A contract law question
Author
Discussion

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Apologies for the long post but I wanted to include all the facts.

I am after advise before I decode what to do on the following please:

About 6 months ago I put a deposit down for the forthcoming Nissan GTR.
At the time I was told this was not a deposit but an 'intention to purchase' which would reserve my place in the queue to be sold on a first come first served basis.
Last week I upped this deposit to 3.5k as a formal deposit with which the dealer will place the order today and it will become non-refundable.

Last night I discovered that Nissan had announced internally that they are roughly 3 times oversubscribed for the first years allocation (March09-March10) and will be allocating the cars on a 'lottery' system and not a 'first come first served' basis. This has been verified. Nissan have not formally told thier customers this yet.

Now my questions are as follows:

1) Although my deposit is technically non-refundable as of tommorow, if I wait until I am told the date of delivery and then cancel if it is apparent that I 'lost' the lottery, presumably I can still demand my 'non-refundable' deposit back as they have breached thier contract by changing the allocation rules?

2)Assuming 1)to be true: WOuld the answer be different if I spoke to the dealer about it (he already has the deposit under the previous 'terms') and he confirms that yes it is now a lottery but I allow the deposit to remain until delivery dates are confirmed rather than demanding an instant refund.

Hope this makes sense and thanks in advance for your help

mmm-five

12,399 posts

315 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Surely the non-refundable part is only if YOU cancel for some reason.

If the SUPPLIER cannot come up with the goods then you will get a refund.

If the 'contract' infers anything other than this, then it would be 'unreasonable' and would likely not make it far in court.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
Surely the non-refundable part is only if YOU cancel for some reason.

If the SUPPLIER cannot come up with the goods then you will get a refund.

If the 'contract' infers anything other than this, then it would be 'unreasonable' and would likely not make it far in court.
If Nissan can't provide the goods you should get a refund.


Your dealer sounds like a c0ck. Go and see him and say look, am I geting a car or not, and if not, why not?



Edited by Vesuvius 996 on Wednesday 2nd April 12:36

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
But thier argument would be 'they had never guaranteed a date. Nothing has changed. If I want to cancel my order that is my perogative'

From what I have heard they intend to take a hard line with respect to deposits.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Yes.

What you have essentially said is correct. However, with all 'contract law' questions, the devil is in the detail, in this case the contract if it is written, however if it is as you have explained then you are correct.

I would just speak to them today and be open and honest about what you have discovered. They may know about it or they may not. What you have asked them is reasonable and you have given them the opportunity to give your deposit back as the terms have now changed, or to accept your deposit on the new terms you are defining.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Vesuvius 996 said:
[Your dealer sounds like a c0ck. Go and see him and say look, am I geting a car or not, and if not, why not?



[]
To be fair, it is definitely NOT the dealers fault, but that of Nissan GB.
The dealer has always been honest about knowing next to nothing (this is echoed on the GTR forums by customers of every GTR dealer)

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
But thier argument would be 'they had never guaranteed a date. Nothing has changed. If I want to cancel my order that is my perogative'

From what I have heard they intend to take a hard line with respect to deposits.
They probably will as it is a loss of money for them. That doesnt mean it is right.

Your contract was not made on the 'intention to purchase' it was made on the understanding you were allocated a first come first served car on a waiting list - and on that you placed your deposit.

If that is no longer the case then you can argue your contract is no longer applicable to the situation. The terms have changed.

However, you should make this situation clear or ask them for written confirmation before they place your deposit with NIssan.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Yes.

What you have essentially said is correct. However, with all 'contract law' questions, the devil is in the detail, in this case the contract if it is written, however if it is as you have explained then you are correct.

I would just speak to them today and be open and honest about what you have discovered. They may know about it or they may not. What you have asked them is reasonable and you have given them the opportunity to give your deposit back as the terms have now changed, or to accept your deposit on the new terms you are defining.
The point of this post is that I don't actually want to speak to them, if by doing so I am accepting new terms.
The deposit I have paid so far has been over the phone and everything has been done verbally thus as far as I am concerned the terms are that I have agreed to buy roughly the 25th car which comes in.
If nothing else is said, i would prefer wait for the allocation announcement to find out if I am still there or thereabouts in which case I still want the car. But if it turns out I am now number 85 then I want to cancel at that point.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
JustinP1 said:
Yes.

What you have essentially said is correct. However, with all 'contract law' questions, the devil is in the detail, in this case the contract if it is written, however if it is as you have explained then you are correct.

I would just speak to them today and be open and honest about what you have discovered. They may know about it or they may not. What you have asked them is reasonable and you have given them the opportunity to give your deposit back as the terms have now changed, or to accept your deposit on the new terms you are defining.
The point of this post is that I don't actually want to speak to them, if by doing so I am accepting new terms.
The deposit I have paid so far has been over the phone and everything has been done verbally thus as far as I am concerned the terms are that I have agreed to buy roughly the 25th car which comes in.
If nothing else is said, i would prefer wait for the allocation announcement to find out if I am still there or thereabouts in which case I still want the car. But if it turns out I am now number 85 then I want to cancel at that point.
Right.

