Changing from a Golf MK2 8v GTI to a MK3 16v
Discussion
Okay, I must be getting old. I'm starting to realise my own mortality. A friend of a friend recently had a smash in his Mk2 golf leaving him quite badly hurt, the other driver (in a Leon) had a few cuts and bruises. Which got me thinking maybe it's time to get something a bit more modern.
Question is would I be dissappointed with a 16v MK3 Golf GTI having been driving about in a MK2 8v?
If I had to sum up the MK2 I'd say it's a light car that's got enough power to put a grin on my face but not enough so I'd kill myself, combined with a communicative chassis which encourages you to drive with your fingertips. Could I expect this sort of a drive from a newer Golf?
Also thinking 'bout MK4 Turbos and Seat Leon Cupras (non R)
Question is would I be dissappointed with a 16v MK3 Golf GTI having been driving about in a MK2 8v?
If I had to sum up the MK2 I'd say it's a light car that's got enough power to put a grin on my face but not enough so I'd kill myself, combined with a communicative chassis which encourages you to drive with your fingertips. Could I expect this sort of a drive from a newer Golf?
Also thinking 'bout MK4 Turbos and Seat Leon Cupras (non R)
Driven a MK3 8v which was very soft compared to my MKII but I liked it. Its just a step up in comfort, better for the motorway, quieter and more refined. I would have thought the 16v solved the slowness issue of the 8v. I thinks its got 150bhp? Going MKV Turbo route will be another step up the refinement scale and another step up the weighing scales! It does have good tuning potential though. Go drive them all and see what you think.
I owned a mk2 8v for years and, like you, thought it time to get something newer. Looked at mk3 16v and vr6 and to be honest I was disappointed. Nice enough I suppose but quite dull and flat footed. Basically, had none of the enthusiasm of a mk2 and no fun to chuck around.
I think you're on the right track with a Leon Cupra. Supposed to be good cars and cracking value IMO.
I think you're on the right track with a Leon Cupra. Supposed to be good cars and cracking value IMO.
Ive had both and found the 16v mk3 was not as good in standard trim as the mk2 8v in terms of fun and driveability. But when i fitted some eibach dampers and springs it made the 16v mk3 a lot better and much less prone to pitch and roll. Generally much more pleasing to drive and it still had a/c and recaro's! You do need to keep the mk3 on the boil if you want to push on but if your not affraid of 6500 rpm then its good fun
The reason why i felt my 8v was so nice to drive was that there was a capable chassis with just enought power to be happy with. Since the mk3 shape, Golfs have become a lot heavier. It might be worth looking at Polo GTI's if you're looking for the same sort of fun. The ones from around the year 2000 onwards have a similar power-weight as the mk1 Golf GTI. But the shape after uses the 1.8T - certainly worth a look.
clarkee200 said:
I...if your not affraid of 6500 rpm then its good fun

I don't think I've ever taken my little 8v above 5500rpm, rarely need to take it over 4800 for regular "pressing on" driving.
so, MK3 16v with some suspension mods or a polo with a 1.8t? Am I right in thinking that a chip can see a 1.8t on the right side of 225bhp? That'd be a bit nuts in a polo. 'speshly if you stripped off all the bling and did it up in granny spec.
Mk 2 to Mk 3? You'll hate it mate, they're not the same cars at all, don't bother. The only VW alternative you should consider to your Mk2 is a Corrado. Otherwise, there's nowt between your Mk2 and the current Gti that should interest you in the VW stable.
I wouldn't worry about having a car smash. Look at the stats - if you bear in mind that possibly 50 million people walk out through their front doors every day, the stats clearly show that driving is a very safe activity. If you're a regular person who drives in a regular way, motoring becomes a very safe activity indeed. You're far more likely to die of cancer or a hospital acquired infection, so if you're starting to consider your own mortality, you have other issues such as diet and lifestyle before you need to address your motoring. Imo.
I wouldn't worry about having a car smash. Look at the stats - if you bear in mind that possibly 50 million people walk out through their front doors every day, the stats clearly show that driving is a very safe activity. If you're a regular person who drives in a regular way, motoring becomes a very safe activity indeed. You're far more likely to die of cancer or a hospital acquired infection, so if you're starting to consider your own mortality, you have other issues such as diet and lifestyle before you need to address your motoring. Imo.

I have always wanted a Corrado, but being a gigging drummer I'm not sure if I'd get a whole drumkit in the boot. I may be proved wrong though.
I know the VR is the one to go for, but with today's fuel prices I don't fancy running about in a 2.9 with a drinking problem. What are the other engine choices like. I know that the 1.8 16v is to be avoided, but what are the 2.0's and the G60 like for performance?
I know the VR is the one to go for, but with today's fuel prices I don't fancy running about in a 2.9 with a drinking problem. What are the other engine choices like. I know that the 1.8 16v is to be avoided, but what are the 2.0's and the G60 like for performance?
2.0l valver has a good engine, and IMO better than the 1.8 valver despite (in theory) not being as powerful. The early valver does have its own thrasy charm though. The performance was not the same as a VR and it runs out at an indicated 135mph (well that's where I stopped anyway as I felt the limiter approaching). It's fast enough day to day though! The economy in the 2.0l was about 35mpg, which is surprisingly similar to a VR6 (in normal drvinging at least).
