ICO joins the scamerati
Discussion
ICO Decision Notice FS50098965 said:
The complainant requested figures for the number of speeding tickets issued at camera sites 265 and 266 on Marlow Road in High Wycombe.
The public authority refused to provide this information citing section 31 (Law Enforcement Exemption) as the basis for its refusal.
In correspondence with the Commissioner, the public authority also cited section 38 (Health and Safety Exemption) as an additional basis for its refusal.
The Commissioner found that the public authority did not comply with some of its procedural obligations under the Act. However the Commissioner decided that the information was exempt because disclosure would prejudice law enforcement and would endanger health and safety and that the public interest in maintaining both exemptions outweighed the public interest in disclosing the requested information.
The Information Tribunal has ruled on this decision and has upheld this appeal.
How the disclosure of the number of speeding tickets issued could prejudice law enforcement is something I struggle to understand. The ICO has done the public a serious disservice.The public authority refused to provide this information citing section 31 (Law Enforcement Exemption) as the basis for its refusal.
In correspondence with the Commissioner, the public authority also cited section 38 (Health and Safety Exemption) as an additional basis for its refusal.
The Commissioner found that the public authority did not comply with some of its procedural obligations under the Act. However the Commissioner decided that the information was exempt because disclosure would prejudice law enforcement and would endanger health and safety and that the public interest in maintaining both exemptions outweighed the public interest in disclosing the requested information.
The Information Tribunal has ruled on this decision and has upheld this appeal.
Streaky
PS - note that the Scamera Pratnership also tried on the "elf-n-safety" argument - S
streaky said:
ICO Decision Notice FS50098965 said:
The complainant requested figures for the number of speeding tickets issued at camera sites 265 and 266 on Marlow Road in High Wycombe.
The public authority refused to provide this information citing section 31 (Law Enforcement Exemption) as the basis for its refusal.
In correspondence with the Commissioner, the public authority also cited section 38 (Health and Safety Exemption) as an additional basis for its refusal.
The Commissioner found that the public authority did not comply with some of its procedural obligations under the Act. However the Commissioner decided that the information was exempt because disclosure would prejudice law enforcement and would endanger health and safety and that the public interest in maintaining both exemptions outweighed the public interest in disclosing the requested information.
The Information Tribunal has ruled on this decision and has upheld this appeal.
How the disclosure of the number of speeding tickets issued could prejudice law enforcement is something I struggle to understand. The ICO has done the public a serious disservice.The public authority refused to provide this information citing section 31 (Law Enforcement Exemption) as the basis for its refusal.
In correspondence with the Commissioner, the public authority also cited section 38 (Health and Safety Exemption) as an additional basis for its refusal.
The Commissioner found that the public authority did not comply with some of its procedural obligations under the Act. However the Commissioner decided that the information was exempt because disclosure would prejudice law enforcement and would endanger health and safety and that the public interest in maintaining both exemptions outweighed the public interest in disclosing the requested information.
The Information Tribunal has ruled on this decision and has upheld this appeal.
Streaky
PS - note that the Scamera Pratnership also tried on the "elf-n-safety" argument - S
I fail to understand how it would affect either law enforcement either.
Seems to me they are hiding something, how unusual for this goverment.
The argument is that if you knew how many tickets were issued by camera's you will gain an understanding of which sites are being enforced more heavily then others. This information will be used to avoid detection and therefore the "law" card is played, further by knowing where you can speed with little chance of being caught means you will kill hundreds of children and hence the "public safety" card being played.
I thought in this day and age of "speeding drivers are worse than knife murderers" they would have been only too happy to supply the details unless of course it highlights the fact that the cameras dont meet the criteria for being there in the first place? Strange argument as well saying they failed to comply and then he quotes the same reasons as the authority in reference to why they need not supply? doesn't read very well, hope you understand 

bluepolarbear said:
The argument is that if you knew how many tickets were issued by camera's you will gain an understanding of which sites are being enforced more heavily then others. This information will be used to avoid detection and therefore the "law" card is played, further by knowing where you can speed with little chance of being caught means you will kill hundreds of children and hence the "public safety" card being played.
