Automatic Speed Monitoring of police cars
Automatic Speed Monitoring of police cars
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
I know one or two esteemed bib on here have views about hidden cameras are good and all instances of speeding, ideally, should be prosecuted...

Well, I'm thinking that it would be setting a great example if the police used technology that exists today to prove how they drive about within the speed limit every mile they drive whilst not responding to an emergency.

The technology would obviously result in an automatic standard penalty for exceeding the speed limit and would demonstrate clearly that it is possible to (for example) overtake slow moving traffic safely without exceeding the limit. Also, merging and moving into traffic flow etc could all be demonstrated safely (ie, within the limit).

It's very hard for me to think of a reason why this shouldn't happen and very soon.

It would be applauded by the likes of Brake who have so far failed dismally to convince anyone of the dangers of exceeding the posted limit.

So how do we make this happen?

SM

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
It should be quite simple to do. GPS tracking on the car. But also include an input for when the car is responding to a call so speeding during these periods can be removed/re-classified.

Could produce some nice stats.

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
"Do as I say, don't do as I do" wink

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Munter said:
Could produce some nice stats.
And be educational too. For example, I'd like to see how to safely join a dual carriageway when there's a steady stream of trucks doing 55mph nose-to-tail. Police car approaching at 70mph up the slip road but at current course will fail to make it past the lead truck in time to join ahead.

I would tend to flex the old right foot a touch and speed up to join ahead of the convoy, but would like to see demonstrated the safety focussed "brake and barge into a gap that's not really there or slow right down even more to join behind the last truck" method.

If unmonitored I'd wager that most police would take the lazy, unsafe option that involves speeding rather than practice the above.

SM

marlinmunro

3,071 posts

236 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Tuscan Rat said:
supermono said:
I know one or two esteemed bib on here have views about hidden cameras are good and all instances of speeding, ideally, should be prosecuted...
I do not think you will find a Bib on here that thinks hidden cameras are good, and that all instances of speeding should be prosecuted.

You will find that the Bib on here feel that Inappropriate speeding should be prosecuted.


As for a device that measures my speed, it’s already in most Police vehicles. It’s the Black box Instant Data Recorder. Records everything I do. Its not checked everyday but they are dip sampled every now and again by DPS / IPCC. Also as a traffic car, I have a calibrated camera recording my speed that again the tapes are dip sampled by the above.

My question would be what tolerances would you give to Police officers ? Would they be the same as I and most Bib ( Not Scameras ) give to motorists ?
Proper Police men no bleeding cameras I remember those days well. Was pulled as a youngster and giving a proper talking too if I had been a bit heavy on the right foot. You know what it worked I had huge respect for those guys. Today I feel sorry for the police they are under so much pressure from the loony left and frankly nutters.

ps: a BiB with a TVR bloody fantastic biggrin

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Tuscan Rat said:
I do not think you will find a Bib on here that thinks hidden cameras are good,
Ahem:

in another thread on this forum vonhosen said:
I'd personally rather that people didn't know the locations, in fact they could hide them completely for all I care. I also don't care how many get caught either.
SM

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
You would know as he would be arguing every point with you smile

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Very sorry, SM, but I can't support you on this one. To be honest I'm not in the least bit bothered about police drivers speeding so long as it's safe, which is how it should be for everybody else, too.

We've already got far too much technology looking over our shoulder and being used to monitor and control what we do, rather than helping us.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

Sheriff JWPepper

3,851 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
EU_Foreigner said:
"Do as I say, don't do as I do" wink
To a certain extent that is true, the public do not have the need to exceed the limit. However the police do, there is the obvious need to respond to urgent incidents and also in order to stop a vehicle it is often necessary to catch up with a vehicle which may already be doing or exceeding the limit.



Edited by Sheriff JWPepper on Tuesday 8th April 10:53

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Sheriff JWPepper said:
EU_Foreigner said:
"Do as I say, don't do as I do" wink
To a certain extent that is true, the public do not have the need to exceed the limit. However the police do, there is the obvious need to respond to urgent incidents and also in order to stop a vehicle it is often necessary to catch up with a vehicle which may be already be doing or exceeding the limit.
In any instance where the police need to exceed the speed limit, I presume the lights and or siren need to be used. When these are turned on could be recorded. Then we could remove those "responding to call" periods. And see how much speed limit breaking go's on outside permissable periods.

Sheriff JWPepper

3,851 posts

235 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Blues & sirens not always used or necessary. In fact they can be counter productive as other drivers can panic and do something stupid.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Ah. In which case my whole device falls apart like the chocolate bunny I have just eaten. lick

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Well this is strange.

"BRAKE", that mad Welshman and actually pretty much everyone in the public eye; two of my local "safety" camera people and even the famous road safety expert (and convicted drunk driver) Alisdair Stewart was on TV the other day pointing out that when somebody was "speeding" they automatically had an accident and went on to show the footage (ok so they went through a red light and hit someone coming through the opposite green light, but he pointed out that speeding caused it)...

Why doesn't anyone in power tell these people they're wrong if they disagree?

They'd sure think fitting automatic devices as described would tip the overall balance towards "safe" especially when they consider the "keep to the speed limit" message it'd send out. I mean if the police are doing it, it must be right.

