Motorway Breakdown
Author
Discussion

MCFCForever

Original Poster:

1,343 posts

224 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
I have heard that if you break down on the motorway around Manchester and if the police turn up before your recovery service they insist on ring their own appointed recovery firm. Who then charge a fortune to recover your car.

Has anybody else heard this?

Matt.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Generally they'll give you 30 minutes to get it moved, if you don't they will arrange the removal.
Not a fortune to remove, but you will have removal fee & daily storage charges to pay.

Edited by vonhosen on Monday 24th March 18:08

MCFCForever

Original Poster:

1,343 posts

224 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Ahh okay.

Isn't 30 minutes a bit unrealistic? Ive never known the RAC or AA to turn up within 30 minutes, normally around 45-60 minutes for me?

Matt.

Soren2

251 posts

226 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
It's the same for any force. Our rules (M6 Cumbria) are for 30 minutes recovery time. Breakdown/recovery services are aware of this, and are aware that they need to respond sharpish. If a vehicle has broken down and one of the recognised recovery services have been called, we're usually quite comfortable with that. If Jack the Lad's Nova has melted on the hard shoulder and his uncle Frank is coming from Accrington to help him out, we'll keep a closer watch. If he can't or doesn't get there within a reasonable time, we'll have it recovered.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
I once cooked the engine on a car on the M1. Trafpol were somewhat.........officious about the whole thing. Well, one of them was. Had this bizarre way of looking off in a different direction while talking to me. A bit like that ginger fellah in CSI. His mate kept smirking as I followed his gaze and asked what we were supposed to be looking at.

His threat of having my car towed before the RAC arrived didn't really phase me as the engine damage was clearly terminal (on a £150 XR2). Don't think he liked me saying so either rolleyes

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
MCFCForever said:
Ahh okay.

Isn't 30 minutes a bit unrealistic? Ive never known the RAC or AA to turn up within 30 minutes, normally around 45-60 minutes for me?

Matt.
I'd guess if you told the police you'd called the AA RAC, they'd give you the benifit of the doubt.

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

Umm....can someone (BIB) quote the regulation that says they have the right to do this....

If I was 400 miles from home in my Porsche and had the RAC on the way, there is NO way I would let a local recovery driver touch my car....

Are they going to arrest me ??? For what ??? They would have to and I think they would look a little silly in court...

All the best Brett smile

Davevx220

432 posts

275 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
In Hampshire the Highways Agency will allow approx 2 hours... possibly longer for HGV's etc depending on the circumstances.

Dangerous location / unlit / untaxed / unroadworthy / RTC etc..........straight away.

All above will be authorised by the police before removal. (soon to change)


9 Removal of certain vehicles by traffic officers (1) The power to make regulations under section 99 of the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 (c. 27) includes, in relation to the removal of vehicles by traffic officers, power to make consequential provision.
(2) The provision which may be made by virtue of subsection (1) includes in particular provision—
(a) amending, or
(b) applying in relation to vehicles removed by traffic officers (with or without modifications),
any provision of sections 100 to 102 of that Act (disposal of vehicles removed under section 99).


Traffic Managment Act 2004





Edited by Davevx220 on Monday 24th March 19:22

uk_vette

3,336 posts

235 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Generally they'll give you 30 minutes to get it moved, if you don't they will arrange the removal.
Not a fortune to remove, but you will have removal fee & daily storage charges to pay.

Edited by vonhosen on Monday 24th March 18:08
.
.
.
Not a fortune to remove it,

Who are you trying to kid !

Shame on you.

You and I both know how damn expensive it is,

bluepolarbear

1,666 posts

277 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Davevx220 said:
Traffic Managment Act 2004
I don't doubt they have the authority to remove the vehicle but I am more suspect of their legal right to charge their costs. The contract is between the police and vehicle recovery agent not with you as a driver.

All a bit academic on the grounds that possesion if nine tenths and all that.

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
Used to be 4 hours if the vehicle was lit and attended. If there were any issues, then it was immediate removal.

I understand this has been re-assessed to 2 hours in some forces.

If your Porsche is in the way or causing risk to others, regardless whether you have called the RAC, the AA or the Minister for funny walks, it will be removed whether you like it or not and by the nearest and quickest available recovery agent who is on the police list to do so! If you protest about this in the wrong manner, you may well be removed as well at the same time your vehicle is removed and not to the same place the vehicle is going wink

Northants155boy

1,198 posts

286 months

Monday 24th March 2008
quotequote all
I broke down in the outside lane of the M25 in a traffic jam, I called the RAC who I was with at the time to come and recover me. I also called the local plod who responded as the Jam was begining to clear and I was causing a seperate jam, problems were the car was stuck in Park and I had no electrics and couldn't get the gear box into Neutral (gearbox had a lockout on it, which I didn't know how to remove) so couldn't be moved to the hard shoulder, the police were pretty good to be fair and called a local recovery firm to come and collect me, they said whoever turned first would recovery me. Of course the local firm called by the police arrived first and recovered me to their local garage, as an aside it was a blown fuse which when replaced had me on my way. I had to pay the recovery firm for the callout and recovery which was £120, and I was refuned all this by the RAC as they had failed to recover me which was part of my policy at the time, so no problems.

