What happens when the identified driver denies it?
What happens when the identified driver denies it?
Author
Discussion

garycat

Original Poster:

5,438 posts

241 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all

Lets say driver A gets an S172 to identify the driver for a speeding offence and they fill it in properly, signed etc and identify the driver as driver B.

Driver B denies that they were the driver at the time and says it was driver A. Neither has an alibi or any proof that they were not the driver.

How would the courts deal with this situation?

MCFCForever

1,343 posts

224 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
I think it would fall back on the person who is the registered owner of the car, so Driver A.

Matt

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
As I understand it the police would interview both drivers - but if both can hold there nerve and there are no incriminating photo's they should get off with itsmokin.

jezzaaa

1,951 posts

290 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
bad company said:
As I understand it the police would interview both drivers - but if both can hold there nerve and there are no incriminating photo's they should get off with itsmokin.
That can happen, but I think you can also both receive a summons under s172 to attend a Mags court...and then you have to convince the beaks that you applied all due diligence to discover who the driver was but failed.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
jezzaaa said:
bad company said:
As I understand it the police would interview both drivers - but if both can hold there nerve and there are no incriminating photo's they should get off with itsmokin.
That can happen, but I think you can also both receive a summons under s172 to attend a Mags court...and then you have to convince the beaks that you applied all due diligence to discover who the driver was but failed.
Why would both get a summons?

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Not 'would' but 'could'

A names B

B names?

172:

(2) Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—

(a)the person keeping the vehicle(A) shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and

(b)any other person (B) shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.

dvd

garycat

Original Poster:

5,438 posts

241 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
Not 'would' but 'could'

A names B

B names?
I'm talking about the case of A names B and B names A. One is obviously lying but there is no evidence as to which one.

Driver A has done their due diligence in naming B.

Edited by garycat on Wednesday 26th March 15:13

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
garycat said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
Not 'would' but 'could'

A names B

B names?
I'm talking about the case of A names B and B names A. One is obviously lying but there is no evidence as to which one.

Driver A has done their due diligence in naming B.

Edited by garycat on Wednesday 26th March 15:13
In that case, you might have fulfilled S172 as importantly B has also fulfilled his requirement under S172 - even if he does name A!

Only problem is now is there is now evidence that A was the driver at the time and they would probably proceed with the speeding charge.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Only problem is now is there is now evidence that A was the driver at the time and they would probably proceed with the speeding charge.
What evidence ? One person's nomination of another is insufficient to prove the identity of the driver..wink

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
garycat said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
Not 'would' but 'could'

A names B

B names?
I'm talking about the case of A names B and B names A. One is obviously lying but there is no evidence as to which one.

Driver A has done their due diligence in naming B.

Edited by garycat on Wednesday 26th March 15:13
In that case, you might have fulfilled S172 as importantly B has also fulfilled his requirement under S172 - even if he does name A!

Only problem is now is there is now evidence that A was the driver at the time and they would probably proceed with the speeding charge.
Does B have any requirement under S172? Isn't that just aimed at the RK which I assumed A would be as he got the first notice?

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
This must have happened a dozen or more times and what the solution is ???????????

Other than matter being farmed out to Plod for enquiry and possibkly resolved.

172 Reg Keeper (A) names B
172 B then names A.

Has A fullfilled his obligation as B denies?

CPS take action against A (Reg Keeper) for failing to name and witness summons on B to give his denial that he was not driver as A was.

What's the bench going to do?

SS?

dvd



Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Presumebly it gets to court and the Mags convict some RK's for the s172 offence and let others off, the result probably depending on whether or not it's a sunny day.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
Is there a pic of the driver?

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
JustinP1 said:
Only problem is now is there is now evidence that A was the driver at the time and they would probably proceed with the speeding charge.
What evidence ? One person's nomination of another is insufficient to prove the identity of the driver..wink
Of course, but at least the court can ask him whether he was speeding or not...

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
JustinP1 said:
garycat said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
Not 'would' but 'could'

A names B

B names?
I'm talking about the case of A names B and B names A. One is obviously lying but there is no evidence as to which one.

Driver A has done their due diligence in naming B.

Edited by garycat on Wednesday 26th March 15:13
In that case, you might have fulfilled S172 as importantly B has also fulfilled his requirement under S172 - even if he does name A!

Only problem is now is there is now evidence that A was the driver at the time and they would probably proceed with the speeding charge.
Does B have any requirement under S172? Isn't that just aimed at the RK which I assumed A would be as he got the first notice?
Yes, if asked. If he doesn't comply with s172 then according to what Dwight has reproduced this means A is not free until B complies.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
If we assume that one of A or B was in fact driving, then one would be telling the truth and the other would be supplying false statements..

If they persisted with their claims that the other was driving, then my best guess would be that the police would investigate further with a view to A or B (or both) being charged with more serious offences.




SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
SS2. said:
JustinP1 said:
Only problem is now is there is now evidence that A was the driver at the time and they would probably proceed with the speeding charge.
What evidence ? One person's nomination of another is insufficient to prove the identity of the driver..wink
Of course, but at least the court can ask him whether he was speeding or not...
Even if they could force A into the witness box to be questioned under oath (which they can't), surely the more relevant question would be 'can you confirm that you were the driver at the time of the alleged offence'..

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
If we assume that one of A or B was in fact driving, then one would be telling the truth and the other would be supplying false statements..

If they persisted with their claims that the other was driving, then my best guess would be that the police would investigate further with a view to A or B (or both) being charged with more serious offences.
Difficult to see why. One persons word against another. The police surely have better things to do.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
SS2. said:
If we assume that one of A or B was in fact driving, then one would be telling the truth and the other would be supplying false statements..

If they persisted with their claims that the other was driving, then my best guess would be that the police would investigate further with a view to A or B (or both) being charged with more serious offences.
Difficult to see why. One persons word against another. The police surely have better things to do.
I don't think that the police would regard a perceived attempt to pervert the course of public justice as a trivial matter..



bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
s2art said:
SS2. said:
If we assume that one of A or B was in fact driving, then one would be telling the truth and the other would be supplying false statements..

If they persisted with their claims that the other was driving, then my best guess would be that the police would investigate further with a view to A or B (or both) being charged with more serious offences.
Difficult to see why. One persons word against another. The police surely have better things to do.
I don't think that the police would regard a perceived attempt to pervert the course of public justice as a trivial matter..
As I said previously if both parties hold their nerve the police would have nowhere to go with this.