Proof of no prior opinion
Discussion
Driving along, I saw a speed trap in the distance. Slowed down to 20 mph (30 zone) to allow for the worst possible slip / operator errors to stay within the 30 limit. To my suprise, he still lifted the laser gun and aimed at my car, which to me proved that it was impossible that he was forming prior opinion as I was doing 20 mph on the GPS (no other cars around me).
This made me think - if I had my video camera in the car, and was filming the GPS reading as well as the camera operator, would that be acceptable as proof for those unlucky enough to be caught, that the operator was just sweeping every car rather then forming an opinion?
This made me think - if I had my video camera in the car, and was filming the GPS reading as well as the camera operator, would that be acceptable as proof for those unlucky enough to be caught, that the operator was just sweeping every car rather then forming an opinion?
I've already had dealings of this in court. It wouldn't matter, because the "Law" would still say that he wasn't targeting you indiscriminately and that he "believed" you "may have been" driving in excess of the limit. If you did take a video they'd then argue that you weren't in full control of your vehicle!
In a common sense world you would think that if the operator cannot distinguish from those cars who are speeding or not, then he cannot make an evidential standard prior opinion.
However, as justamin and others have found out, it wouldnt even matter if a third party have a video, the operator can be shown targeting numerous vehicles which are not speeding on the actual enforcement video!
To my eyes it's a farce. Somehow not to some courts though.
However, as justamin and others have found out, it wouldnt even matter if a third party have a video, the operator can be shown targeting numerous vehicles which are not speeding on the actual enforcement video!
To my eyes it's a farce. Somehow not to some courts though.
esselte said:
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
why waste his time then?
I can to the same evidential standard predict the toss of a coin. It's just when I get it wrong, I am 'just checking'...
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
Just to confirm: are you perfectly happy with every aspect of current UK speed enforcement? If you are (which you seem to be from your constant arguing with people here), it suggests to me that you are either anti-car or a beneficiary of cameras, because no remotely reasonable person could otherwise think that current practice is satisfactory.People being in favour of speed cameras in principle is one thing (misguided thought they are). People who insist on defending everything that the authorities are doing in relation to speed enforcement make me highly suspicious.
GPSHead said:
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
Just to confirm: are you perfectly happy with every aspect of current UK speed enforcement? If you are (which you seem to be from your constant arguing with people here), it suggests to me that you are either anti-car or a beneficiary of cameras, because no remotely reasonable person could otherwise think that current practice is satisfactory.People being in favour of speed cameras in principle is one thing (misguided thought they are). People who insist on defending everything that the authorities are doing in relation to speed enforcement make me highly suspicious.
Don't you think people can enjoy driving without exceeding speed limits or breaking other motoring laws ?
I have little or no time to do speed enforcement personally, but I have nothing against people who do. After all at the end of the day you shouldn't be speeding & if you are you're fair game to them that do.
Limiting the risk of prosecution for speeding isn't all that challenging, if you are so inclined to.
Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 6th April 22:36
I perceive it as offensive that if I am clearly NOT exceeding the limit, that someone is pointing a laser gun at me to check. That gives the impression you are doing something wrong whilst you are not.
As a side question, if these camera operators are civilians, how much "verbal" can you give them or do they have some sort of special protection? I limited myself to a couple of fingers on this occasion.
As a side question, if these camera operators are civilians, how much "verbal" can you give them or do they have some sort of special protection? I limited myself to a couple of fingers on this occasion.
esselte said:
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
why waste his time then?So, roadside copper thinks 'I reckon that car's doing about 45, what does the gun say? Oh right? Nearly 40, so I was a bit out. Lets see if I can be a bit more accurate next time.'
If you want good judgement, it takes experience to build it.
vonhosen said:
Why do you assume anti-car ?
I'm told that if you don't travel everywhere in excess of the speed limit, you hate cars and are an evil lentil munching cyclist 
wendyg said:
People on here are often citing the benefits of a policeman with discretion over a camera with none.
It really shows the true colours of the anti camera brigade when they're equally against any form of speed enforcement, human or not.thewurzel said:
vonhosen said:
Why do you assume anti-car ?
I'm told that if you don't travel everywhere in excess of the speed limit, you hate cars and are an evil lentil munching cyclist 
wendyg said:
People on here are often citing the benefits of a policeman with discretion over a camera with none.
It really shows the true colours of the anti camera brigade when they're equally against any form of speed enforcement, human or not.Ha-ha-ha-ha ha.
