Verbal contract - legal advice required.
Discussion
Need help here guys, we are needing 3 bathrooms completely refitted & we accepted a quote from a local bathroom company back in mid january.
The total cost of the works (supply & fit inc plastering, plumbing, tiling (but no tiles) was £36,000.
The owner of the firm wanted me to pay a 50% deposit, which i refused & we agreed on a £5,000 deposit, paid on January 16th. The owner told me he would get the formal contract to me within the week, & the wotks were written on to his planner commencing the 1st of may for a period of 7 weeks duration.
Other trades have been arranged to start after the bathrooms have been finished.
Over the last couple of months i have chased him several times for the contract & schedule of works, which has not been forthcoming & he has stopped returning my calls.
I finally get hold of him this week & get all manner of excuses why this has not been done, so i request the contract & schedule of works by the end of the week & mention that i would like him to supply police checks on the 2 chaps doing the work (they will have keys & unrestricted access to the entire house during the 7 weeks, while we are at work).
Today i recieve a letter saying that he cannot comply with the request for the police checks & has refunded my deposit.
Given that there are only 3 weeks until the works are due to begin, is there anything i can do to get recompense? A legal friend of mine has suggested that if i had cancelled the works with this notice, i would have lost my deposit (which i would expect) & that for the contractor to cancel he shhould be refunding the deposit plus a similar amount as compensation.
It was also mentioned that i should look for a new contractor to complete the work within the previously mentioned timescale & if this turns out to be more expensive due to the short notice, claim the diffrence back from the original contractor through the courts.
Does this sound reasonable?
The total cost of the works (supply & fit inc plastering, plumbing, tiling (but no tiles) was £36,000.
The owner of the firm wanted me to pay a 50% deposit, which i refused & we agreed on a £5,000 deposit, paid on January 16th. The owner told me he would get the formal contract to me within the week, & the wotks were written on to his planner commencing the 1st of may for a period of 7 weeks duration.
Other trades have been arranged to start after the bathrooms have been finished.
Over the last couple of months i have chased him several times for the contract & schedule of works, which has not been forthcoming & he has stopped returning my calls.
I finally get hold of him this week & get all manner of excuses why this has not been done, so i request the contract & schedule of works by the end of the week & mention that i would like him to supply police checks on the 2 chaps doing the work (they will have keys & unrestricted access to the entire house during the 7 weeks, while we are at work).
Today i recieve a letter saying that he cannot comply with the request for the police checks & has refunded my deposit.
Given that there are only 3 weeks until the works are due to begin, is there anything i can do to get recompense? A legal friend of mine has suggested that if i had cancelled the works with this notice, i would have lost my deposit (which i would expect) & that for the contractor to cancel he shhould be refunding the deposit plus a similar amount as compensation.
It was also mentioned that i should look for a new contractor to complete the work within the previously mentioned timescale & if this turns out to be more expensive due to the short notice, claim the diffrence back from the original contractor through the courts.
Does this sound reasonable?
You are lucky to get your deposit back to be honest.
You brought in conditions after agreeing the initial contract so you could have been deemed in breach of the contract and the builder could have sued you for loss of earnings and profit.
Looks like he was too busy t do the job so used your newly introduced condition as a way to get out.
You may have been better letting him continue to let you down right up until the day the works shold have started. then as mentioned you could have got someone else in and sued him for any extra incurred costs and inconvenience as well as the return of the deposit.
You brought in conditions after agreeing the initial contract so you could have been deemed in breach of the contract and the builder could have sued you for loss of earnings and profit.
Looks like he was too busy t do the job so used your newly introduced condition as a way to get out.
You may have been better letting him continue to let you down right up until the day the works shold have started. then as mentioned you could have got someone else in and sued him for any extra incurred costs and inconvenience as well as the return of the deposit.
Presumably the police checks were not part of the original contract, and therefore you were looking to change the terms. I'm guessing he could have said no, and carried on under the original agreement...
I'd chalk it down to experience and look for someone else.
The price you stated sounds very expensive, depending upon the fittings, so you may have had a lucky escape. However I guess your location might have an impact on that...although I reckon you could bring people & goods over from the mainland and still get it done for less.
I'd chalk it down to experience and look for someone else.
The price you stated sounds very expensive, depending upon the fittings, so you may have had a lucky escape. However I guess your location might have an impact on that...although I reckon you could bring people & goods over from the mainland and still get it done for less.
You need to distinguish between making a request for police records and cancelling the contract. When you made your request did you say that you would not wish to proceed if no Police records were forthcoming? If not your request is not unreasonable and it is him who has pulled out on you not the other way around. if this is the case then he is in breach of your agreement - evidenced by his letter returning the deposit and you can sue for your loss suffered as a result of his breach.
You will have an obligation to mitigate your loss, meaning that you cannot just go wild and incur costs with the hope of claiming it all from him.
You will have an obligation to mitigate your loss, meaning that you cannot just go wild and incur costs with the hope of claiming it all from him.
What has been said above is correct.
To be frank the problem with the deal is the 'verbal' nature.
I have been stung in the past so before over anything as a deposit it is only after I have seen and agreed to a written contract. No difference in legality of course, however at least both parties know where they stand.
My opinion is that what most likely has happened is that they have too much work on or more profitable work which is why they were putting off the subject of formalisation, and the 'police checks' issue they used as a scapegoat.
If your conversation was "Could I possibly ask that police checks are carried out on the workmen" then this is not a change of terms, it is just asking a question. However, if you said:
"I am not having anyone near my property with a criminal record, unless you can supply police checks for all of the workmen, the deal is off" then technically, it could be seen that it is actually you who has breached the contract.
If it is the former, and you want to chase this guy up, you will have to put forward your position in writing that your conversation was a request, not a requirement, and you want the works to go ahead as per your agreement. If he refuses, warn him that if he does not you will have to get the work done elsewhere and sue him if there is additional cost over his quote. You would then have to complete the works and sue him for the difference.
To be frank the problem with the deal is the 'verbal' nature.
I have been stung in the past so before over anything as a deposit it is only after I have seen and agreed to a written contract. No difference in legality of course, however at least both parties know where they stand.
My opinion is that what most likely has happened is that they have too much work on or more profitable work which is why they were putting off the subject of formalisation, and the 'police checks' issue they used as a scapegoat.
If your conversation was "Could I possibly ask that police checks are carried out on the workmen" then this is not a change of terms, it is just asking a question. However, if you said:
"I am not having anyone near my property with a criminal record, unless you can supply police checks for all of the workmen, the deal is off" then technically, it could be seen that it is actually you who has breached the contract.
If it is the former, and you want to chase this guy up, you will have to put forward your position in writing that your conversation was a request, not a requirement, and you want the works to go ahead as per your agreement. If he refuses, warn him that if he does not you will have to get the work done elsewhere and sue him if there is additional cost over his quote. You would then have to complete the works and sue him for the difference.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



