WTF can mobile operaters legally do this?
WTF can mobile operaters legally do this?
Author
Discussion

crackthatoff

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

244 months

Saturday 29th March 2008
quotequote all
so I was sauntering through a little village I know well and at the end of it there sometimes is a mobile camera van that is catching people coming from the 60 zone into the village 30 zone which I suppose is fair game... untill today!... the bd was facing the other way no more than 50 yards before the national speed limit sign.
come on this is not fair!!!... surely there are rules? I looked at the speedo when I was almost on top of him and it read 35-37 ...I suppose I better wait for the ticket eh? it just rattles me to the core that no way no how is the little fooker making that particular road any safer, not even in the slightest !!

what is the offence for throwing a bucket of water inside the van drenching the git !

havoc

33,511 posts

266 months

Saturday 29th March 2008
quotequote all
Repost! wink


Sorry, not wanting to make light of your predicament. But it does seem to be a very common thread on here.

Technically, you were in the wrong. Practically, your point above is spot-on. Guess which one our government cares about?!?

Keep your fingers crossed your "35-37" was in reality "33-35" and he decided you weren't worth bothering with...

Gizmo535

18,150 posts

240 months

Saturday 29th March 2008
quotequote all
My 3 points were a similar situation. 60 turns into a 30 about a mile outside a village (seriously). Fairly steep downhill; van was parked behind a hedge at the start of a layby instead of its usual place at the end of the layby where you can see it. rolleyes
43 in a 30, bang to rights, but hardly bloody fair.

crackthatoff

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

244 months

Saturday 29th March 2008
quotequote all
Gizmo535 said:
My 3 points were a similar situation. 60 turns into a 30 about a mile outside a village (seriously). Fairly steep downhill; van was parked behind a hedge at the start of a layby instead of its usual place at the end of the layby where you can see it. rolleyes
43 in a 30, bang to rights, but hardly bloody fair.
yeah but this is just before a 30 turns to a 60, like 50 yards before !!!!!!
Im going to do what a true english gent does when sulking ..... drink me some stella !

Negative Creep

26,145 posts

258 months

Saturday 29th March 2008
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
come on this is not fair!!!
Since when has speed enforcement been fair? That Xmas party won't pay for itself.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Saturday 29th March 2008
quotequote all
Can they legally do it? Yes. Technically you are breaking the law, and guess what, they need the cash.

thecremeegg

2,100 posts

234 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Seen this a few times when heading along the Salisbury plains into Shrewton and Chitterne - sneaky tactic but probably quite legal sadly

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
Gizmo535 said:
My 3 points were a similar situation. 60 turns into a 30 about a mile outside a village (seriously). Fairly steep downhill; van was parked behind a hedge at the start of a layby instead of its usual place at the end of the layby where you can see it. rolleyes
43 in a 30, bang to rights, but hardly bloody fair.
yeah but this is just before a 30 turns to a 60, like 50 yards before !!!!!!
Im going to do what a true english gent does when sulking ..... drink me some stella !
It's pointless arguing that booking people exceeding the speed limit 50 yards before it changes to a higher one is at all unfair [BTW - I am not a proponent of unreasonable speed limits or the use of scameras]. Is booking them 51 yards before, OK or unfair? 52 yards? 60 yards? 100 yards? 10 yards? one yard?

Like it or not, reasonable speed limit or not, you were exceeding it.

Streaky

Trax

1,601 posts

263 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
Is it legal for them to do it? yes. Is it right? probably not, is it making our roads safer? definately not.

The safety partnerships have no mandate for safety, it is just outsourced law enforcement to private companies, and its a business.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
I don't accelerate till I get to the NSL sign but it means I have ars often crawling all over my bumper or deciding to overtake me just as I begin to accelerate... neither condusive to safety but its what the idiots in charge want.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
crackthatoff said:
Gizmo535 said:
My 3 points were a similar situation. 60 turns into a 30 about a mile outside a village (seriously). Fairly steep downhill; van was parked behind a hedge at the start of a layby instead of its usual place at the end of the layby where you can see it. rolleyes
43 in a 30, bang to rights, but hardly bloody fair.
yeah but this is just before a 30 turns to a 60, like 50 yards before !!!!!!
Im going to do what a true english gent does when sulking ..... drink me some stella !
It's pointless arguing that booking people exceeding the speed limit 50 yards before it changes to a higher one is at all unfair [BTW - I am not a proponent of unreasonable speed limits or the use of scameras]. Is booking them 51 yards before, OK or unfair? 52 yards? 60 yards? 100 yards? 10 yards? one yard?

Like it or not, reasonable speed limit or not, you were exceeding it.

Streaky
The Germans seem to have more common sense. Either by law or guidelines (not sure which) they dont do people for transgressions within 50M (i think) of a change of limit.

