Scamera vans......
Author
Discussion

edp190

Original Poster:

336 posts

240 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
Can they catch motorbikes?!

Im referring to Scottish ones namely on the A82 in Glencoe on an overtaking straight thats not got any junctions!!!!!!!! mad


tia

Soren2

251 posts

226 months

Monday 17th March 2008
quotequote all
edp190 said:
Can they catch motorbikes?!

Im referring to Scottish ones namely on the A82 in Glencoe on an overtaking straight thats not got any junctions!!!!!!!! mad


tia
Yes.

They record your speed, then take a note of your number.

Pretty routine.

edp190

Original Poster:

336 posts

240 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Ah i see, so do they have to physically take the rego themselves or do they have another camera pointing the other direction?! cheers

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
edp190 said:
Ah i see, so do they have to physically take the rego themselves or do they have another camera pointing the other direction?! cheers
Assuming they were targetting approaching vehicles from your direction anyway, they could either jot the number down in a notebook as you pass by or, if its possible, they could pan the camera around and record the back of the bike..

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Not from a standing start wink - Streaky

edp190

Original Poster:

336 posts

240 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
lol, they were parked at the side of the road facing me and the van had no side windows and therefore not possible to pan the camera round as you suggest. Also there was no one in the front of the van. I may have got away with it. 13 days to go! smile

Taita

8,018 posts

234 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Surely this can't stand up? A civvy with a notepad in the front of the van, they can't have maintained a view of you at all times surely?

Also, where do they point the laser, no front plate on a bike, surely it could bounce off the rider / hugger / tyre, all of which will cause inaccurate results.

Didn't someone point a laser at the back of an artic and get a reading of 158mph?

Appalling. again.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Aren't there continuity of evidence issues? I mean sure they have a film of a bike going at some random speed but would a judge just take their word for it that it was your bike?

I'm certain they'd issue the tax demand anyway knowing it was dodgy in the hope you'd pay, but I can't see it getting to court, surely?

SM

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Appalling ?

If he was speeding & was caught, no.
If he wasn't & is falsely accused, yes.

What's the problem with someone writing the index down rather than the camera getting it ?

If a car without a front plate drove into a petrol station & the occupants stole a load of items from the shop & then made off, if the staff wrote down the rear index shouldn't that be valid evidence in any legal proceedings even though the camera didn't get it?

Taita

8,018 posts

234 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Appalling ?

If he was speeding & was caught, no.
If he wasn't & is falsely accused, yes.

What's the problem with someone writing the index down rather than the camera getting it ?

If a car without a front plate drove into a petrol station & the occupants stole a load of items from the shop & then made off, if the staff wrote down the rear index shouldn't that be valid evidence in any legal proceedings even though the camera didn't get it?
But what happens if he's got slightly dodgy eyesight, gets it wrong, you wrongly get points, banned, disqualified, lose job / house. Worst case obviously.

There should be a sort of 'chain of visual continuity' where the bike is in sight at all times before some wr writes down the plate.

andmole

1,594 posts

242 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Appalling ?

If he was speeding & was caught, no.
If he wasn't & is falsely accused, yes.

What's the problem with someone writing the index down rather than the camera getting it ?

If a car without a front plate drove into a petrol station & the occupants stole a load of items from the shop & then made off, if the staff wrote down the rear index shouldn't that be valid evidence in any legal proceedings even though the camera didn't get it?
Total lack of trust in the individuals/organisations/legal systems involved as witnessed by this reply, thats the problem!!

supermono said:
Aren't there continuity of evidence issues? I mean sure they have a film of a bike going at some random speed but would a judge just take their word for it that it was your bike?

I'm certain they'd issue the tax demand anyway knowing it was dodgy in the hope you'd pay, but I can't see it getting to court, surely?

SM
Von, much as we all respect the accuracy of the information you provide, it's about time you realised that there is a fundamental breakdown of trust in the system, brought about by the dodgy practises of the scam partnerships and the CPS. Unfortunately this breakdown in trust has spread to our views of the BiB, a position not helped by the occasional plonker in uniform.

Edited by andmole on Tuesday 18th March 10:26

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Tuesday 18th March 2008
quotequote all
Taita said:
vonhosen said:
What's the problem with someone writing the index down rather than the camera getting it ?
But what happens if he's got slightly dodgy eyesight, gets it wrong, you wrongly get points, banned, disqualified, lose job / house. Worst case obviously.
If the accused was to deny that it was their vehicle involved in an alleged 'incident', then the burden of proof would fall to the prosecution to prove that it was.