I should ask these peole their views...

SM

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
We have live tracking for all our vehicles.

In the backs of our cars we have a "black box" thing that records speed and position data, also another one that transmitts this to control room. It will tell them our position on a map as well as speed. All this is recorded.

However it can only be used for internal investigations as i dont think its evidential.

Also all traffic cars have video with speed shown on the tape so its all there to be seen for all marked and un marked police vehicles.

Derek Smith

50,027 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
We had three prisoners in for assault on a female police office on a train where she was stripped to the waist and her clothes strewn across the tracks. Four of the group ran off.

None of the prisoners were saying anything despite there being sufficient evidence to charge. Whilst I was getting my no comments a PC came into my interview room looking pleased with himself.

When I told him I was getting nowehere (not perhaps in those identical words) he laughed and said his chap was "singing". This generated a contemptuous retort from my chap. The PC then read out a name from the statment he had in his hand, saying that his mate had put them all away. This shut my bloke up. Then the PC put another name forward and my bloke's face fell. Suddenly twigging what was going on (I was, I must admit, the the quickest on the uptake sometimes) I said to the PC: "OK, Dave, stop there. Let's give my bloke a chance to say something. If he gives us the other two names, then we'll go easy on him."

My bloke then made a full and frank, giving the names of all four additional offenders. I then photcopied my statement and gave it to the other two interviewing officers in their rooms.

The suggestion from the PC that he'd got two of the names was pure fabrication. He'd got a couple of probables from the collator and then just took a chance.

When we put our case (all seven) before a DS, a real good bloke, he was furious. He considered our tactics to be dishonest. He reckoned that if offenders could not trust the police to be upfront then we would no longer be working with the public but against it.

I was a bit put out, thinking that I'd be given a ticker-tape welcome to the court but after a bit of thought I eventually understood where he was coming from. Police must be honest and straightforward. Hiding is against all the historic princles of the service. Gatsos are ok, hidden cameras are dishonest.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
I know one or two esteemed bib on here have views about hidden cameras are good and all instances of speeding, ideally, should be prosecuted...

Well, I'm thinking that it would be setting a great example if the police used technology that exists today to prove how they drive about within the speed limit every mile they drive whilst not responding to an emergency.

The technology would obviously result in an automatic standard penalty for exceeding the speed limit and would demonstrate clearly that it is possible to (for example) overtake slow moving traffic safely without exceeding the limit. Also, merging and moving into traffic flow etc could all be demonstrated safely (ie, within the limit).

It's very hard for me to think of a reason why this shouldn't happen and very soon.

It would be applauded by the likes of Brake who have so far failed dismally to convince anyone of the dangers of exceeding the posted limit.

So how do we make this happen?

SM
They are exempt from the limit for a Police purpose (where adherence to that limit would hinder that purpose) , the exemption says nothing about it having to be an emergency.

I did say I'd rather cameras are hidden, but I didn't say that I would like all minor transgressions to be prosecuted.

Police vehicles already have GPS tracking & data recorders on the vehicles, let the public have them too. smile

Edited by vonhosen on Tuesday 8th April 16:45

Skodaku

1,805 posts

250 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
How about leaving the BiB alone - to get on with their job - and putting the kit into Scameravans and the vehicles driven by their operators, (non-BiB) ? Could be interesting.

marlinmunro

3,071 posts

236 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Vanhosen quote:

"I did say I'd rather cameras are hidden, but I didn't say that I would like all minor transgressions to be prosecuted. "

Well that really is the crux of the matter, they are! and every day someone gets a speeding ticket for very small transgressions. Hence the anger. There is no thought into road safety, its all a numbers game now rolleyes

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
supermono said:
I know one or two esteemed bib on here have views about hidden cameras are good and all instances of speeding, ideally, should be prosecuted...

Well, I'm thinking that it would be setting a great example if the police used technology that exists today to prove how they drive about within the speed limit every mile they drive whilst not responding to an emergency.

The technology would obviously result in an automatic standard penalty for exceeding the speed limit and would demonstrate clearly that it is possible to (for example) overtake slow moving traffic safely without exceeding the limit. Also, merging and moving into traffic flow etc could all be demonstrated safely (ie, within the limit).

It's very hard for me to think of a reason why this shouldn't happen and very soon.

It would be applauded by the likes of Brake who have so far failed dismally to convince anyone of the dangers of exceeding the posted limit.

So how do we make this happen?

SM
They are exempt from the limit for a Police purpose (where adherence to that limit would hinder that purpose) , the exemption says nothing about it having to be an emergency.

I did say I'd rather cameras are hidden, but I didn't say that I would like all minor transgressions to be prosecuted.

Police vehicles already have GPS tracking & data recorders on the vehicles, let the public have them too. smile

Edited by vonhosen on Tuesday 8th April 16:45
Thank you for the kind offer, Von, but no, no, a thousand times, no!!

Best wishes all,
Dave.

Greendubber

15,389 posts

234 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Our radio's are now linked to the mapping system we use in the control room, its only a matter of time before someone works out distance over time etc to see if someone is driving beyond their grade.