Surely if there had been lots of tickets issued it would act as a detterent, and show the need for a camera, and if not many were being issued then it would show that the detterent was working.Altough I'm sure you can turn that round and read something else if you wanted too.
Must learn not to ask questions, think, etc. better jsut sit here in the corner,,,,,,,,,,,
whyohwhy said:
Surely if there had been lots of tickets issued it would act as a detterent, and show the need for a camera, and if not many were being issued then it would show that the detterent was working.
My understanding of the logic is that a Scameraship has say 20 sites but only has 5 camera's which are moved around the sites. By knowing the revenue / tickets issued and each given site you will get a good understanding of which sites are used and which are less used and can therefore commit the henous crime of speeding with a degree of impunity.Of course it is all b**locks and what they don't want to show is that the camera on the long straight new dual carriageway with 40mph limit is generating pound notes faster than the Bank of England while the one out in the sticks which is a pain to service and is outside a school doesn't get much action.
Surely, they are not Law Enforcement until the CPS Prosecute? So the issuance of NIPs is NOT by a Law Enforcement agency but by the Scamera who are simply a private tax collection service/ private company...Had you asked for the numbers prosecuted, that could be a very different thing?
Jasandjules said:
Surely, they are not Law Enforcement until the CPS Prosecute? So the issuance of NIPs is NOT by a Law Enforcement agency but by the Scamera who are simply a private tax collection service/ private company...Had you asked for the numbers prosecuted, that could be a very different thing?
I think you will find that the NIP is issued by the Police, hence "Law Enforcement"Jasandjules said:
Surely, they are not Law Enforcement until the CPS Prosecute? So the issuance of NIPs is NOT by a Law Enforcement agency but by the Scamera who are simply a private tax collection service/ private company...Had you asked for the numbers prosecuted, that could be a very different thing?
It's all, ICO included, one big racket.The state is broken, time for a new one.
Mojocvh][dunce mode on] What is the ICO [dunce mode off said:

That's Freedom of Information ... you know, the thing Nu Labia was all in favour of, until they appreciated what it meant.
streaky said:
Mojocvh][dunce mode on] What is the ICO [dunce mode off said:

That's Freedom of Information ... you know, the thing Nu Labia was all in favour of, until they appreciated what it meant.
don't ask me!
MoJo.
Well, maybe someone in the ICO has their head screwed on right:
Mail on Sunday said:
The opening of Heathrow's new Terminal 5 was under threat last night after its management was warned that a plan to fingerprint passengers may be illegal.
The £4.3billion terminal is due to open on Thursday.
But the Information Commissioner has told Spanish-owned airport operator BAA that its plan to fingerprint all passengers may breach the Data Protection Act.
Does the plan infringe our human rights? Tell us your opinion below
The Commissioner's office says passengers ordered to give their prints should do so "under protest" and that such a scheme would normally be considered "intrusive".
It has launched an investigation into whether BAA "took account of the data protection implications of its proposal".
Unless Heathrow provides evidence that the move is necessary, the Commissioner has the power to order it to stop fingerprinting passengers or face legal action.
Last night there were fears that Terminal 5's opening could be delayed, potentially causing flight chaos at Heathrow.
David Smith, the Deputy Information Commissioner, said: "We want to know why Heathrow needs to fingerprint passengers at all.
"Taking photographs is less intrusive. So far we have not heard BAA's case for requesting fingerprints.
"If we find there is a breach of data protection legislation, we would hope to persuade them to put things right.
"If that is not successful we can issue an enforcement notice. If they don't comply, it is then a criminal offence and they can be prosecuted."
The airport claims fingerprinting is necessary so that all passengers - domestic and international - can mix freely in Terminal 5's huge airside shopping mall.
