Moneyclaim
Author
Discussion

gtitim

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
Lent someone some tools,and they have not returned them. They have moved house, refuse to answer my calls and clearly have no intention of returning them. The tools arent worth a fortune, maybe £150 or so, but thats £150 i dont have to replace tools with right now. The person is fully aware I want my tools back. I have given up phoning and texting as my calls are ignored and text not replied to. I was going to send a recorded letter to the person, but he is a postman, and the letter will inevitably be lost/ not signed for, so thats a waste of time.

I am thinking moneyclaim may be the way to go, as i shall claim for the cost of replacement tools, and it would be worth the £30 or so to get them a CCJ if they ignore it. Can anyone suggest any other ways to sort it ( cant send round the boys etc because of my job - would be sacked and prosecuted if i did)or has anyone had any experiences of moneyclaim ie is it worth it?

davido140

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
moneyclaim is great, very easy to use.

I've used it twice, both time the other party immediatly folded and gave me my money + costs.

First one was to reclaim bank charges, second was a deposit I left on a car with a private seller who then decided to sell it to someone else and keep my money.

For most people its easier to cave in and pay rather than fight (especially if they know they are in the wrong and just hoping to get away with it).

If the other party is a scumball chav then they probably dont care about a CCJ. But Im sure you wouldnt have lent your tools to a complete tool! smile

g_attrill

9,173 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
I would say send the letter anyway because should it go to court that is what they like to see, but use Special Delivery (add it to the costs) because Recorded is pretty much useless for proving service, and it's difficult for SD to "go missing".

Also MCOL is only £20 for claims < £300.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Saturday 5th April 2008
quotequote all
Keep a record of any attempts at communication, and send the letter, giving them a chance to reply (say, a week) before you proceed. It will make you look better in the eyes of the court, and less like you're wasting their time by using them as a first option.

I don't believe that they will rule against you if you don't, but you may not be able to get the other party to pay your court fees.

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
Could you use their car registration to query the (new) address?

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
polus said:
Could you use their car registration to query the (new) address?
You either need a 'bent coppa' or to be a clamping company to do that frown - Streaky

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
gtitim said:
Lent someone some tools,and they have not returned them. They have moved house, refuse to answer my calls and clearly have no intention of returning them. ... The person is fully aware I want my tools back.
It seems to me that, by the definitions in the Theft Act 1968, this is theft:

1. Basic definition of theft
(1) A person is guilty of theft if he dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it; and ‘theft’ and ‘steal’ shall be construed accordingly.

3. ‘Appropriates’
(1) Any assumption by a person of the rights of an owner amounts to an appropriation, and this includes, where he has come by the property (innocently or not) without stealing it, any later assumption of a right to it by keeping or dealing with it as owner.

Streaky
Streaky

mel

10,168 posts

306 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
Are you simple?

You know where he lives by the sounds of it, but you say you can't "send the boys round" I guess because you're a baby copper, well I hate to say it but if you haven't got the balls to go and knock on the guys door and say "can I have my tools back please" then you're in the wrong job.

gtitim

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
mel said:
Are you simple?

You know where he lives by the sounds of it, but you say you can't "send the boys round" I guess because you're a baby copper, well I hate to say it but if you haven't got the balls to go and knock on the guys door and say "can I have my tools back please" then you're in the wrong job.
I have the balls to go get my tools, and would have already gone round, but know if i go round there i will end up fighting and/or the other person will file a complaint. i am not going to end up risking my career for some tools. I will however, use whatever means i can within the law to recover my goods. Also, if i go round, he wont answer the door anyway. hes childish like that. So what other choices do i have but to use moneyclaim/court proceedings?

Edited by gtitim on Sunday 6th April 11:07

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
gtitim said:
mel said:
Are you simple?

You know where he lives by the sounds of it, but you say you can't "send the boys round" I guess because you're a baby copper, well I hate to say it but if you haven't got the balls to go and knock on the guys door and say "can I have my tools back please" then you're in the wrong job.
I have the balls to go get my tools, and would have already gone round, but know if i go round there i will end up fighting and/or the other person will file a complaint. i am not going to end up risking my career for some tools. I will however, use whatever means i can within the law to recover my goods. Also, if i go round, he wont answer the door anyway. hes childish like that. So what other choices do i have but to use moneyclaim/court proceedings?

Edited by gtitim on Sunday 6th April 11:07
This is a first for SP&L - BiB asking the public what do do when someone has knicked *their* stuff!!!

I don't want to be harsh as I don't know how much 'training' you have had so far, but this is exactly the type of issue that you will be asked to advise upon, and more importantly *deal with* on behalf of a member of the public.

If you do not think that you could knock on his door and speak to him in a fashion which will not mean that you will end up in a fight, then you have a long way to go IMHO.

Take your balls in your hands, and go to speak to him. If there is no answer write a note saying, "I don't want to report this as theft or take you to court, I just want my tools back please." and arrange a method of doing this. You are going to have to write to him anyway to warn him of legal action, but you may as well avoid all this by going there.

