HPI, FINANCE, INSURANCE
Author
Discussion

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
We did a deal last month and took a 57 reg Fiesta in part ex.

HPI'd the car and all came back clean. Vehicle had all docs.

We then "trade" car out to a main dealer about a week later. One week after that, they go to put vehicle on stocking loan. The company call back and say, "sorry, vehicle has finance on it".

Main dealer return car to us and get refund.

We call HPI and they confirm it now has finance............ It was taken out 08/03/2207 but the vehicle was registered on 03/11/2007???

It transpires that it was a replacement vehilce given to the owner by his insurance company as he had crashed his first car in the 1st 12 months of ownership.

It took Ford Credit Europe 4 months to place it on HPI and now they want the car back as the finance is in arrears.

They say it is not their fault as inasurance company took 4 months to tell them about new car.

Any advice guys?

JamesZS

541 posts

227 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Just to clarify... are you getting a refund for this?

Did you buy it outright/with a loan/ with finance?

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
JamesZS said:
Just to clarify... are you getting a refund for this?

Did you buy it outright/with a loan/ with finance?
We are a dealership.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
The Insurer should have informed the Dealer/Credit Co to swap the finance when they Total Lossed the car. If it didn't come up on the HPI check when they did, then how were they to know ? If they did, then they should not have.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Law students everywhere will be thanking you for this one smile interesting twist on the transfer of title who owns the car seminars you get when doing law I should think.

Any Lawyers want to kick in on this one smile
I did contract law at uni, and used to like this type of thing, but this looks a bit more complicated.

That said, the easy answer is the finance company wants it back, there is finance attached, but that doesnt help the OP.

You could try to put the blame on another party like HPI but I don't think they are to blame.

My two-penneth is that it is the finance companies responsibility to find out where their vested interests lie, not for the insurance company to tell them. A phone call at any time would have avoided all of this.


Just had a brainwave. If the car was taken as a part-ex, then this is part of the contract of sale of the other vehicle. If the other party have sold something which is not their to sell, then if the contract is void, at lest the OP could take action to mitigate some loss by getting the car back until they can arrange finance for the other part of what is owed.

I might have to think about that one more later though as supposed to be working....!

Exige46

318 posts

267 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Not a lawyer at all, but would have thought it quite simple. The chap (Mr A) who sold the dealership the Fiesta did not have title to the car, which was in fact owned by Ford Credit. Therefore the Fiesta should be returned to Ford Credit and Mr A will need to be sued for monies outstanding.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Exige46 said:
Not a lawyer at all, but would have thought it quite simple. The chap (Mr A) who sold the dealership the Fiesta did not have title to the car, which was in fact owned by Ford Credit. Therefore the Fiesta should be returned to Ford Credit and Mr A will need to be sued for monies outstanding.
That is an answer, but it might mean that the OP has to get what he is owed back at £10 a week.

The problem is that if he has a history of arrears then he might be spending a lot of time enforcing that too.

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Exige46 said:
Not a lawyer at all, but would have thought it quite simple. The chap (Mr A) who sold the dealership the Fiesta did not have title to the car, which was in fact owned by Ford Credit. Therefore the Fiesta should be returned to Ford Credit and Mr A will need to be sued for monies outstanding.
And I just let £6k wonder off down the road, NOT likely

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Just got off the Phone with Ford credit and they are releasing title!!


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
Just got off the Phone with Ford credit and they are releasing title!!
Great result.

I have heard this happen in another case too. They just come down heavy on the person who scammed them.

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
paoloh said:
Just got off the Phone with Ford credit and they are releasing title!!
Great result.

I have heard this happen in another case too. They just come down heavy on the person who scammed them.
Even though the guy has obviously commited fraud, the Police don't want to know....

paoloh

Original Poster:

8,617 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Exige46 said:
Not a lawyer at all, but would have thought it quite simple. The chap (Mr A) who sold the dealership the Fiesta did not have title to the car, which was in fact owned by Ford Credit. Therefore the Fiesta should be returned to Ford Credit and Mr A will need to be sued for monies outstanding.
That is of course the usual textbook answer however in this instance I think if it did ever come to a fight, it would fail the reasonabless test as the OP had done everything possible to ensure that the seller had good title to the car The finance company had failed to ensure that they had title to the vehicle in question (due to lack of awareness I agree) however that would I think compromise the finance companies rights (interesting that Ford Credit rolled on this so I suspect they may have been told the same) the odd reality here is that effectively they NEVER had title to THAT particular car as it was a replacement not the original car financed. Therefore at the time it was sold technically they didnt own it ergo tough as I see it.

I'm sure a lawyer will be along in amo to show how I will be wrong smile



Cheers
Hi Guam,

I quoted to Ford that they had not taken Diligent care of their goods. I had shown all diligence by performing industry standard checks. I think they knew that too and.......

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Exige46 said:
Not a lawyer at all, but would have thought it quite simple. The chap (Mr A) who sold the dealership the Fiesta did not have title to the car, which was in fact owned by Ford Credit. Therefore the Fiesta should be returned to Ford Credit and Mr A will need to be sued for monies outstanding.
That is of course the usual textbook answer however in this instance I think if it did ever come to a fight, it would fail the reasonabless test as the OP had done everything possible to ensure that the seller had good title to the car The finance company had failed to ensure that they had title to the vehicle in question (due to lack of awareness I agree) however that would I think compromise the finance companies rights (interesting that Ford Credit rolled on this so I suspect they may have been told the same) the odd reality here is that effectively they NEVER had title to THAT particular car as it was a replacement not the original car financed. Therefore at the time it was sold technically they didnt own it ergo tough as I see it.

I'm sure a lawyer will be along in amo to show how I will be wrong smile



Cheers
You are right.

There is case law with regard to the transfer of goods and when ownership is transferred. I think the test is whether the buyer bought in good faith and was diligent.

I have a feeling that the example refers to a painting about 100 years ago. Oh yes, and the common description of the 'rogue' - but then again they all do! My lecturer was entertaining in that he instead often referred to crims as 'scrotes'.