Sorry. My apologies. I've been back through your contributions on recent forums, and clearly you can read.
You have my sympathy though. It must be difficult to live with such a disability. Most people don't appreciate how hard it is to live in the modern world without the ability to understand basic scientific process, with it's demand for actual evidence.
It must also be incredibly frustrating to find that when you trying so hard to show people a clear cause and effect, such as speed and death, that these interfering 'scientists' can come along and show 15 or 20 other variables which muck up your results. They should be shot.
Edited by wendyg on Sunday 6th April 23:48
wendyg said:
esselte said:
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
why waste his time then?So, roadside copper thinks 'I reckon that car's doing about 45, what does the gun say? Oh right? Nearly 40, so I was a bit out. Lets see if I can be a bit more accurate next time.'
If you want good judgement, it takes experience to build it.
I understand that concept however statistically unlikely that the guy on this occasion was 'training' himself. However, this has nothing to do with whether he will let people off or not - those thresholds will probably be already set for him.
In practical terms, the 'personal testing' scenario from the evidence I have seen is unlikely. The tapes I have seen and heard of show that the choice of vehicles zapped was indiscriminate. The evidential standard is the opinion of excess speed, not a particular number. In practice, and in legal scenarios, despite this being the primary evidence even the most haphazard or unlikely ways of gaining this opinion are accepted.
So really, they don't need to train themselves, there is simply no motivation to. Secondly, what would happen if they did 'train themselves' at the start of a session and find that half the time they were wrong? Would they go back to the station, gun in hand? Would they admit to this in court if they were asked? This would in all honesty invalidate all of the evidence of that session, so why would they do it?
vonhosen said:
GPSHead said:
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
Just to confirm: are you perfectly happy with every aspect of current UK speed enforcement? If you are (which you seem to be from your constant arguing with people here), it suggests to me that you are either anti-car or a beneficiary of cameras, because no remotely reasonable person could otherwise think that current practice is satisfactory.People being in favour of speed cameras in principle is one thing (misguided thought they are). People who insist on defending everything that the authorities are doing in relation to speed enforcement make me highly suspicious.
Don't you think people can enjoy driving without exceeding speed limits or breaking other motoring laws ?
I have little or no time to do speed enforcement personally, but I have nothing against people who do. After all at the end of the day you shouldn't be speeding & if you are you're fair game to them that do.
Limiting the risk of prosecution for speeding isn't all that challenging, if you are so inclined to.
Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 6th April 22:36
People who enjoy 'making progress' are typically those who know how to limit the risk, which as you say isn't all that challenging, and I would agree.
It's the poor sods who aren't into 'making progress' who get caught buy vans doing 36 in a 30 etc.
A generalisation, but you get the jist!. And you see post after post on here of people being done for minor infringements, who I would guess have got away with the more enthusiatic interpretation of the speedo on numerous other occasions.
Speed cameras therefore don't appear to be catching the people the operators say they are targetted at, they do catch poor sods who will just pay up however.
JustinP1 said:
wendyg said:
esselte said:
herewego said:
Just because he speed checks your car doesn't mean he thinks you're speeding.
why waste his time then?So, roadside copper thinks 'I reckon that car's doing about 45, what does the gun say? Oh right? Nearly 40, so I was a bit out. Lets see if I can be a bit more accurate next time.'
If you want good judgement, it takes experience to build it.
In practical terms, the 'personal testing' scenario from the evidence I have seen is unlikely. The tapes I have seen and heard of show that the choice of vehicles zapped was indiscriminate. The evidential standard is the opinion of excess speed, not a particular number. In practice, and in legal scenarios, despite this being the primary evidence even the most haphazard or unlikely ways of gaining this opinion are accepted.
So really, they don't need to train themselves, there is simply no motivation to. Secondly, what would happen if they did 'train themselves' at the start of a session and find that half the time they were wrong? Would they go back to the station, gun in hand? Would they admit to this in court if they were asked? This would in all honesty invalidate all of the evidence of that session, so why would they do it?
Why would that situation have anything to do with discretion?
I only came up with idea, because I consider myself a person of integrity, and if that was my job, and I was stuck for a few hours in that situation, that's what I'd do.
You clearly have a soul of cynicism.
I wonder on which side everyone else would place themselves?
Edited by wendyg on Sunday 6th April 23:56
Edited by wendyg on Sunday 6th April 23:58
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



