Any Trailer weight law experts?
Discussion
Evening,
I'm after some help to clear up something i was told a few years back, and confirm if it's true or not.
In essence i've been told that if you are towing an unladen trailer behind a vehicle, that vehicle's maximum towing capacity must be equal to or above the maximum gross weight of the trailer. The idea being that you COULD tow more than the vehicle's maximum weight with the trailer, hence being illegal. I'm told that there have been prosecutions for this.
So in essence the question is: If i was to tow an empty braked trailer with a maximum weight of 3500kg, with a car that has a maximum braked towing capacity of 1900kg, would i be breaking the law?
I'm after some help to clear up something i was told a few years back, and confirm if it's true or not.
In essence i've been told that if you are towing an unladen trailer behind a vehicle, that vehicle's maximum towing capacity must be equal to or above the maximum gross weight of the trailer. The idea being that you COULD tow more than the vehicle's maximum weight with the trailer, hence being illegal. I'm told that there have been prosecutions for this.
So in essence the question is: If i was to tow an empty braked trailer with a maximum weight of 3500kg, with a car that has a maximum braked towing capacity of 1900kg, would i be breaking the law?
Without being definitive on this, I don't see how you can be acting illegally if the mass of the trailer and its load (if any) is less than the published trailer mass. It's not compulsory to load the trailer to its plated capacity.
Obviously if you exceeded either your braked trailer mass or your gross train mass you could then expect to be prosecuted.
You could tow more than the weight of your vehicle, but you aren't doing so. You also could simply be moving the trailer from one place to another.
You could just as equally overload a trailer but not exceed the vehicle's towing capacity. That is equally as possible in theory and I imagine equally as prosecutable i.e. not at all until the act is done, detected and been proven.
Obviously if you exceeded either your braked trailer mass or your gross train mass you could then expect to be prosecuted.
You could tow more than the weight of your vehicle, but you aren't doing so. You also could simply be moving the trailer from one place to another.
You could just as equally overload a trailer but not exceed the vehicle's towing capacity. That is equally as possible in theory and I imagine equally as prosecutable i.e. not at all until the act is done, detected and been proven.
That's what i was thinking. Trouble is i remember reading (on PH i think) a story of someone getting nicked on the way to picking up a MK1 Escort for having the empty trailer plated higher than the car.
If anyone's got any more detail on this it would be appreciated as it rather majorly affects my choice of tow cars (i can only hire 3500kg max capacity trailers locally).
If anyone's got any more detail on this it would be appreciated as it rather majorly affects my choice of tow cars (i can only hire 3500kg max capacity trailers locally).
agent006 said:
That's what i was thinking. Trouble is i remember reading (on PH i think) a story of someone getting nicked on the way to picking up a MK1 Escort for having the empty trailer plated higher than the car.
If anyone's got any more detail on this it would be appreciated as it rather majorly affects my choice of tow cars (i can only hire 3500kg max capacity trailers locally).
Probably an officious arse of a copper.If anyone's got any more detail on this it would be appreciated as it rather majorly affects my choice of tow cars (i can only hire 3500kg max capacity trailers locally).
I don't see how you can get nicked for towing an empty or loaded trailer if the gross train wieght isn't exceeded.
Taking it a step further we used to pull 38 ton gross semi trailers with 32 ton gross tractor units with no come back, I even used to take them for MOT with a 28 gross unit.
The trouble with trailers etc there's a minefield of information and mis-information out there.
Basically the rule is this: Each vehicle on the road is constructed to tow a trailer or caravan up to a certain weight and this is give to the new owner of every vehicle in the owners manual.
However, the laws changed with the introduction with new rulings from the EU where it stated that the towed trailer must not exceed the weight of the towing vehicle - but if your car is over a certain age it does not ALWAYS apply. Also the laws changed with licensing ages too.
I have had a lovely experience with the BiB's and VOSA over a similar matter I'm 41 and have on my license the catagory C1+E as well as C1 and C.
C1+E refers to HGV's (or LGV's nowadays) up to 7.5 tons towing a trailer. Now, the DVLA say that I am able to tow a lorry and trailer combination up to a MAM (max unauthorised mass) of 8.25 tonnes, however I got pulled twice by the BiB's whilst towing my EMPTY 3.5 ton car trailer behind an UNLADEN 7.5 ton Ford Cargo. Both times the BiB's didn't know the law and threatened prosecution over driving a vehicle I was not licensed to drive, not having insurance for the class etc. I therefore kept a copy of the details from the DVLA website on the law plus a weighbridge certificate of the combination unladen which showed a total weight of just over 4 tons.
