Advice needed desperately...
Advice needed desperately...
Author
Discussion

chris_gorton

Original Poster:

19 posts

230 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
I was hoping someone with a bit of experience would be able to give me some advice as to where i stand within the law.Its quite a long story but i would greatly appreciate anyone bothering to read the whole thing and help me.

It all started when a gentleman crashed into the back of me one rainy evening.It was a low speed rear shunt that left my bumper and boot damaged.The other party immediately accepted liability and i was contacted by Swift Cover Insurance to have my car collected by one of their dedicated repair centres.
The repair centre arranged a 2:00 pick up and delivery of my (too small) courtesy car.At 4:00 there was still no car and no phone call so i rang them and was told the car just left as there was no drivers available and it should arrive with me at 6:00.The car finally arrived at 7:30 with no petrol in it.As nobody had explained this particualr company's petrol policy i did the polite thing and gave them my car with £20 of petrol.I instantly phoned and requested the petrol be returned once the car was repaired.
Two weeks pass and i get a phone call the Thursday before Easter informing me my car was ready to be delivered so i arrange delivery to my girlfriends address for 4:00.As before, 4:00 comes and goes with no phone call.At 6:00 i ring them and they tell me my car has left and is on its way.By 8:30 i'm growing impatient so i ring and am told the car is sitting in the garage and never left.Being a bank holiday weekend, i am told the car can't be delivered until the following Tuesday,i kick up a fuss and they agree to come in on Saturday and deliver it then.
Saturday afternoon the car arrives, yet again 1 hour late but i expect it by now.I inspect the repairs and the paint match and everything is satisfactory so i sign for the car but tell the driver the petrol is missing.Later that evening i drive the car for the first time and find my gear lever is wobbling all over the place and there is about 1 1/2 inchs of play when in gear or in neutral.I immediately phone the insurance company to complain, where i'm told that it is the garage's problem to rectify as it was not accident related.
I phoned the garage on Friday and they've just got back to me that it is "wear and tear" and they arent willing to fix it but will refund my petrol.I stupidly forgot to note the mileage but it seems to have gone up way more than a 76 mile round trip.Have i got a leg to stand on or am i wasting my money and time getting my family solicitor involved?

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
Get your insurers assesor involved and don't let them wriggle out of this with the 'it's not our problem crap'
I had a Merc repaired by my insurance companies approved garage (I was blackmailed into using it as they said if I use the approved garage they would come and pick my immobile car up but if I wanted to use another repairer it was up to me to drag my immobile car around three other garages for quotes....what would you do at 7pm on a January evening?

Anyway my car came back a pile of ste and they tried the .. its between you and the garage crap'
I pointed out they approved the garage so were therefore liable for its work..
I got their head inspector to come and view the car . . . it was a mess so I got the insurance companies agreement that they would insect the car themselves before the garage was allowed to release it.

Not an easy job though, many fraught phone calls and three months in a crappy hire car.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
I would forget all this stuff about petrol and lateness, I don't know why your bothered about £20 of petrol. You can cover the lateness in a general letter of complaint later.
What's important is the gear selector/gearbox problem. If they have assessed it and say there is nothing wrong just wear and tear then you can take it to another(local) garage and see what they say. If something is damaged then you can give the original repair shop the option of fixing it. If they refuse then you can get it done at your local garage and send them the bill.

2SPN

1,558 posts

302 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
What kind of car is this? Sounds like a bush or rod has failed in the selector mechanism, probably caused by the paint shop muppet crashing through the gears but simple and cheap to fix.

Salsera

263 posts

233 months

Monday 31st March 2008
quotequote all
When my other half had to have his car done after having the side of his car taken out by a lorry we had to use an approved body shop instead of one we wanted to use, part of the repair was the rear screen which had to be removed and then put back in so the body work could be done. When we got it back found out the heater in the rear screen had stopped working, took it round a friendly local garage and they had a look found the problem. Then we had the hassel of contacting the insurers and garage the work was done at. Quite alot of hassel but defnitally keep at it. Eventually they got ours sorted out at no cost to us, but you do have to keep on top of it. I think they rely on people thinking it's not worth the hassel.

chris_gorton

Original Poster:

19 posts

230 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Its an E36 BMW 318is.I'm wasting my time with the lateness and my petrol because to some of us £20 is a lot of money and the lateness was a pretty serious customer services failure which makes me look patient and them incompetant if it does go to court.I'm only 22, i don't have anyone in my life to help me out financially and i'm paying through the nose for private health care for my girlfriend.It just astounds me that without even seeing the gearbox the garage has said its my fault and expects me to accept that.It makes you wonder how many times this happens to people and they do nothing about it.

Thanks for the advice people, i guess i'll just have to keep pestering them and get the solicitors onto them because i've already spent £30 phoning them and the insurance company in the last 3 weeks and the whole thing is draining me

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
I take it Swiftcover is your insurer ? Perhaps the best thing to do in this case would have been to go via their insurer not your own. You would have got a nice hire car, and the repairs done where you wanted. Anyway...

Swiftcover are cheap. And you get what you pay for. Did you look at the bit in the policy that says they can use 2nd hand parts to repair you car ? Or the bit about having to use their cheap-as-chips network ?

Doesn't excuse the bad service, however. Not convinced you will get that far with the wear and tear bit. It will be hard to prove that a low impact shunt affected the gear box.

In the first instance, get a complaint in. When you call say "you do not think you have been treated fairly" and wish to make a complaint under the terms of the FSA.


chris_gorton

Original Poster:

19 posts

230 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Sorry didnt explain myself very well.The driver that hit me was insured with swift cover.I didnt want to do it through my insurance because i'm currently locked in a battle with them too because it turns out they are a broker and my payments havent been received by HSBC who i'm (supposedly) actually insured with but i've got proof that the money has been sent to the brokers.Hence why i'm F*CKING stressed at the moment.
And i'm not trying to claim that the gearbox was damaged in the accident,i'm saying that one of the drivers (delivery/collection) or mechanics, has the delicacy of an overweigh elephant when changing gear in my car.Another possibility is that one of them took it out for a weekend as they did have the car for 2 and half weeks to repair a bumper and boot.Either way i've think i've been quite patient by asking him to inspect it and prove it was 'wear and tear' rather than trying to fob me off without even seeing the gearbox.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Tuesday 1st April 2008
quotequote all
Ah, that puts a different slant on matters. I still think you are going to have a job to prove the gerbox wasn't like that before (not suggesting it was). Not impossible, if persistance.

Would be tempted to get the lawyers involved, they have admitted liabilty afterall. Ignore the bit about the FSA.

So the lesson for next time is still don't let Swiftcover do your repairs, get them done yourself and bill them !

Good luck.