Inconsistent treatment of motoring offences
Inconsistent treatment of motoring offences
Author
Discussion

Markbishop

Original Poster:

173 posts

276 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Caught the tail end of 'Motorway Cops' on BBC1 last night, the bit where they summarise what happened to the people featured in the show. Compare and contrast the penalties...

Man parks on hard shoulder and goes for a pee. BiB investigate; find he has no licence and is an illegal immigrant. Result: £75 fine, three points on his non-existent licence (so no points really).

Polish lorry driver travels on wrong side of the road, thinking two-way street is dual carriageway. Car swerves to avoid, collides with bike. Motorist seriously injured, biker carted off in air ambulance with possible spinal damage. Result: charged with careless driving but scarpers back to Poland so no penalty.

British doctor in recent Merc pulled for speeding (I did't see the main part of the show so don't know how fast): £600 fine, six points.

Rank these three incidents in order of the risk they represented to other road users. Then do the same by severity of penalties.

Methinks there's something wrong with the system...

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
You make a good point.

Another one is how boring that show was.

cluelessboy

66 posts

228 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
I think the first one took the piss.

bimsb6

8,808 posts

252 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
speeder was doing 101 mph and a doctor ,lied through his teeth as to why he was speeding ,said he was on an emergency call ,he had his mrs and sprog in car with him ! the child was standing on the back seat unrestrained .the fines points for the others were a joke .

Smart roadster

769 posts

257 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
The fellows peeing on the hard shoulder were illegals so off to be deported, the Polish lorry driver didn't scraper but hasn't been back since and the doc was doing over a ton with his unrestrained child in the back. Claimed he was off to an emergency with his wife and kid in the car. Only just over a ton I'll grant you but I think his attitude and the unrestrained kid swung it against him.

way to slow there I see

Edited by Smart roadster on Thursday 27th March 13:18

Kevin 996C4

13,891 posts

311 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
What about the French uninsured idiot? Can you deport within the EU???

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Being a sad git i have it recorded

Now lets go over the end titles

Driver of stolen car he wins community service (which he won't turn up to)

Drunk of driver who ran off after crashing his car on the motorway He wins Not prosecuted because of lack of evidence

Chinese driver with no license He wins 3 points on a license he doesn't have and £75 fine

Disqualified french driver with no insurance He gets 7 points and £200 fine

Polish lorry driver who almost kills a motorcyclist was charged (not prosecuted) with driving without due care and attention


However

Speeding doctor doing 101mph in his own fully taxed and insuranced car Is tonight's winner with 6 points and £600 fine




I love British justice system how can anyone even try and justify the above its st

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
bimsb6 said:
speeder was doing 101 mph and a doctor ,lied through his teeth as to why he was speeding ,said he was on an emergency call ,he had his mrs and sprog in car with him ! the child was standing on the back seat unrestrained .the fines points for the others were a joke .
I imagine if the system didn't overreact to hideously to trivia like doing 101mph, he wouldn't have even considered lying to the police.

SM

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
cor, you guys are stoopid, don't you listen to the goverment and nimbys - speeding is the worst offence you can commit in the UK nowadays.

Of course killing a biker is fine as long as you were under the 30 limit - driving without insurance just means you will try hard not to have an accident - but doing 100mph on the motorway - that causes children within a 10 mile radius to drop dead...

Chrispy Porker

17,761 posts

259 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Well for a start the Pole should have been remanded in custody.
Surely he was never likely to turn up for court.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
It was rather unseemly when the WPC was almost rubbing her hands with glee at the prospect of sending that poor guy back to China. Okay, the guy was illegal, and was taking the P (in more ways than one), but, as with thousands of other people who have tried to make a better life for themselves, it was a sorry fact of life that he would be deported.
It was nothing to be joking about just because she had another "detection", or whatever it was that was getting her juices flowing.

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
It was rather unseemly when the WPC was almost rubbing her hands with glee at the prospect of sending that poor guy back to China. Okay, the guy was illegal, and was taking the P (in more ways than one), but, as with thousands of other people who have tried to make a better life for themselves, it was a sorry fact of life that he would be deported.
It was nothing to be joking about just because she had another "detection", or whatever it was that was getting her juices flowing.
Probably made her quota of illegals for the month and was looking forward to the flat screen TV bonus..