If you think he will make a complaint against you if you go there, what do you think he will do when he has court papers in his hands?


gtitim

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
This is a first for SP&L - BiB asking the public what do do when someone has knicked *their* stuff!!!

I don't want to be harsh as I don't know how much 'training' you have had so far, but this is exactly the type of issue that you will be asked to advise upon, and more importantly *deal with* on behalf of a member of the public.

If you do not think that you could knock on his door and speak to him in a fashion which will not mean that you will end up in a fight, then you have a long way to go IMHO.

Take your balls in your hands, and go to speak to him. If there is no answer write a note saying, "I don't want to report this as theft or take you to court, I just want my tools back please." and arrange a method of doing this. You are going to have to write to him anyway to warn him of legal action, but you may as well avoid all this by going there.

If you think he will make a complaint against you if you go there, what do you think he will do when he has court papers in his hands?
Only in training at the moment, so not fully aware of all laws/grounds etc. Will not risk my career over this. Shall be writing a letter, sending by special delivery tomorrow and wait and see. If no joy then shall proceed with moneyclaim. I am not one to avoid confrontation, but know that he would take a swing just to provoke me, or would say i took a swing even if i didnt. by not going there, i prevent any accusations being made.

T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
I understand your reasons about not wanting to knock his door to a degree, but can you not ask a few of your work mates to go and ask about the theft of your goods?

if this guy knows your job, and is still happy to keep your tools, then i have little faith a ccj or letter will upset him sorry

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
Have you tried involving the police? wink

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
way it seems to me is that a trainee copper is not sure what to do about theft, not sure if it is worth going to the place or not sure if it is worth reporting to his boss's

I knew they were cutting down on the training to save costs, but if this is the result, might as well use CPO's who might have a clue....

Not a great advertisement for confidence in the police

gtitim

Original Poster:

1,633 posts

232 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
Scraggles said:
way it seems to me is that a trainee copper is not sure what to do about theft, not sure if it is worth going to the place or not sure if it is worth reporting to his boss's

I knew they were cutting down on the training to save costs, but if this is the result, might as well use CPO's who might have a clue....

Not a great advertisement for confidence in the police
Ok, I am in training, and will be covering the law and all aspects of what is/ isnt a theft sometime in the summer. Having only just joined, I dont know every law. Joining doesnt mean swallowing the law books and suddenly knowing it all!

If i go in person to the door, he either will ignore it or come out, take a swing or provoke me into a fight. He will then complain to the police that an off duty officer has harrassed him/assaulted him. That is NOT what i need during training. Until Streaky posted that it WAS theft, I didn't think it was, as I had willingly let him have the tools, hence considering using moneyclaim/small claims. I would rather deal with thismyself through small claims than via the police, as it will be hassle I can do without, and moneyclaim is just a case of filling a form in.

T_Pot

2,542 posts

228 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
I think people are being a little harsh here, how many of us knew everything when we started our jobs, if he was a qualified policeman, id agree totally, but they guy is new in the job, have some consideration guys.


Toni896

2,188 posts

257 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
gtitim, I dont know how the police do their training however before you do anything else, go see your training officer or station mate and get some advice.

they will know how much or how little(depending on your service ) you know and should help you out on the best course of action.

nad your right if you know it will get nasty no point ruining your career !


Jasandjules

72,687 posts

260 months

Sunday 6th April 2008
quotequote all
I'd speak to one of your training officers.. The point at which lending becomes theft is a murky one, but I'm willing to bet if a uniform turned up at his door suggesting he'd nicked some tools, you'd get them back pretty damn soon...

Failing that, it's a MCOL. It's not hard to do, and you can add the charge of the proceedings on to the claim, and add interest too.

mel

10,168 posts

306 months

Monday 7th April 2008
quotequote all
I don't think we're being harsh at all, it's frankly pathetic and I'm totally at a loss to believe that someone who can't handle a situation like this has even been accepted to join the police.

To say "he will provoke me into a fight" jesus H christ what is that all about! It's what half the town centre is trying to do to the BiB on an average saturday night FFS, if you can't keep your composure and remain calm in the face of provocation then you're doomed. If you're that worried take a friend as an independant witness, better still make it one of the other kids from plod school.

I'm truely scared by the quality of up and coming police officers if you are an example, did you not do any "role play" exercises during the selection process? Do you not sit around in class rooms discussing how to deal with difficult situations? If so then you must be a pretty inactive student by the sounds of it. I mean for gods sack we're talking about someone who I assume was a "mate" (if not why lend the tools in the first place) You need to brush up on communication skills and learn how to talk to people to get required results PDQ, and if you're worried about unsubstantiated compaints at this stage in your career you'd better get used to them as you'll have plenty to come.

Just deal with it like a man and go and ask for your tools back, and please don't ask your "training officer" for "advice" because frankly if I was in his boots and you asked me I'd despair, over something so trivial to show that you can't handle it and need help would mark you down as a waste of space and destined for either a well deserved shoeing or a senior rank, either way I wouldn't want such an incopetant working anywhere near me.