Gafferjim

1,337 posts

296 months

Tuesday 25th March 2008
quotequote all
Recovery time was one of the problems with the various Police forces differing in their opinions. Since the HATO's took responsiblity for common-o-garden broken down vehicles, it's now 2 hours, unless there is some sort of other issue with the vehicle.
I'm not going to go into what is, and what isn't an issue.
At the moment the police forces have the various contracts with the recovery companies and we go through them to have a vehicle recovered, around September of this year, the Highways Agency will take over those contracts, and be fully responsible for recovery of "common-o-garden" broken down vehicles, although the Police will still have recovery firms that will remove vehicles that have any sort of police interest

bluepolarbear

1,666 posts

277 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
but under what legisation can they charge for recovery?

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
bluepolarbear said:
but under what legisation can they charge for recovery?
My Guess is the same piece of legislation which they charge you to board up your house if the window is smashed, i.e. NONE.. They will simply issue a bill and most people will pay. There's certainly an argument that you could be obliged by a court to pay "reasonable costs of recovery" however if you had AA/RAC Cover.......

Chrispy Porker

17,761 posts

259 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
Used to be 4 hours if the vehicle was lit and attended. If there were any issues, then it was immediate removal.

I understand this has been re-assessed to 2 hours in some forces.

If your Porsche is in the way or causing risk to others, regardless whether you have called the RAC, the AA or the Minister for funny walks, it will be removed whether you like it or not and by the nearest and quickest available recovery agent who is on the police list to do so! If you protest about this in the wrong manner, you may well be removed as well at the same time your vehicle is removed and not to the same place the vehicle is going wink
Bear in mind, he knows numerous unpleasant killing techniques..

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Mg6b said:
Used to be 4 hours if the vehicle was lit and attended. If there were any issues, then it was immediate removal.

I understand this has been re-assessed to 2 hours in some forces.

If your Porsche is in the way or causing risk to others, regardless whether you have called the RAC, the AA or the Minister for funny walks, it will be removed whether you like it or not and by the nearest and quickest available recovery agent who is on the police list to do so! If you protest about this in the wrong manner, you may well be removed as well at the same time your vehicle is removed and not to the same place the vehicle is going wink
Bear in mind, he knows numerous unpleasant killing techniques..
Hi Lol smile

I am hardly going to kill a BIB smile

But they might find it extremely difficult to "REMOVE" me smile

All the best Brett smile

Edited by Brett928S2 on Wednesday 26th March 18:10

Gafferjim

1,337 posts

296 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
bluepolarbear said:
but under what legisation can they charge for recovery?
I've found this on the net....................


1.2. The power to recover vehicles is set out in the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 and the Removal and Disposal of Vehicles Regulations 1986. This legislation places the cost of recovery on the owner and not the police. This was confirmed by the appeal court decision in the case of Clarke v West Midlands Police 1998.

I think that any vehicle stopped on the H/S of a motorway constitutes as an "obstruction" (as you're not allowed to park or stop etc. etc)
The police wanted 30 mins then it's removed, the recovery services said that they couldn't attend in such short a time, and the final outcome was 2 hours, but certain police forces went their own way on it, with varying times applying depending on where you were unfortunate to breakdown.
As I've said, it's now 2 hours throughout the country. (apart from those skirt wearers, and the daffodile crunchers, and I've no idea what they decided! ;-))

the site I found that bit from was here;............
http://www.west-midlands.police.uk/publications/fr...

and from the 1984 act;...............

(a) has been permitted to remain at rest or has broken down and remained at rest on a road in contravention of a prohibition or restriction contained in an order under section 46 of the 1984 Act in circumstances in which an offence would have been committed in respect of the vehicle but for paragraph 1(4)(b) of Schedule 3 to the Road Traffic Act 1991 (permitted parking areas);

as there are no permitted parking area's etc on a motorway, perhaps this could be the bit that it falls under.
I stand corrected if i'm wrong, and bow down to the legal eagles amongst us.


Edited by Gafferjim on Wednesday 26th March 23:33

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
The relevant section on cost recovery is Sec 102 Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 (I believe).

The power to require removal by the owner is Reg 3 The Removal and Disposal of Vehicles Regulations 1986 & the power to then remove if they don't is Reg 4.

Edited by vonhosen on Thursday 27th March 00:11

deeps

5,432 posts

272 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Chrispy Porker said:
Mg6b said:
Used to be 4 hours if the vehicle was lit and attended. If there were any issues, then it was immediate removal.

I understand this has been re-assessed to 2 hours in some forces.

If your Porsche is in the way or causing risk to others, regardless whether you have called the RAC, the AA or the Minister for funny walks, it will be removed whether you like it or not and by the nearest and quickest available recovery agent who is on the police list to do so! If you protest about this in the wrong manner, you may well be removed as well at the same time your vehicle is removed and not to the same place the vehicle is going wink
Bear in mind, he knows numerous unpleasant killing techniques..
Hi Lol smile

I am hardly going to kill a BIB smile

But they might find it extremely difficult to "REMOVE" me smile

All the best Brett smile
Brett, Chrispy Porker was referring to Mg6b... be scared, be very scared, LOL smile Mg6b AKA ex trafpol007.