MK4 Slowride

10,028 posts

239 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
It was rather unseemly when the WPC was almost rubbing her hands with glee at the prospect of sending that poor guy back to China. Okay, the guy was illegal, and was taking the P (in more ways than one), but, as with thousands of other people who have tried to make a better life for themselves, it was a sorry fact of life that he would be deported.
It was nothing to be joking about just because she had another "detection", or whatever it was that was getting her juices flowing.
Ok, maybe she shouldn't have been so keen.

He's here illigally and was driving on the road illegally. Perhaps he's never even had a driving lesson in China let alone the UK. With such a flagrant disregard for our laws like he's displayed i'm glad he's going back and really couldn't care less what happens to him when he arrives back. People can more than easilly enough enter the UK legally, no fuss or questions asked. It's a shame more aren't detected, good job bib.

Rusty Moskvitch

22 posts

229 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
The doctor should have said he was familiarising himself with the car. Plod would have understood that and sent him on his way. PC whatshisname was doing horrendous speeds in a car with which he was not familiar and got away with it. Or is it one law for them and another for the rest of us? Oh yes, silly me, so it is!

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
That was PC Milton yes.

How can it be fair that it is flat level fines anyway - doing 94.9 and 70.1 carries the identical penalty in a 70 mp/h zone. Again, the UK is the only country in Europe to have that strange system. Everyone else just has a price per km over the limit. My last fine was for 112 in a 100 zone, so a straight 12 * 3 Euro = 36 Euro. Then on your way sir.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Rusty Moskvitch said:
The doctor should have said he was familiarising himself with the car. Plod would have understood that and sent him on his way. PC whatshisname was doing horrendous speeds in a car with which he was not familiar and got away with it. Or is it one law for them and another for the rest of us? Oh yes, silly me, so it is!
He was convicted of dangerous driving following appeal.

Yes the Police are subject to different rules & regulations than the public. They can also have flashing headlamps, blue lights, carry CS gas, have different powers of arrest etc etc.

Edited by vonhosen on Thursday 27th March 17:06

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
EU_Foreigner said:
That was PC Milton yes.

How can it be fair that it is flat level fines anyway - doing 94.9 and 70.1 carries the identical penalty in a 70 mp/h zone. Again, the UK is the only country in Europe to have that strange system. Everyone else just has a price per km over the limit. My last fine was for 112 in a 100 zone, so a straight 12 * 3 Euro = 36 Euro. Then on your way sir.
They are not identical fines, fines are a matter for the court on the individual circumstances.
They are identical if FPN is issued (though graduated FPNs were in the Road Safety Act 2006 but haven't been started yet).

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
Markbishop said:
Caught the tail end of 'Motorway Cops' on BBC1 last night, the bit where they summarise what happened to the people featured in the show. Compare and contrast the penalties...

Man parks on hard shoulder and goes for a pee. BiB investigate; find he has no licence and is an illegal immigrant. Result: £75 fine, three points on his non-existent licence (so no points really).

Polish lorry driver travels on wrong side of the road, thinking two-way street is dual carriageway. Car swerves to avoid, collides with bike. Motorist seriously injured, biker carted off in air ambulance with possible spinal damage. Result: charged with careless driving but scarpers back to Poland so no penalty.

British doctor in recent Merc pulled for speeding (I did't see the main part of the show so don't know how fast): £600 fine, six points.

Rank these three incidents in order of the risk they represented to other road users. Then do the same by severity of penalties.

Methinks there's something wrong with the system...
Police action was consistent, they reported all of the above.
The sentencing is nothing to do with the Police, they are not responsible for it.

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
I don't think anyone blames the police for the inconsistent treatment of motoring offences.

Yes - I was referring to the FPN, as I understand the range of 70.1 and 94.9 mph all attract the identical FPN offer.

bimsb6

8,808 posts

252 months

Thursday 27th March 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
bimsb6 said:
speeder was doing 101 mph and a doctor ,lied through his teeth as to why he was speeding ,said he was on an emergency call ,he had his mrs and sprog in car with him ! the child was standing on the back seat unrestrained .the fines points for the others were a joke .
I imagine if the system didn't overreact to hideously to trivia like doing 101mph, he wouldn't have even considered lying to the police.

SM
he was asian it's a cultural thing . he said he was on an emergency call, then it was to give a diagnosis (i think) the child being unrestrained was his wifes fault ,then wanted speed reduced to under 100mph .i think from memory there were a couple of other changes in his story too .