good locations than none at all. Ultimately, they don't catch people who aren't speeding in the first place, regardless of their location, visibility etc.

As an aside, I don't think speed cameras are some kind of magic fix for dangerous drivers on the roads, and that they should be there to supplement traffic officers, not replace them.

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
alphadog said:
Show me a sensible and prudent location for a speed camera and I'll show you a pointless one. It's not the universal panacaea that I fear you believe it is!
According to UK Gov own figures, the 6,000 UK speed
cameras save about 100 lives per year.

The 1,745 figure is for deaths *and* serious injuries,
hence about 1,645 of those are the serious injuries.

In other words, it takes about 60 speed cameras to
save one life per year.

Not as much use a chocolate teapot, in other words.

Given the couple of million motorists per year prosecuted
for speeding, it's pretty clear that some pretty
serious massaging of the figures, by including
serious injuries, has to be done to make speed cameras
look good.

andmole

1,594 posts

242 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Taita said:
Mods please excuse me momentarily.

Wurzel, will you please fking shut up, you are chatting st on every speed related post and you are getting on mine, and many others, hairy tits. Button up, and feck off under the bridge.
I'd like to make one point here, I don't feel I can take seriously the views of someone who hides behind a totally anonymous profile, and who is not prepared to divulge his interest in the issues. By interest I mean a vested interest that prevents that person from having an unbiased opinion.

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
The thing that really gripes me every single time they try to justify the cameras they quote the same thing "accidents at camera sites are down" OF COURSE THEY ARE!! whose gonna crash on that 100 metres of stripes after they slow down for them!! And apparently if they do have the desired effect and reduce ksi accidents they are supposed to be re assessed and moved somewhere else, anyone ever heard of 1 being taken away after sited? Theres 1 outside Aberdeen that regularly faces up the dual carriageway (away from the cross over junction which is used as the reason for it being there) and lo and behold there have been no Ksi accidents for 3 years so why is it still there? Rant over Ta,
Gary

delboy735

1,656 posts

233 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
What really pisses me off, is that everybody and his/her brother/sister knows that "speed cameras" are there for the fking money.....end of.

Even fat bd Brown knows they are there for the money....obviously, but all we ever do is fking moan on this site!!!

If all motorists and motoring organisations got together to protest, and have a full days go slow, the country would grind to a halt, and just maybe, the government in its Ivory tower would get the message that we as motorists are pissed off about being taken for a ride............no pun intended.

We all know that this will never happen. Thats why I no longer own a car.fking expense. Tax on fuel, cost of MOT,Very real fear of fking speeding ticket for creeping over the limit and giving yet more of my hard earned money to fat bd brown.

Wish I had enough money ( and bottle) to emigrate from this godforsaken island we call home!!



Climbs off soap box.getmecoat


Sorry if anyone is offended..........................just having a senior moment.

bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
hmm, 85% of people think that speed cameras are a good idea, BUT, i've never met one.

Even a mate of mine who works for a camera partnership doesn't. He did, until the call came to lower all the trigger thresholds. For instance, there used to be a camera covering a piece of road that boy bracers used to use. 40MPH limit, and the camera was set at 65MPH. Yes, it caught the nutters and left everyone else alone, until it was dropped to 46MPH, and you couldn't fill it with film quick enough.

It was basically set at the +25 threshold, which I don't think is too unreasonable to be honest.

Interestingly, in Hull, when the 'catching killers' slogan was favourite and the netting off sceme started, the vans were out practically 24/7. The rules have changed and you never see the vans now. All about safety of course.

bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
what you're seeing chaps is the power of marketting, which is what this government is very very good at. You can sell ANYTHING with the correct marketting. Just look at bottled water sales!

Number of people killed or seriously injured at camera sites goes down after camera is installed- TRUE

Average speeds are down at camera sites - TRUE

Hit someone slower and they have more chance of living - TRUE

No profit, money left over after running camera operation has to be given to government - TRUE


Sounds difficult to argue with, says mr gullible camera partnership representative, and on the fact of it he'd be right, HOWEVER.......................


The KSI figure is an amalgamation of the killed and seriously injured statistics. SI is much much larger, so an increase in K - which there has been, is masked by it. SI is simply at least an overnight stay in hospital which due to lack of beds, better paramedic care, changes in procedure means it's gone down naturally anyway MASKING the K figure. Transpires that the hospital admissions figures don't tally with the police njuries figures anyway. For some reason!

Cameras are placed where there have been 4 KSIs. Doesn't matter if these are 4 people in 1 car in the ice, or 4 seperate accidents, or swerving to miss a dog or whatever. Most accidents are by their very nature 'accidents' and one off occurences. 1 car with 4 in has a blow out and hits a tree, up goes the camera, and would you believe, no more accidents. As the criteria favours scenarios like this, you will in most instances see a fall in KSI's- regression to the mean. You could have put a lolly pop stick in the ground and the same thing would have happened.

People slam on when they see cameras or drive slower anyway. whoopy do.

Hit the little girl at 40 and there's an 80% chance she'll die. Hit her at 30 and there's 80% chance she'll live. That goes up to 99.999% if she knew the green cross code, could hear the car coming, and the driver was watching the road and not the speedo.
At why is it OK to kill 1 in 5 anyway?

rant over.

