Thinking of sueing someone off eBay
Thinking of sueing someone off eBay
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
Only a matter of a couple of hundred quid or so. I don't really want to go into detail, but although he eventually sent me the goods, he took so long about it that I'd raised a dispute. He agreed to get the item collected and refund me the money if I cancelled the dispute.

I was fairly sure he wouldn't but given PayPal were doing nothing with the dispute I felt I'd take the chance and sell the thing myself to get my money back if he was lying.

So sure enough he didn't refund me, however, this guy is such an imbecile that I'm quite inclined to take him to the small claims court just to spoil his day.

Question is, do eBay messages constitute a contract? If he promises to do something but doesn't, will the judge rubber stamp the action?

He's 300 miles away so if we had to go to court, which court would it be? My local one would be sweet.

SM

eta: by the time the goods arrived I'd given up and bought another so his is no use to me.

Edited by supermono on Thursday 3rd April 13:04

tlracing

703 posts

254 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
Providing you have his address and some evidence to support your claim, it's worth the effort. You can now issue the claim online, so won't necessarily have to go to court.

Have a look at www.moneyclaim.gov.uk

Edited by tlracing on Thursday 3rd April 13:52


Edited by tlracing on Thursday 3rd April 13:53

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
Sm,

Unless I have missed something here, you sold the item on, and didn't return it to the guy who sold it to you, therefore he didn't give you your money back.

On what basis would you sue him? (He may well be a c0ck, but sadly that's not an offence these days!)


Oli.

bimsb6

8,808 posts

252 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
how much are you out of pocket ? as that is all you can chase him for .

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
This may not seem as simple as it sounds.

The law of contract is such that you would have to show that he has breached it enough for you to have to nullify it. Delivering something late won't usually be enough to prove this. What also goes against you is that the item did turn up.

Now, if you wanted to sue him it would be on the original contract terms. Did you raise the dispute before the item arrived?

If so, you have proof that you had informed him that you wanted to cancel, and his email seems to suggest he has agreed to this. On those grounds you could argue that the contract has now been rescinded, yet he is still to action this. Hypothetically the court would have to decide if the email was a real intention of his actions, which no doubt they will agree.

I say hypothetically, as something like 98% of small claims summons don't end up in a courtroom as the pressure of this settles the issue one way or another. If you wanted a choice of court, print the relevant form from the County Courts website - N1 off the top of my head - and take it down to your local court. This way the paperwork will come from them and not Nottingham or Northampton or wherever the online service is based.



supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
zcacogp said:
Unless I have missed something here, you sold the item on, and didn't return it to the guy who sold it to you, therefore he didn't give you your money back.
lol. Yes you misunderstand. Obviously I wouldn't sue him for something I'd sold on. He sent it late but lied twice that he'd already sent it. So it seemed to me he'd defrauded me and wasn't sending it at all. I raised a dispute and bought another. The goods arrived a few hours after I'd started the dispute. I still hold the goods for his collection. He said if I cancelled the dispute he'd refund me and collect the goods... This is the bit I'm wondering -- he said he'd do this and hasn't.

SM

andyuk911

1,979 posts

240 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
Not to hi-jack this thread ...

I am thinking of taking a shop to the small claims court for my son.

He bought an item online for a small amount of money, let say below £100 ...found it was 100% unsuitable.

I therefore took it back the following day after receipt and the shop refused the item as I was returning it in person ...

So I sent it back and guess what, they refused the item from the delivery company..

Long story short .. Trading Standards tell me they have been ignoring the Consumer Protection act 2000 Distance Selling regs for a while ..

In the end I took the item back, put it in the shop and took a few pixs ... at which they swore at me and went to pursue me ...

So I reported them to the police ..

So at the moment the Bank are dealing with them .. but because of his age he does not have a credit card, just Solo .. so I hope he get his money.

If not smalls claims here I come ...

(So to be so vague ... I am sure you all can guess why ....)


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
andyuk911 said:
Not to hi-jack this thread ...

I am thinking of taking a shop to the small claims court for my son.

He bought an item online for a small amount of money, let say below £100 ...found it was 100% unsuitable.

I therefore took it back the following day after receipt and the shop refused the item as I was returning it in person ...

So I sent it back and guess what, they refused the item from the delivery company..

Long story short .. Trading Standards tell me they have been ignoring the Consumer Protection act 2000 Distance Selling regs for a while ..