Look at this situation practically. If it works out good, you are fine. If not, then what will you do?

Lets say you want to cancel later on. They will say that they placed your deposit in good faith and you entered into a binding contract with them, and you are getting cold feet. They could argue that what they told you was correct. You are in a waiting list with them not the manufacturer... yada yada...

If they dig their heels in, the ultimate action is that you will have to do the legwork to take them to court. Secondly, win the case. With something that is arranged verbally, it is your word against theirs - and of course their T&Cs which they will have written down in their dealership which are on request should you wish to see them...

Realistically it is not a strong position later. However, the bargaining tool you have now is that you can walk away before they place the order. Rather than see you walk away, they may be more flexible in their terms - and importantly you can get them in writing to see exactly what you can expect, so if you don't get you are promised then you can walk away.




Edited by JustinP1 on Wednesday 2nd April 12:55

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Are you saying this as someone who works in the legal profession?

If, so I am massively suprised by your answer.
If I enter a verbal contract then I am in someway bound by some written terms which exist somewhere which have never been bought to my attention?

I assumed, obviously incorrectly, that it would be a relatively easy process through the courts.

Edited by blindswelledrat on Wednesday 2nd April 13:01

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Am I right in thinking that you are only interested in speculatively buying an early version of this car, merely to sell it on at a profit?

If that is the case then the action taken by Nissan has obviously been designed to make life difficult for you.

If you have placed a formal deposit you need to read the small print very carefully, I would bet that there is no guarantee of either a delivery date or car number X.

sir_lurk_alot

316 posts

226 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
You are bound by the terms of your contract, as you have entered into an agreement when signing the contract.

The best thing to do is check your contract, see what it says about this issue in the contract. If it stipulates a time frame, or a 'first come first serve' agreement and they are now changing the terms of the contract, you will be entitled to your money back. As they are no longer abiding by the terms of the original agreement it will negate the original agreement you had with them. It is not your fault that they have taken too many orders and are now being forced to change the agreement which you entered into, in good faith.

The problem you will have is if it says that these details are subject to change without you being notified, in which case you are stuffed.

hope that helps

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Are you saying this as someone who works in the legal profession?

If, so I am massively suprised by your answer.
If I enter a verbal contract then I am in someway bound by some written terms which exist somewhere which have never been bought to my attention?

I assumed, obviously incorrectly, that it would be a relatively easy process through the courts.

Edited by blindswelledrat on Wednesday 2nd April 13:01
I am not a solicitor, but as part of my Business Management degree, I took law and specialised in contract law.

Since then, and also in managing my own company I have spent a decade with the issues as above and got a lot more practical insight, as well as taking three PLCs to court over contract terms and conditions, with them backing down and paying my costs each time.

Each company, whether they sell to business or consumers will have to comply with the Sale of Goods Act, however they will also most likely have a 'Terms and Conditions of Sale' whereby although they cannot contradict the act (well not in consumer contracts anyway...) they will also have the set of rules and definitions which is their Terms and Conditions. By entering into someones premises and entering into a contract with them, they could argue that you have accepted these Terms. The type of thing with be things defining what a deposit is, and when ownership of goods changes. Best practice to protect both parties is that they should put a copy of these terms in front of you and get you to sign a contract, however, this is not always realistic.

This is especially true if it is a shop you have walked into. Have a look next time, around the till area usually there will be a laminate with a lot of small print on. I can't remember the exact requirement, but I am pretty sure that the terms must be 'displayed' and that there are copies to be available by request. The situation is slightly different if you have *only* dealt with them by phone. In this case then they should have sent you their terms if they wish to rely on anything other than common law.

The problem is with verbal contracts is if there is a dispute, especially over a technicality it is difficult for either party to conclusively prove they are right. IMHO I can see this happening here should things turn sour. That said, the worst that should happen is that if there is a shortage the dealer would be quite happy to keep the allocation and sell it at the dealership at list price or above. That way they will not have incurred a loss, and therefore nothing they could claim from you.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
Ean218 said:
Am I right in thinking that you are only interested in speculatively buying an early version of this car, merely to sell it on at a profit?

If that is the case then the action taken by Nissan has obviously been designed to make life difficult for you.

If you have placed a formal deposit you need to read the small print very carefully, I would bet that there is no guarantee of either a delivery date or car number X.
To answer your question, no- not at all.I intend to keep it for as long as they hold thier value-ish.
Normaly I would not spend that kind of money on a new car because, to me, the cost of a car is it's depreciation and not its price, and your average 60k car will lose 1000 per month give or take (which I consider unjustifiable).
Whereas I would expect the Nissan to be £500 or so per month at worst and given that i really really want one-it is perfect.
However, the longer I have to wait, the greater the depreciation will be.
I would not pay 60k for it if supply equalled demand on the basis that I couldn't afford it/justify it. I would simply wait 3 or 4 years and buy a second hand one.