Domestic passengers at Terminal 1 are already being fingerprinted so that they, too, can be routed into its main airside lounges with shops and restaurants, rather than less well-appointed domestic departure areas.
Passengers passing through security place a hand on a scanner which records four fingerprints. They also face a camera and are photographed.
Leaflets issued to domestic passengers at Heathrow say: "To ensure we maintain the highest levels of border security, we are required to introduce additional controls for passengers travelling to UK destinations.
"For this reason, we will capture the photo and fingerprints of passengers. Only passengers who comply with these additional controls will be able to fly to UK destinations."
But critics say the main reason for common departure areas is because BAA wants all passengers to be able to spend money in "duty free" shops.
Its website says: "We're transforming Heathrow to make big improvements for all passengers. Domestic passengers will in future use the same departure lounges as international passengers.
"That means all our passengers will enjoy the same wide choice of shops and restaurants."
The Information Commissioner took action after a complaint from civil liberties group Privacy International.
It said that "compulsory fingerprinting...will substantially violate UK Data Protection law", adding: "To diminish privacy rights in order to achieve greater sales revenue is a disquieting development."
The so-called open terminals have major security risks.
An incoming international passenger could potentially switch tickets with an accomplice booked on a domestic flight.
The international passenger - possibly a terrorist or a criminal - would then be able to fly elsewhere in Britain and enter the country without being checked by the immigration authorities.
However, other airports, including London Gatwick and Manchester, already have open terminals.
Instead of fingerprinting, passengers are photographed as they pass through security and have their identities rechecked at the departure gate.
But BAA says the fingerprinting at Terminal 5 has been installed under orders from the Government.
It says a working group, which included the Home Office's Borders and Immigration Agency, decided it was the "most robust system" to protect Britain's borders.
In a statement, BAA said: "When BAA announced plans for common departure lounges, the BIA was keen on a reliable biometric element to border control.
"Fingerprinting was selected as the most robust method by BAA, the BIA and other government departments.
"The data is encrypted immediately and is destroyed within 24 hours of use, in accordance with the Data Protection Act.
"It does not include personal details nor is it cross-referenced with any other database."
But last night the Home Office denied ordering Heathrow to fingerprint passengers.
A spokesman said: "We required a plan to keep the UK border secure. The design of the scheme is a matter for BAA."
StreakyThe £4.3billion terminal is due to open on Thursday.
But the Information Commissioner has told Spanish-owned airport operator BAA that its plan to fingerprint all passengers may breach the Data Protection Act.
Does the plan infringe our human rights? Tell us your opinion below
The Commissioner's office says passengers ordered to give their prints should do so "under protest" and that such a scheme would normally be considered "intrusive".
It has launched an investigation into whether BAA "took account of the data protection implications of its proposal".
Unless Heathrow provides evidence that the move is necessary, the Commissioner has the power to order it to stop fingerprinting passengers or face legal action.
Last night there were fears that Terminal 5's opening could be delayed, potentially causing flight chaos at Heathrow.
David Smith, the Deputy Information Commissioner, said: "We want to know why Heathrow needs to fingerprint passengers at all.
"Taking photographs is less intrusive. So far we have not heard BAA's case for requesting fingerprints.
"If we find there is a breach of data protection legislation, we would hope to persuade them to put things right.
"If that is not successful we can issue an enforcement notice. If they don't comply, it is then a criminal offence and they can be prosecuted."
The airport claims fingerprinting is necessary so that all passengers - domestic and international - can mix freely in Terminal 5's huge airside shopping mall.
Domestic passengers at Terminal 1 are already being fingerprinted so that they, too, can be routed into its main airside lounges with shops and restaurants, rather than less well-appointed domestic departure areas.
Passengers passing through security place a hand on a scanner which records four fingerprints. They also face a camera and are photographed.
