Car insurance claim- whats the next step?
Discussion
Will keep it brief, i was involved in a car accident last december when a guy ran into the back of me. He admitted liability at the scene, we exchanged details and as i was experiencing some discomfort in my back i attended hospital. I put in my claim as normal and my car was taken away for repair and i had a courtesy car whilst it was for which i had to pay the excess of £700.
Now some 3 months later i have had contact from my own insurance co. to say that the third party is denying any collision took place at all. As there were no witnesses they are saying that it is a difficult situation. All they have is the hospital reports to say i attended, they are waiting on photos and reports from the repairers and the hand written details the guy gave me at the scene. I have already asked the insurance co. to ask why he would give details at the scene if no accident occurred. I am in a bit of a pickle now especially as i had to fork out £700 to get my car back and am worried they wont resolve this and i will end up with a big legal bill. I am tempted to go round and see the guy but dont want to be accused of harrasment. Anyone know what the usual outcome is to situations like this or what i should possibly do next???
Now some 3 months later i have had contact from my own insurance co. to say that the third party is denying any collision took place at all. As there were no witnesses they are saying that it is a difficult situation. All they have is the hospital reports to say i attended, they are waiting on photos and reports from the repairers and the hand written details the guy gave me at the scene. I have already asked the insurance co. to ask why he would give details at the scene if no accident occurred. I am in a bit of a pickle now especially as i had to fork out £700 to get my car back and am worried they wont resolve this and i will end up with a big legal bill. I am tempted to go round and see the guy but dont want to be accused of harrasment. Anyone know what the usual outcome is to situations like this or what i should possibly do next???
i tried to report it to the police at the time but they said as there were no significant injuries it wasnt a police matter. Will they still be interested now if i go to see them and explain. I dont believe he gave me false details but is just denying a collision took place which is why i asked my insurance the question 'why did he give me details at the scene if an accident didnt take place' you just wouldnt exchange details for the hell of it would you unless you were that way inclined so to speak ??
Definitely don't go to see him. If he is the kind of lying a
hole who would deny a collision ever happened then if you turned up, even being as pleasant as its possible to be, he would spin it so that you came and harrassed/threatened him and that would harm your case even more.
What an absolute scummer. Can things like this go to court? He is clearly a coward and maybe feels able to lie to an insurance company but under oath is a whole new league.
hole who would deny a collision ever happened then if you turned up, even being as pleasant as its possible to be, he would spin it so that you came and harrassed/threatened him and that would harm your case even more.What an absolute scummer. Can things like this go to court? He is clearly a coward and maybe feels able to lie to an insurance company but under oath is a whole new league.
As others have said, don't go to see him. This is a matter for your insurance company to sort out.
What he is banking on is that there is a lot of 'cash for crash' cases going on, and is hoping that they will believe him and not you. What also happens as well with cases which insurers think may be fraudulent is they might hold up things. They think rightly that if someone is trying it on, when it looks like they are found out they wont risk being caught and not pursue the claim.
The thing to do is reconfirm the situation with the insurance company, and tell them that he is blatantly lying. Also offer to pass on a photocopy of the details he gave at the scene. The endgame of him denying all this is that you all end up in court and he will have to deny he has ever met you and of his writing is a forgery. Of course it is obvious who they are going to believe.
In a nutshell, keep up the pressure on your insurance company, letting them know you will be happy to help them should they wish to take the matter to the police with regard to fraud.
What he is banking on is that there is a lot of 'cash for crash' cases going on, and is hoping that they will believe him and not you. What also happens as well with cases which insurers think may be fraudulent is they might hold up things. They think rightly that if someone is trying it on, when it looks like they are found out they wont risk being caught and not pursue the claim.
The thing to do is reconfirm the situation with the insurance company, and tell them that he is blatantly lying. Also offer to pass on a photocopy of the details he gave at the scene. The endgame of him denying all this is that you all end up in court and he will have to deny he has ever met you and of his writing is a forgery. Of course it is obvious who they are going to believe.
In a nutshell, keep up the pressure on your insurance company, letting them know you will be happy to help them should they wish to take the matter to the police with regard to fraud.
Assuming you had the TPs registration number, then this would have come up on the MID check. Your insurers also would have done a DVLA registered keeper check. So between these two sets of details, if the address you had was incorrect they would have found out.
One assumes he was insured ? If so, forget whatever he says. Continue the process. It sounds like there are insurers involved on the TP side, as 3 months is the limit for stating a position on liabilty under the Civil Procedure Rules.
Only about 5% of disputed liabilty cases go to court, so it is unlikely, but as above, keep on at your insurers, if they TP insurers won't deal then they shoud litigate. The alternative is to appoint your own solicitors.
One assumes he was insured ? If so, forget whatever he says. Continue the process. It sounds like there are insurers involved on the TP side, as 3 months is the limit for stating a position on liabilty under the Civil Procedure Rules.
Only about 5% of disputed liabilty cases go to court, so it is unlikely, but as above, keep on at your insurers, if they TP insurers won't deal then they shoud litigate. The alternative is to appoint your own solicitors.
dearboy said:
I put in my claim as normal and my car was taken away for repair and i had a courtesy car whilst it was for which i had to pay the excess of £700.
Did you take out the legal protection when you took out your insurance?If you did then I've always found that getting them to make the first moves in recovering your excess helps move things along......
Appologies for the thread hijack....
I am in a very similar situation. Was involved in an accident 14 months ago, no joke. (hit from behind after traffic lights with injuries to both myself and brother). The guy hit both myself and the person next to me. He has admitted liability for hitting the other car but not myself. He is now denying that he even hit my car at all. What's worse is that i had a call from my insurance company 2 days ago saying that all costs have come from my insurance as they could not prove that he did it, even though he admitted in his initial statement that there was damage to his car in the area in which he made contact. There was no paint transfer as both cars were the same colour.
My insurance company have obviously overlooked this admission and have taken the cost from my policy. I need to try to figure out the best way in which to sort this mess out because after 14 months of being down a £400 excess i really need to get it back. What makes it worse is that another claim from 4 months before that one is still on-going. They are actually useless what should i do?
I am in a very similar situation. Was involved in an accident 14 months ago, no joke. (hit from behind after traffic lights with injuries to both myself and brother). The guy hit both myself and the person next to me. He has admitted liability for hitting the other car but not myself. He is now denying that he even hit my car at all. What's worse is that i had a call from my insurance company 2 days ago saying that all costs have come from my insurance as they could not prove that he did it, even though he admitted in his initial statement that there was damage to his car in the area in which he made contact. There was no paint transfer as both cars were the same colour.
My insurance company have obviously overlooked this admission and have taken the cost from my policy. I need to try to figure out the best way in which to sort this mess out because after 14 months of being down a £400 excess i really need to get it back. What makes it worse is that another claim from 4 months before that one is still on-going. They are actually useless what should i do?
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