Cpn Jack Spanner

2,632 posts

236 months

Sunday 30th March 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
streaky said:
crackthatoff said:
Gizmo535 said:
My 3 points were a similar situation. 60 turns into a 30 about a mile outside a village (seriously). Fairly steep downhill; van was parked behind a hedge at the start of a layby instead of its usual place at the end of the layby where you can see it. rolleyes
43 in a 30, bang to rights, but hardly bloody fair.
yeah but this is just before a 30 turns to a 60, like 50 yards before !!!!!!
Im going to do what a true english gent does when sulking ..... drink me some stella !
It's pointless arguing that booking people exceeding the speed limit 50 yards before it changes to a higher one is at all unfair [BTW - I am not a proponent of unreasonable speed limits or the use of scameras]. Is booking them 51 yards before, OK or unfair? 52 yards? 60 yards? 100 yards? 10 yards? one yard?

Like it or not, reasonable speed limit or not, you were exceeding it.

Streaky
The Germans seem to have more common sense. Either by law or guidelines (not sure which) they dont do people for transgressions within 50M (i think) of a change of limit.
This Government, and it's predecessor, threw common sense out the window long ago.

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

232 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
I don't accelerate till I get to the NSL sign but it means I have ars often crawling all over my bumper or deciding to overtake me just as I begin to accelerate... neither condusive to safety but its what the idiots in charge want.
This absolutely kills me...I really do stick to the speed limits because I find it the only way I can make driving interesting...but all that seems to happen is that I'm overtaken at the most monumentally stupid points and get tailgaters swarming all over me. But at least I can be smug in the knowledge that I'm driving safely according to the powers that be (and some of those who inforce it) wink

pimpin gimp

3,319 posts

231 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
To be fair though, how does the copper know that you haven't blasted through the village at a constant 40mph (ish) as many people do, drive at 40 all the time, regardless of whether the limit is 30, 40, 50 or nsl.

crackthatoff

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

244 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
pimpin gimp said:
To be fair though, how does the copper know that you haven't blasted through the village at a constant 40mph (ish) as many people do, drive at 40 all the time, regardless of whether the limit is 30, 40, 50 or nsl.
I suppose that is a fair enough point !

leicesterboy15

151 posts

230 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
hondafanatic said:
mark69sheer said:
I don't accelerate till I get to the NSL sign but it means I have ars often crawling all over my bumper or deciding to overtake me just as I begin to accelerate... neither condusive to safety but its what the idiots in charge want.
This absolutely kills me...I really do stick to the speed limits because I find it the only way I can make driving interesting...but all that seems to happen is that I'm overtaken at the most monumentally stupid points and get tailgaters swarming all over me. But at least I can be smug in the knowledge that I'm driving safely according to the powers that be (and some of those who inforce it) wink
Driving at the limit doesn't make you safe, last week I was following a car that was sticking to the limit on a clear road, it was annoying but then that was the limit so I backed off, I thought he must be a 'safe' driver until we go to some traffic lights and he decided to jump them and turn right without indicating. It might just be me but I would have thought going at 35 is far less dangerous than jumping a set of traffic lights at a cross roads in the middle of London.

As for the speeding, very unfair but will probably stand up in court. I genuinely always thought though that you can accelerate up to that point so that when you hit the sign you are travelling closer to that speed - I'm sure my driving instructor told me this along with being allowed to exceed the speed limit briefly when overtaking (but then it was 12 years ago). It works both ways, you don't hit a 30 sign from a 60 and then hit the brakes, you slow down gradually so you are as close to 30 as possible when you cross the sign.

andy400

11,837 posts

262 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Got caught on camera for the first time in ages just a few days ago. Strange mix of emotions - Angry at myself for speeding and not keeping a better look out for scamera vans, and angry at whoever thinks a scamera van monitoring a nearly empty dual carriageway to see if anyone is doing sixty in a (nonsensical) fifty zone is a good idea for improving safety.

Bang to rights and all that, but.... Grrr....

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

232 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
leicesterboy15 said:
hondafanatic said:
mark69sheer said:
I don't accelerate till I get to the NSL sign but it means I have ars often crawling all over my bumper or deciding to overtake me just as I begin to accelerate... neither condusive to safety but its what the idiots in charge want.
This absolutely kills me...I really do stick to the speed limits because I find it the only way I can make driving interesting...but all that seems to happen is that I'm overtaken at the most monumentally stupid points and get tailgaters swarming all over me. But at least I can be smug in the knowledge that I'm driving safely according to the powers that be (and some of those who inforce it) wink
Driving at the limit doesn't make you safe, last week I was following a car that was sticking to the limit on a clear road, it was annoying but then that was the limit so I backed off, I thought he must be a 'safe' driver until we go to some traffic lights and he decided to jump them and turn right without indicating. It might just be me but I would have thought going at 35 is far less dangerous than jumping a set of traffic lights at a cross roads in the middle of London.quote]

Hence the wink