I'm off to bed.

bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
ps. forgot about the last point.................

Money spent on running the scheme, no profit. Very true. After the new cars, listed building for the offices, air conditioning, oak office furniture, subsidised canteen, private parking spaces, 'fact finding missions', and the Xmas party, any profit if given to the government.


it's not about the money, la la la la la

night night.


thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
delboy735 said:
What really pisses me off, is that everybody and his/her brother/sister knows that "speed cameras" are there for the fking money.....end of.

Even fat bd Brown knows they are there for the money....obviously, but all we ever do is fking moan on this site!!!

If all motorists and motoring organisations got together to protest
But that's the thing - most regular motorists support speed cameras, and realise why they exist. This and other motoring forums are not exactly representative of the motoring public.

delboy735 said:
, and have a full days go slow, the country would grind to a halt, and just maybe, the government in its Ivory tower would get the message that we as motorists are pissed off about being taken for a ride............no pun intended.
I hear that those "Don't buy petrol" days have been doing great at reducing fuel prices biggrin

bryan35 said:
hmm, 85% of people think that speed cameras are a good idea, BUT, i've never met one.
The reactions that some speed camera haters give you for suggesting you support them might tell you why people might not want to admit it around you. They probably just don't want to be bored by an anti speed camera rant.

bryan35 said:
It was basically set at the +25 threshold, which I don't think is too unreasonable to be honest.
Interesting that you think that way. How would you feel if, instead of reducing the camera threshold, they increased the limit to -6 of the camera's trigger?

Edited by thewurzel on Tuesday 18th March 00:42

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
bryan35 said:
what you're seeing chaps is the power of marketting
Very much so, campaigns like "Safe Speed" are very good at convincing people that it's safe to drive at excessive speeds. Pure spin, rather than fact, of course.

bryan35 said:
People slam on when they see cameras or drive slower anyway. whoopy do.
Or in other words, they work.

bryan35 said:
That goes up to 99.999% if she knew the green cross code, could hear the car coming, and the driver was watching the road and not the speedo.
At why is it OK to kill 1 in 5 anyway?
Just from reading this, I can tell you don't have any children of your own. If you have to have your eyes glued to the speedo to stay under the speed limit, maybe you should book a few additional driving lessons.

Nobody says it's ok to kill 1 out of 5 children, just that it's a better result than 4 out of 5.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
bryan35 said:
ps. forgot about the last point.................

Money spent on running the scheme, no profit. Very true. After the new cars, listed building for the offices, air conditioning, oak office furniture, subsidised canteen, private parking spaces, 'fact finding missions', and the Xmas party, any profit if given to the government.


it's not about the money, la la la la la

night night.
The same people who complain about money now would still be complaining if they scrapped the fines and just gave you the points. "Why should I pay for speed cameras out of general taxation, I don't get caught, they should just fine the people who do get caught..." etc

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all

alphadog

2,049 posts

264 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
I don't doubt that there are some in less useful locations than others, but this doesn't make them all bad. I'd rather have some in crap locations and some in good locations than none at all. Ultimately, they don't catch people who aren't speeding in the first place, regardless of their location, visibility etc.

As an aside, I don't think speed cameras are some kind of magic fix for dangerous drivers on the roads, and that they should be there to supplement traffic officers, not replace them.
Personally I'd like to see cameras just deployed in areas where speed over the limit can be demonstrated as the main cause of fatal accidents. Don't forget, we pay a lot of our hard earned cash for the 'privelege' of using the roads - very frustrating to see the cheap and nasty solution that prevails!

Too many 'road safety' schemes now consist of lowering the speed limit and/or increased enforcement. Take a driver through the Peak District and you'll see some high quality primary route 'A' roads with a recently imposed 50 limit. I wrote to Derbyshire enquiring if there had been a large number of accidents caused by vehicles travelling at over 50 - the reply was that statistics of this nature are 'hard to come by'!

Driving legally on these roads has now become a lot more unpleasant and tedious - instead get the map out and find some nice 'C' roads!

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
bryan35 said:
... SI is simply at least an overnight stay in hospital ...
SafeSpeed said:
In the UK, but only for the roads, a serious injury is defined as follows:

"Serious injury: An injury for which a person is detained in hospital as an “in-patient”, or any of the following injuries whether or not they are detained in hospital: fractures, concussion, internal injuries, crushings, burns (excluding friction burns), severe cuts and lacerations, severe general shock requiring medical treatment and injuries causing death 30 or more days after the accident. An injured casualty is recorded as seriously or slightly injured by the police on the basis of information available within a short time of the accident. This generally will not reflect the results of a medical examination, but may be influenced according to whether the casualty is hospitalised or not. Hospitalisation procedures will vary regionally." (from DfT publication: RCGB notes (click here))

An interesting definitions document from IRTAD contains the following snippet:

"Several OECD countries are not able to provide hospitalised data for the time being. For example, in the UK data on those hospitalised are included within the seriously injured category and are not available separately although research indicates that about one-half of serious injuries are hospitalised."

http://www.safespeed.org.uk/serious.html 
My emphasis.

Streaky