Even VOSA stopped me and didn't know the law.......
So, best bet is to check on the vehicle's towing capacity, your license and the DVLA website!!
Basically the rule is this: Each vehicle on the road is constructed to tow a trailer or caravan up to a certain weight and this is give to the new owner of every vehicle in the owners manual.
However, the laws changed with the introduction with new rulings from the EU where it stated that the towed trailer must not exceed the weight of the towing vehicle - but if your car is over a certain age it does not ALWAYS apply. Also the laws changed with licensing ages too.
I have had a lovely experience with the BiB's and VOSA over a similar matter I'm 41 and have on my license the catagory C1+E as well as C1 and C.
C1+E refers to HGV's (or LGV's nowadays) up to 7.5 tons towing a trailer. Now, the DVLA say that I am able to tow a lorry and trailer combination up to a MAM (max unauthorised mass) of 8.25 tonnes, however I got pulled twice by the BiB's whilst towing my EMPTY 3.5 ton car trailer behind an UNLADEN 7.5 ton Ford Cargo. Both times the BiB's didn't know the law and threatened prosecution over driving a vehicle I was not licensed to drive, not having insurance for the class etc. I therefore kept a copy of the details from the DVLA website on the law plus a weighbridge certificate of the combination unladen which showed a total weight of just over 4 tons.
Even VOSA stopped me and didn't know the law.......
So, best bet is to check on the vehicle's towing capacity, your license and the DVLA website!!
justamin said:
So, best bet is to check on the vehicle's towing capacity, your license and the DVLA website!!
Thanks for the info. My choice is between an estate with 1990kg capacity (which will tow an average trailer and my BMW) or a 4x4 with 3500kg capacity. The 4x4 is looking more unnecessary. In the process of all this i will need to upgrade my license to allow me to tow more than 750kg (mine's post '97).agent006 said:
Evening,
I'm after some help to clear up something i was told a few years back, and confirm if it's true or not.
In essence i've been told that if you are towing an unladen trailer behind a vehicle, that vehicle's maximum towing capacity must be equal to or above the maximum gross weight of the trailer. The idea being that you COULD tow more than the vehicle's maximum weight with the trailer, hence being illegal. I'm told that there have been prosecutions for this.
So in essence the question is: If i was to tow an empty braked trailer with a maximum weight of 3500kg, with a car that has a maximum braked towing capacity of 1900kg, would i be breaking the law?
Just to clarify things what tow car are you using? A 3500kg gross trailer will be quite heavy in itself.I'm after some help to clear up something i was told a few years back, and confirm if it's true or not.
In essence i've been told that if you are towing an unladen trailer behind a vehicle, that vehicle's maximum towing capacity must be equal to or above the maximum gross weight of the trailer. The idea being that you COULD tow more than the vehicle's maximum weight with the trailer, hence being illegal. I'm told that there have been prosecutions for this.
So in essence the question is: If i was to tow an empty braked trailer with a maximum weight of 3500kg, with a car that has a maximum braked towing capacity of 1900kg, would i be breaking the law?
agent006 said:
That's what i was thinking. Trouble is i remember reading (on PH i think) a story of someone getting nicked on the way to picking up a MK1 Escort for having the empty trailer plated higher than the car.
If anyone's got any more detail on this it would be appreciated as it rather majorly affects my choice of tow cars (i can only hire 3500kg max capacity trailers locally).
The only plausible (reasonable) scenario I can think of here is that the plod thought the plated weight was the weight of the trailer empty.If anyone's got any more detail on this it would be appreciated as it rather majorly affects my choice of tow cars (i can only hire 3500kg max capacity trailers locally).
agent006 said:
falcemob said:
Just to clarify things what tow car are you using? A 3500kg gross trailer will be quite heavy in itself.
I'm not yet. The choice is either an Audi A6 quattro (1990kg braked) or a Nissan Patrol (3500 braked). Towing an 1100kg car.I go racing and an extra set of wheels and tyres and some jerry cans of fuel can add quite a bit of weight.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