To reiterate: there small no small print. There is no written contract. my deposit has been taken over the phone after discussions.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
sir_lurk_alot said:
You are bound by the terms of your contract, as you have entered into an agreement when signing the contract.

The best thing to do is check your contract, see what it says about this issue in the contract. If it stipulates a time frame, or a 'first come first serve' agreement and they are now changing the terms of the contract, you will be entitled to your money back. As they are no longer abiding by the terms of the original agreement it will negate the original agreement you had with them. It is not your fault that they have taken too many orders and are now being forced to change the agreement which you entered into, in good faith.

The problem you will have is if it says that these details are subject to change without you being notified, in which case you are stuffed.

hope that helps
Thanks, but you missed the vital point that everything was done over the phone and there is no written contract as such.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
sir_lurk_alot said:
You are bound by the terms of your contract, as you have entered into an agreement when signing the contract.

The best thing to do is check your contract, see what it says about this issue in the contract. If it stipulates a time frame, or a 'first come first serve' agreement and they are now changing the terms of the contract, you will be entitled to your money back. As they are no longer abiding by the terms of the original agreement it will negate the original agreement you had with them. It is not your fault that they have taken too many orders and are now being forced to change the agreement which you entered into, in good faith.

The problem you will have is if it says that these details are subject to change without you being notified, in which case you are stuffed.

hope that helps
Thanks, but you missed the vital point that everything was done over the phone and there is no written contract as such.
So to confirm, you have NEVER been in the dealership and they have NEVER posted you anything?

If so, then they may very well be in contravention of the Distance Selling Regulations.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
lots of things thumbup
I get your point and I also know from experience the difficulty in 'word against word' cases.
However-just to clarify what you said earlier- would a judge ever take into account the dealers standard written contract even though I have never been to thier premises and they have never mentioned it and I have never been asked to sign anything??

My own experiences suggest not, but I defer to anyone who says otherwise for certain/

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
blindswelledrat said:
sir_lurk_alot said:
You are bound by the terms of your contract, as you have entered into an agreement when signing the contract.

The best thing to do is check your contract, see what it says about this issue in the contract. If it stipulates a time frame, or a 'first come first serve' agreement and they are now changing the terms of the contract, you will be entitled to your money back. As they are no longer abiding by the terms of the original agreement it will negate the original agreement you had with them. It is not your fault that they have taken too many orders and are now being forced to change the agreement which you entered into, in good faith.

The problem you will have is if it says that these details are subject to change without you being notified, in which case you are stuffed.

hope that helps
Thanks, but you missed the vital point that everything was done over the phone and there is no written contract as such.
So to confirm, you have NEVER been in the dealership and they have NEVER posted you anything?

If so, then they may very well be in contravention of the Distance Selling Regulations.
To clarify completely:
I went into a branch and placed 1k intention to purchase (just a receipt-don't think I signed anything)
My name was then transfered to a different dealers list and the dealings with them and the actual deposit were done over the phone with no paperwork at all.
However, the dealer will only forward that depoit with my order to Nissan today-so presumably I will subsequently get something through the post?

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
JustinP1 said:
lots of things thumbup
I get your point and I also know from experience the difficulty in 'word against word' cases.
However-just to clarify what you said earlier- would a judge ever take into account the dealers standard written contract even though I have never been to thier premises and they have never mentioned it and I have never been asked to sign anything??

My own experiences suggest not, but I defer to anyone who says otherwise for certain/
As I mentioned above, if you have never been there, then that is a different scenario, and for good reason - of course for situations like this!

In this case it is their responsibility to send you all of the terms and conditions as well as a lot of other requirements as well as informing you of your right to cancel as per the Distance Selling Regulations.

In this case, if they have never sent you anything in writing and all of your contact has been over the phone, then they will be in breach of the regulations, and if push came to shove you could void the whole lot.

Hope this helps!

mmm-five

12,399 posts

315 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
But thier argument would be 'they had never guaranteed a date. Nothing has changed. If I want to cancel my order that is my perogative'

From what I have heard they intend to take a hard line with respect to deposits.
If they change the delivery date (which they haven't given you anyway) then you'll just have to take it on the chin, or cancel and lose your deposit.

If you are told you have not been allocated a car from the lottery, then it's impossible for them to keep their end of the deal (i.e. they can't deliver at all) and so you'd be entitled to a refund.

The first instance is you terminating the contract, the second is the dealer/Nissan terminating the contract.

Speak to the dealer - and if you're not happy refuse to sign anything and request a refund. All this talk is speculation until you know exactly what you've [not] signed up for. Personally I wouldn't be putting £3.5k of my money anywhere without some proper documentation.