Leaflets issued to domestic passengers at Heathrow say: "To ensure we maintain the highest levels of border security, we are required to introduce additional controls for passengers travelling to UK destinations.
"For this reason, we will capture the photo and fingerprints of passengers. Only passengers who comply with these additional controls will be able to fly to UK destinations."
But critics say the main reason for common departure areas is because BAA wants all passengers to be able to spend money in "duty free" shops.
Its website says: "We're transforming Heathrow to make big improvements for all passengers. Domestic passengers will in future use the same departure lounges as international passengers.
"That means all our passengers will enjoy the same wide choice of shops and restaurants."
The Information Commissioner took action after a complaint from civil liberties group Privacy International.
It said that "compulsory fingerprinting...will substantially violate UK Data Protection law", adding: "To diminish privacy rights in order to achieve greater sales revenue is a disquieting development."
The so-called open terminals have major security risks.
An incoming international passenger could potentially switch tickets with an accomplice booked on a domestic flight.
The international passenger - possibly a terrorist or a criminal - would then be able to fly elsewhere in Britain and enter the country without being checked by the immigration authorities.
However, other airports, including London Gatwick and Manchester, already have open terminals.
Instead of fingerprinting, passengers are photographed as they pass through security and have their identities rechecked at the departure gate.
But BAA says the fingerprinting at Terminal 5 has been installed under orders from the Government.
It says a working group, which included the Home Office's Borders and Immigration Agency, decided it was the "most robust system" to protect Britain's borders.
In a statement, BAA said: "When BAA announced plans for common departure lounges, the BIA was keen on a reliable biometric element to border control.
"Fingerprinting was selected as the most robust method by BAA, the BIA and other government departments.
"The data is encrypted immediately and is destroyed within 24 hours of use, in accordance with the Data Protection Act.
"It does not include personal details nor is it cross-referenced with any other database."
But last night the Home Office denied ordering Heathrow to fingerprint passengers.
A spokesman said: "We required a plan to keep the UK border secure. The design of the scheme is a matter for BAA."
Seems an odd article. You want legal fingerprinting? Make it a condition of entry. Refuse? No access to the airport. Simple.
However, why would they take them and not cross-check them with any other system? Surely if such a system existed it'd be wise to put it through the Police National Computer at least. Unless they check them on the way in and out (somehow) to make sure the prints match up with the identity.
I had this done in the US recently and not once did men follow me! They didn't even interrogate me. I was amazed as I assumed the scare-mongering coverage it got was actually justified.
However, why would they take them and not cross-check them with any other system? Surely if such a system existed it'd be wise to put it through the Police National Computer at least. Unless they check them on the way in and out (somehow) to make sure the prints match up with the identity.
I had this done in the US recently and not once did men follow me! They didn't even interrogate me. I was amazed as I assumed the scare-mongering coverage it got was actually justified.
FishFace said:
Seems an odd article. You want legal fingerprinting? Make it a condition of entry. Refuse? No access to the airport. Simple.
However, why would they take them and not cross-check them with any other system? Surely if such a system existed it'd be wise to put it through the Police National Computer at least. Unless they check them on the way in and out (somehow) to make sure the prints match up with the identity.
I had this done in the US recently and not once did men follow me! They didn't even interrogate me. I was amazed as I assumed the scare-mongering coverage it got was actually justified.
You wouldn't spot the pros! However, why would they take them and not cross-check them with any other system? Surely if such a system existed it'd be wise to put it through the Police National Computer at least. Unless they check them on the way in and out (somehow) to make sure the prints match up with the identity.
I had this done in the US recently and not once did men follow me! They didn't even interrogate me. I was amazed as I assumed the scare-mongering coverage it got was actually justified.

BTW, if you want men to follow you, then wearing hot pants and a skin-tight, open shirt might assist *.
Streaky
* regardless of sex. And for men so dressed, that's according to legend, not personal experience, I hasten to add.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