In the end I took the item back, put it in the shop and took a few pixs ... at which they swore at me and went to pursue me ...

So I reported them to the police ..

So at the moment the Bank are dealing with them .. but because of his age he does not have a credit card, just Solo .. so I hope he get his money.

If not smalls claims here I come ...

(So to be so vague ... I am sure you all can guess why ....)
You have seven working days to return the item. You don't need any reason why. They should refund you the full amount for the item and postage.

Thats a lot more simple. Money claim online is your friend here.

I am always surprised that shops start trading like this and really don't bother to check or just completely ignore their responsibilities.

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 3rd April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
lol. Yes you misunderstand. Obviously I wouldn't sue him for something I'd sold on. He sent it late but lied twice that he'd already sent it. So it seemed to me he'd defrauded me and wasn't sending it at all. I raised a dispute and bought another. The goods arrived a few hours after I'd started the dispute. I still hold the goods for his collection. He said if I cancelled the dispute he'd refund me and collect the goods... This is the bit I'm wondering -- he said he'd do this and hasn't.
Ah. OK, fair enough.

So it's more the buggeration factor then?

I can't help, but it sounds like he really is a c0ck, so all the best ...


Oli.

andyuk911

1,979 posts

240 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
andyuk911 said:
Not to hi-jack this thread ...

I am thinking of taking a shop to the small claims court for my son.

He bought an item online for a small amount of money, let say below £100 ...found it was 100% unsuitable.

I therefore took it back the following day after receipt and the shop refused the item as I was returning it in person ...

So I sent it back and guess what, they refused the item from the delivery company..

Long story short .. Trading Standards tell me they have been ignoring the Consumer Protection act 2000 Distance Selling regs for a while ..

In the end I took the item back, put it in the shop and took a few pixs ... at which they swore at me and went to pursue me ...

So I reported them to the police ..

So at the moment the Bank are dealing with them .. but because of his age he does not have a credit card, just Solo .. so I hope he get his money.

If not smalls claims here I come ...

(So to be so vague ... I am sure you all can guess why ....)
You have seven working days to return the item. You don't need any reason why. They should refund you the full amount for the item and postage.

Thats a lot more simple. Money claim online is your friend here.

I am always surprised that shops start trading like this and really don't bother to check or just completely ignore their responsibilities.
Yep you are 100% correct, however they refuse point blank to refund .. Trading Standards are going to prosecute them ..

At the appropriate point I will name and shame as they have done this to a few people !


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
andyuk911 said:
JustinP1 said:
andyuk911 said:
Not to hi-jack this thread ...

I am thinking of taking a shop to the small claims court for my son.

He bought an item online for a small amount of money, let say below £100 ...found it was 100% unsuitable.

I therefore took it back the following day after receipt and the shop refused the item as I was returning it in person ...

So I sent it back and guess what, they refused the item from the delivery company..

Long story short .. Trading Standards tell me they have been ignoring the Consumer Protection act 2000 Distance Selling regs for a while ..

In the end I took the item back, put it in the shop and took a few pixs ... at which they swore at me and went to pursue me ...

So I reported them to the police ..

So at the moment the Bank are dealing with them .. but because of his age he does not have a credit card, just Solo .. so I hope he get his money.

If not smalls claims here I come ...

(So to be so vague ... I am sure you all can guess why ....)
You have seven working days to return the item. You don't need any reason why. They should refund you the full amount for the item and postage.

Thats a lot more simple. Money claim online is your friend here.

I am always surprised that shops start trading like this and really don't bother to check or just completely ignore their responsibilities.
Yep you are 100% correct, however they refuse point blank to refund .. Trading Standards are going to prosecute them ..

At the appropriate point I will name and shame as they have done this to a few people !
Trading Standards may prosecute, but they may have informed you that they don't chase up case and solve them on your behalf. I would go full steam ahead with a 'Final Warning of the Intention of Immediate Legal Action' letter giving them seven days and a court summons.

They will probably pay up well before it gets to court, but even if not you will get a judgement in your favour and they will get a CCJ. Further to that if they still don't pay you can get the court's bailiffs to go to their shop and remove goods for auction on your behalf so you can get your money back!

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 4th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
He's 300 miles away so if we had to go to court, which court would it be? My local one would be sweet.
It would be his local court, unless you can provide a very good reason why it should not be. If you win, you can claim reasonable travel expenses which will be added to the debt.