In terms of safety....well having been in one that rolled at about 50mph and walking away with 2 bruises, I can say that they're pretty solid.
The G60 is a corker of an engine by all accounts, reliability depends on the state of tune! Check out http://the-corrado.net/forum/ as there's a good owner's guide on there. Use the search to check for reliability issues etc. Personally, I've found the Mk2 to be more reliable and the bits are cheaper to come by. The handling's another matter though...
Cheers,
Thomas
In terms of safety....well having been in one that rolled at about 50mph and walking away with 2 bruises, I can say that they're pretty solid.
The G60 is a corker of an engine by all accounts, reliability depends on the state of tune! Check out http://the-corrado.net/forum/ as there's a good owner's guide on there. Use the search to check for reliability issues etc. Personally, I've found the Mk2 to be more reliable and the bits are cheaper to come by. The handling's another matter though...
Cheers,
Thomas
darkyoung1000 said:
The economy in the 2.0l was about 35mpg, which is surprisingly similar to a VR6 (in normal drvinging at least).
35mpg out of a VR6?! No hope. I ran one for almost a year and averaged around 22/23mpg. Maybe 27 on a gentle run but not achievable in day to day driving.In fact, one of my main reasons for selling was that the performance was nowhere near good enough to warrant the sh!t fuel ecomony. Well, that and the nasty timing chain rattle at 65,000 miles!
Hi Mark,
I did exactly what you're considering and went from an 8v Mk2 Gti to a Mk3 16v. The Mk3 initially felt quicker on the test drive but in day to day driving it was very disappointing. I thought that the 2.0 16v would make up for the increased weight but it didn't and the suspension as previously mentioned was poor. Got some uprated dampers which helped but it still felt like a big car. You really did have to keep it in the top end of the rev range to get it to go properly and even then the engine didn't rev like the Mk2 16v ( something to do with a different cam profile I believe ? ).
Anyhow, just my opinion but I'd make sure you take a Mk3 for a long test drive first on all types of roads so you know how it'll feel. Good luck
Cheers
Al
Oh, had a Corrado VR6 not long afterwards and it was very very impressive and felt a lot more agile even with more weight. Would have probably kept it if it didn't use so much oil ( petrol was ok surprisingly with 30mpg on average ) which is sadly a common problem with them
I did exactly what you're considering and went from an 8v Mk2 Gti to a Mk3 16v. The Mk3 initially felt quicker on the test drive but in day to day driving it was very disappointing. I thought that the 2.0 16v would make up for the increased weight but it didn't and the suspension as previously mentioned was poor. Got some uprated dampers which helped but it still felt like a big car. You really did have to keep it in the top end of the rev range to get it to go properly and even then the engine didn't rev like the Mk2 16v ( something to do with a different cam profile I believe ? ).
Anyhow, just my opinion but I'd make sure you take a Mk3 for a long test drive first on all types of roads so you know how it'll feel. Good luck
Cheers
Al
Oh, had a Corrado VR6 not long afterwards and it was very very impressive and felt a lot more agile even with more weight. Would have probably kept it if it didn't use so much oil ( petrol was ok surprisingly with 30mpg on average ) which is sadly a common problem with them
I got 29mpg once out of a VR6 driving it as fast as i could on a busy m'way, ie sitting in L3 and flooring it every time i got a gap. On the way back (from Goodwood) we beat a pair of mates on Fireblades back home, (they had to go the long way as they couldn't ride and navigate at the same time) can't recall the mpg but it wasn't anything too bad, not below 25 mpg i don't think. The car wasn't very old at that time.
Still would never have bought one though.
Still would never have bought one though.
Hargo said:
Hi Mark, You really did have to keep it in the top end of the rev range to get it to go properly and even then the engine didn't rev like the Mk2 16v ( something to do with a different cam profile I believe ? ).
Different engine altogether. The 1.8 16v in the Mk2 Golf is known as the KR, the 2.0 16v in the Mk3 is an ABF.The 2.0 16v in the Corrado is similar to the 1.8 KR but has a slighty less agressive cam profile resulting in less power.
The ABF is pretty responsive to simple tuning, an air filter and proper set up by somewhere like Stealth can see them make around 170bhp.
ive had 2 8v gti`s and then i moved onto a vr6 it felt all to smooth and refined at first,but i soon got used to it,put a k&n and exhaust on it and you WILL become addicted to the sound of it,ive gone back to a 8v for the time being(£400-run-about
so to be fair i like both cars i used to get 20-24mpg knocking about and 28-30mpg on a run in my vr,some people say vr6`s lack performance,they must have s
tters!
so to be fair i like both cars i used to get 20-24mpg knocking about and 28-30mpg on a run in my vr,some people say vr6`s lack performance,they must have s
tters!MK3 16V is a vastly underatted car, don't believe all the s
t written about them in VW mags. The 8v MK3 is cack but the 16v is a corker.
I went from a succession of MK2's (2x 8v and 2x 16v) to a MK3 16v and was mightily impressed, the MK3 was quicker, comfier, stronger and more reliable, also with ABS it was safer.
t written about them in VW mags. The 8v MK3 is cack but the 16v is a corker.I went from a succession of MK2's (2x 8v and 2x 16v) to a MK3 16v and was mightily impressed, the MK3 was quicker, comfier, stronger and more reliable, also with ABS it was safer.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



